Human rights and judicial reform activists yesterday accused the High Court of bias after the latest ruling against three defendants in a combined case involving two murders.
The Judicial Reform Foundation and other groups said the case was based on disputed confessions, parts of which were extracted through torture.
In 1987, insurance agent Ko Hung Yu-lan (柯洪玉蘭) and a child, Lu Cheng (陸正), were kidnapped and murdered separately in Hsinchu.
Chiou Ho-shun (邱和順), Lin Kun-ming (林坤明) and Wu Shu-chen (吳淑貞) were arrested along with another nine suspects and soon confessed during police questioning, which led to their prosecution.
Twenty-two years later, their sentences have yet to be finalized in what is Taiwan’s longest-running criminal proceedings. In 11 trials, Chiou has been sentenced to death and Lin and Wu sentenced to prison, with the latest ruling handed down last month.
The three have appealed repeatedly based in part on the police’s use of torture.
The High Court has handed down convictions each time, despite recognizing that the torture took place. The Supreme Court has consistently rejected the High Court’s rulings.
“It seems that our judges consider the defendants guilty until proven innocent,” said Wellington Koo (顧立雄), an attorney and executive member of the Taiwan Association for Human Rights. “It seems once they get a confession from one or some of the defendants, [the defendants] cannot get [cleared].”
Koo said that during the legal process for the three of the 12 defendants whose cases are still at court, the court revised the confessions several times and overlooked contradictory testimonies.
In the case of Ko Hung, the court never looked into the differences in testimony concerning what happened after she was kidnapped and how she was killed, the activists said in a joint statement.
The court did not clarify why several relatives of Ko Hung testified that they saw her in the evening on the day she was kidnapped, while the defendants said they had kidnapped her in the early afternoon.
In the case of Lu, when seven fingerprints on a piece of evidence did not match any of the defendants, the court ruling only said the defendants left no fingerprints. The ruling did not explain whose fingerprints were found on the evidence, the statement said.
The statement also mentioned phone calls to Lu’s parents asking for ransom that the defendants were said to have made.
“It [the ruling] failed to explain why the analysis of voiceprints from 13 calls asking for ransom did not match the voiceprints of any of the defendants,” the statement said.
Investigations by the Control Yuan and the judiciary have found that the defendants were tortured.
“Torture was clearly recorded during police questioning and the officials involved were impeached by the Control Yuan, while officers involved in the torture were found guilty by the court and sentenced to prison,” Taiwan Alliance to End the Death Penalty executive director Lin Hsin-yi (林欣怡) said. “Yet the Court only deleted the part of the confessions that were clearly the result of torture, while keeping other parts.”
Judicial Reform Foundation executive director Lin Feng-jeng (林峰正) said the detention system should be reformed.
“The defendants have been detained for 22 years,” Lin Feng-jeng said. “Whether they’re proven innocent or guilty, they will have to fight another battle to get compensation.”
“I think there should be a regulation allowing defendants to be freed after a certain number of years if the court is incapable of proving them guilty,” he said.
Kao Yung-cheng (高涌誠), deputy convener of the alliance and a lawyer, said: “Even a country like Myanmar has a rule that no one can be detained for more than five years before a final verdict is handed down.”
“We’re behind even an authoritarian state in this respect,” Kao said.
Kao said this may have to do with the judiciary’s culture of seniority: “It’s a tradition to respect those who are more senior ... So of course, no judge is brave enough to overturn a ruling by their seniors.”
PIVOTAL ROLE: Taiwan’s importance in the global chip supply chain can be bolstered by domestic equipment manufacturing, President Tsai Ing-wen said Efforts must be made to better secure Taiwan’s place in the global supply chain by localizing production of equipment and facilities used by the semiconductor industry, President Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) said yesterday. Tsai discussed the issue during a meeting with representatives from the Taiwan Electronic Equipment Industry Association at the Presidential Office in Taipei. Product shortages throughout the COVID-19 pandemic — particularly of automotive chips — highlighted the pivotal role of Taiwan in the global supply chain, she said. Tsai thanked the association for cooperating with the government on the shared goal of localizing production of important semiconductor industry equipment.
Without completed infrastructure and training, the expedited sale of new F-16s from the US could become a burden rather than a help, a military official said yesterday. Reuters on Thursday last week reported that Washington is looking to accelerate the delivery of 66 new F-16C/D Block 70 aircraft in response to what it sees as increasing intimidation by Beijing. Under the terms of the original US$8 billion deal signed in 2019, the US is expected to deliver a single-seater and double-seater for testing next year, then deliver the 66 new aircraft in batches of four or five from 2024 to 2026. The officials
TRACING UNDER WAY: The CECC has identified six transmission chains among 25 recently confirmed COVID-19 cases, including those linked to a restaurant and a bank The Central Epidemic Command Center (CECC) yesterday reported 54 new COVID-19 infections — 44 imported and 10 local — and identified six transmission chains among local cases. Minister of Health and Welfare Chen Shih-chung (陳時中), who heads the center, said the imported cases are 18 who tested positive upon arrival at the airport and 26 who tested positive during quarantine. Of the local cases, seven are associated with a cluster infection at a Tasty Steak (西堤牛排) outlet in Taoyuan’s Zhongli District (中壢), one is linked to a family of four with COVID-19 reported on Monday, one is a family member of an
BILINGUAL NATION 2030: Those interested can apply online, while recruitment would continue until all of the positions are filled, the Ministry of Education said The recruitment of foreign English teachers for elementary and junior-high schools would be expanded in the 2022-2023 school year as part of Taiwan’s efforts to become a bilingual country, the Ministry of Education (MOE) said yesterday. In a statement, the ministry said that it has since 2004 hired 81 foreign nationals per year to teach English in 16 smaller counties and cities to build a better English-learning environment for students. However, for the 2022-2023 school year, the number of foreign English teachers recruited would increase to 531, with some of them to be posted to Taipei, New Taipei City, Taoyuan, Taichung, Tainan
RSS