Attorneys for The Journalist magazine yesterday tried to persuade Supreme Court judges that the Constitution covers both criminal and civil cases, while Vice Presi-dent Annette Lu's (
To decide whether the verdict of the libel suit brought by Lu against The Journalist should be upheld or the Taiwan High Court should rehear it, the Supreme Court's Civil Department yesterday held a debate for the two sides' lawyers to defend their arguments and try to persuade five Supreme Court Judges -- Lin Chi-fu (
PHOTO: TAIPEI NEWS PHOTOGRAPHER ASSOCIATION
Lu sued the magazine for publishing a story in November 2000 that said she had called its editor-in-chief to spread a rumor that President Chen Shui-bian (陳水扁) was having an affair with one of his aides.
The judges did not summon Lu or any of the defendants, but the magazine's president, Wang Chien-chuang (
Lu's five attorneys are all familiar faces who have frequently defended the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) and its members, including Wellington Koo (
Koo and Hung are also repre-senting the DPP in the lawsuit brought by the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT)-People First Party alliance requesting a recount of the March 20 election ballots.
The Journalist was represented by Lo Ming-tung (
Lo said that Articles 11 and 22 of the Constitution should cover the case and that was why the magazine decided to appeal the verdict.
Article 11 states, "The people shall have freedom of speech, teaching, writing and publication."
Article 22 says, "All other freedoms and rights of the people that are not detrimental to social order or public welfare shall be guaranteed under the Constitution."
"Reporters are responsible for reporting, not investigating," Lo said.
Lo also declared: "It is impossible for reporters to come up with `100 percent accurate' stories."
"The plaintiff's civil claim could sink the entire magazine since it is quite impossible for it to afford the claim," he said.
In response to Lo's arguments, Koo said his client's bottom line was the demand for an apology.
"Our major argument is to ask for a proper apology. That is all," Koo said.
"We know that the defendants may not be able afford so much, but the second verdict by the high court has marginalized the penalty, did it not? We are merely requesting the defendants to make it up to Lu for the damage they have done," he said.
The debate lasted nearly two and a half hours, but the atmosphere was calm.
Lin, the presiding judge, said that a decision would be announced tomorrow at 10am.
According to Lu's original civil claim, which was upheld by the district court, the defendants -- Wang, editor-in-chief Yang Chao (
The cost of printing such clarifications has been estimated at NT$180 million.
The Taiwan High Court reduced the penalty and ruled that the defendants only needed to buy half-page ads on the front pages of four major Chinese-language newspapers to publish a clarification for one day. That would cost about NT$3.86 million.
The court ruled the clarification did not have to be aired over the radio and TV for three days, taking into account the defendants' in- ability to pay for such a large amount of air time.
Taiwan would benefit from more integrated military strategies and deployments if the US and its allies treat the East China Sea, the Taiwan Strait and the South China Sea as a “single theater of operations,” a Taiwanese military expert said yesterday. Shen Ming-shih (沈明室), a researcher at the Institute for National Defense and Security Research, said he made the assessment after two Japanese military experts warned of emerging threats from China based on a drill conducted this month by the Chinese People’s Liberation Army’s (PLA) Eastern Theater Command. Japan Institute for National Fundamentals researcher Maki Nakagawa said the drill differed from the
A fugitive in a suspected cosmetic surgery fraud case today returned to Taiwan from Canada, after being wanted for six years. Internet celebrity Su Chen-tuan (蘇陳端), known as Lady Nai Nai (貴婦奈奈), and her former boyfriend, plastic surgeon Paul Huang (黃博健), allegedly defrauded clients and friends of about NT$1 billion (US$30.66 million). Su was put on a wanted list in 2019 when she lived in Toronto, Canada, after failing to respond to subpoenas and arrest warrants from the Taipei District Prosecutors’ Office. Su arrived at Taiwan Taoyuan International Airport at 5am today on an EVA Air flight accompanied by a
A 79-year-old woman died today after being struck by a train at a level crossing in Taoyuan, police said. The woman, identified by her surname Wang (王), crossed the tracks even though the barriers were down in Jhongli District’s (中壢) Neili (內壢) area, the Taoyuan Branch of the Railway Police Bureau said. Surveillance footage showed that the railway barriers were lowered when Wang entered the crossing, but why she ventured onto the track remains under investigation, the police said. Police said they received a report of an incident at 6:41am involving local train No. 2133 that was heading from Keelung to Chiayi City. Investigators
The Keelung District Prosecutors’ Office today requested that a court detain three individuals, including Keelung Department of Civil Affairs Director Chang Yuan-hsiang (張淵翔), in connection with an investigation into forged signatures used in recall campaigns. Chang is suspected of accessing a household registration system to assist with recall campaigns targeting Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) city councilors Cheng Wen-ting (鄭文婷) and Jiho Chang (張之豪), prosecutors said. Prosecutors yesterday directed investigators to search six locations, including the Chinese Nationalist Party’s (KMT) Keelung office and the residences of several recall campaign leaders. The recall campaign leaders, including Chi Wen-chuan (紀文荃), Yu Cheng-i (游正義) and Hsu Shao-yeh
RSS