US analysts called on Taiwan to base its territorial claims in the South China Sea on international law and emphasized the nation’s likely role as a “balancer” in the US’ “pivot” toward Asia when facing Chinese hegemony, while Taiwanese academics said US policies regarding Taiwan and the pivot are “contradictory,” and its close alliance with China “blind” and naive.
At an international symposium titled “US presence in Asia and Regional Peace and Security” organized by the Taiwan National Security Institute in Taipei yesterday, former American Institute in Taiwan (AIT) director William Stanton called on the nation to abandon the “nine-dash line” according to which Taiwan claims the entire South China Sea. China also uses the nine-dash line for its territorial claims in the region.
“Taiwan has already provided an ideal model of how the Asian neighbors should interact in their negotiated settlements of fishing disputes with Japan and the Philippines. Taiwan should again lead the way by basing its claims to South China Sea territories on international law rather than on the Republic of China’s unexplained 1947 nine-dash map [published when the Republic of China had not yet retreated to Taiwan],” Stanton said.
Photo: Wang Min-wei, Taipei Times
The 1982 UN Convention on the Law of the Sea is “a reasonable basis that everybody agrees on, except for China and Taiwan. The nine-dash line is [something] somebody sketched out and just said: It’s all ours. Taiwan, not a member of the UN, always says how it abides by international conventions,” he added. “I would like to see Taiwan again get out front and say, ‘we’re abiding by international law.’ And I don’t think from a practical point of view it would affect [its] interests.”
When told that such a change might require an amendment to the Constitution, Stanton acknowledged the difficulty, but said it is his job as a critic to say that this is what Taiwan ought to do.
“Whether practically you can do it or not is a different question,” he added.
A former US Department of State official said at the symposium that it would leave the US and other Asian neighbors wondering whether there exists “a potential Beijing-Taipei maritime axis” after “the Taipei government repeatedly supported Beijing” throughout the frictions between China and South East Asian countries over the South China Sea by claiming that the islands are “Chinese.”
“It doesn’t take a lot of sophisticated analysis to conclude that, if Taiwan is not part of the ‘pivot,’ then the ‘pivot’ will not work,” said John Tkacik, former Chief of China Analysis in the department’s Bureau of Intelligence and Research.
Tkacik said that to be successful, the US’ pivot should be a balancing strategy against an adversary that has “hegemonic aspirations.”
Both US specialists underscored Taiwan’s strategic role in the US pivot, which is “principally about China.”
As “America’s pivot presupposed solid encouragement and military/naval coordination with its partners in Asia,” Washington could not afford to disregard contributions from Taiwan, one of its security partners in Asia, when “China’s obvious strategy now is to undermine America’s alliances across Asia,” Tkacik said.
Stanton, while saying that views of the nation as “uniquely poised to be an important partner in the security component of [the pivot]” are accurate, added that the ideas are “unlikely to be implemented given current self-imposed constraints in both Taiwan and the US.”
Taiwanese academics expressed concern over the “self-imposed constraints.”
Former National Security Council deputy secretary-general Parris Chang (張旭成) said the US has failed to distinguish between friends and enemies and ignored that the aim of the pivot is to counter China with an alliance between the US and Asian partners.
“[The US government] has blindly endorsed the implementation of Chinese President Xi Jinping’s (習近平) ‘new model of great powers relations,’ and has turned a blind eye to Beijing’s intention to change the Asia-Pacific order and rules of the game,” Chang said. “The US has no understanding of Chinese leaders’ idea of a great power and strategic thinking.”
Chang also added that President Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九) administration’s pro-China stance has led to his “lack of care for Taiwan’s defense.”
Taiwan Thinktank deputy executive director Lai I-chung (賴怡忠) said the US’ call for Taiwan to give up its South China Sea claims on the one hand and its insistence on the “one China” policy on the other is “contradictory.”
“China’s territorial claims in the East and South China seas are based on its claims to own Taiwan. If China does not own Taiwan, its claims over the Diaoyutai (釣魚台) and Spratly (Nansha, 南沙群島) island chains would be untenable,” Lai said, adding that the US’ “one China” policy, its warning against Taiwan antagonizing Beijing and its hesitation to integrate Taiwan into a China free economic network have all pushed the nation away from its proclaimed rebalancing strategy.
Soochow University political science associate professor Lo Chih-cheng (羅致政) said the US has been encouraging Taipei’s economic dependence on China, but now, as former US secretary of state Hillary Rodham Clinton said, sees that the economic dependence might cost the nation its political independence.
A magnitude 7.0 earthquake struck off Yilan at 11:05pm yesterday, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said. The epicenter was located at sea, about 32.3km east of Yilan County Hall, at a depth of 72.8km, CWA data showed There were no immediate reports of damage. The intensity of the quake, which gauges the actual effect of a seismic event, measured 4 in Yilan County area on Taiwan’s seven-tier intensity scale, the data showed. It measured 4 in other parts of eastern, northern and central Taiwan as well as Tainan, and 3 in Kaohsiung and Pingtung County, and 2 in Lienchiang and Penghu counties and 1
FOREIGN INTERFERENCE: Beijing would likely intensify public opinion warfare in next year’s local elections to prevent Lai from getting re-elected, the ‘Yomiuri Shimbun’ said Internal documents from a Chinese artificial intelligence (AI) company indicated that China has been using the technology to intervene in foreign elections, including propaganda targeting Taiwan’s local elections next year and presidential elections in 2028, a Japanese newspaper reported yesterday. The Institute of National Security of Vanderbilt University obtained nearly 400 pages of documents from GoLaxy, a company with ties to the Chinese government, and found evidence that it had apparently deployed sophisticated, AI-driven propaganda campaigns in Hong Kong and Taiwan to shape public opinion, the Yomiuri Shimbun reported. GoLaxy provides insights, situation analysis and public opinion-shaping technology by conducting network surveillance
‘POLITICAL GAME’: DPP lawmakers said the motion would not meet the legislative threshold needed, and accused the KMT and the TPP of trivializing the Constitution The Legislative Yuan yesterday approved a motion to initiate impeachment proceedings against President William Lai (賴清德), saying he had undermined Taiwan’s constitutional order and democracy. The motion was approved 61-50 by lawmakers from the main opposition Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and the smaller Taiwan People’s Party (TPP), who together hold a legislative majority. Under the motion, a roll call vote for impeachment would be held on May 19 next year, after various hearings are held and Lai is given the chance to defend himself. The move came after Lai on Monday last week did not promulgate an amendment passed by the legislature that
AFTERMATH: The Taipei City Government said it received 39 minor incident reports including gas leaks, water leaks and outages, and a damaged traffic signal A magnitude 7.0 earthquake struck off Taiwan’s northeastern coast late on Saturday, producing only two major aftershocks as of yesterday noon, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said. The limited aftershocks contrast with last year’s major earthquake in Hualien County, as Saturday’s earthquake occurred at a greater depth in a subduction zone. Saturday’s earthquake struck at 11:05pm, with its hypocenter about 32.3km east of Yilan County Hall, at a depth of 72.8km. Shaking was felt in 17 administrative regions north of Tainan and in eastern Taiwan, reaching intensity level 4 on Taiwan’s seven-tier seismic scale, the CWA said. In Hualien, the
RSS