Worst of all, they rustle together a good song concept only to waste it. Your Girlfriend Might Be a Cop: The eye falls on that title and doesn’t want to leave. The lyrics make it halfway there. (“She looks at me like a thief/ Like she knows all my crimes and can bust me any time.”) But the song needs more form than the five minutes it seems to have taken to make it. No, four.
— Ben Ratliff, NY Times News Service