Tue, Oct 16, 2012 - Page 12 News List

Book review: Political Will and Common Sense

By Bradley Winterton  /  Contributing reporter

Political Will and Common Sense, By Shih Ming-te

When I interviewed Shih Ming-te (施明德) in 2002, on the occasion of his candidacy for Mayor of Kaohsiung, what struck me most was the security. I went along with a translator and outside a building in central Taipei we were met by a very muscular security guard; there was another one by the entrance to the apartment, which was accessed by a narrow private staircase.

Shih served 25 years as a political prisoner in Taiwan, and for a long time was force-fed daily by a tube to his stomach painfully inserted through his nose. He must be as aware as anyone alive that he’s living in a land where political violence is a recent memory.

Shih’s always been in essence a radical maverick. He was first imprisoned at the age of 21 for espousing Taiwanese independence, and for this crime remained locked up for 15 years. Then he was one of the leaders of the 1979 Kaohsiung Incident at which the DPP was essentially founded, for which he suffered another 10 years’ incarceration. But he’s never occupied major office under a DPP government (apart from being party chairman), and in 2006 led the Red Shirt Movement protesting against the alleged corruption of his former colleague, then-president Chen Shui-bian (陳水扁). (It’s worth remembering that Chen was also often a fellow joker, as when, as Mayor of Taipei, he dressed up for a government-funded student party as a mixture of Michael Jackson and Superman.)

But Shih always appeared a personable and even romantic figure, smiling with his hands in his trouser pockets outside the court in 1980, and posing naked with his two daughters last year to mark his 70th birthday. He’s a political joker who’s been made to suffer terribly for his insolence. He’s twice been nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize, once by Lech Walesa.

Publication Notes

Political Will and Common Sense

By Shih Ming-te

268 pages

Shih Ming-te Lecture Foundation

Taiwan, Softback

Now, at 71, he’s brought out English translations of two of his works, Political Will and Common Sense. They’re very different. Political Will is a testament he wrote in 1980 to read out at his trial; he ended up handing it to the judges in written form. Common Sense is a short book he published in Chinese last year.

One of the problems for Shih has been that his Red Shirts Movement was enthusiastically welcomed by Chinese media because it sought to discredit a DPP president. But Shih will have no truck with any talk of “unification.” Almost the whole of Common Sense is a defense of Taiwan as an independent nation, and indeed at the time of the Kaohsiung Incident he repeatedly told the judges that Taiwan was already an independent state, and had been so for 30 years.

Shih is quick to point out that “Common Sense” was the title given to a pamphlet published in 1776 by Tom Paine, supporting the American colonists and their campaign for independence. The parallel is not exact because Taiwan never was a part of China, though it might be considered to have been for a time a sort of colony. But the point Shih is making is that knowing what country you belong to ought to be simple common sense, and he can’t understand why so many Taiwanese aren’t sure.

Political Will is the more interesting of the two works, though neither is gripping. In it, Shih makes the crucial claim that democracy in Taiwan would reinforce its status as an independent state, admired by the rest of the world. He’d always claimed that democratization was his key aim, and that Taiwan as an independent state was already a de facto reality. But in linking the two in this manner, Shih establishes a crucial argument that time has seen bear fruit.

This story has been viewed 4311 times.

Comments will be moderated. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned.

TOP top