Fri, Dec 01, 2006 - Page 15 News List

'Deja vu' all hardware and hooey

The Jerry Bruckheimer and Tony Scott collaboration is big on bangs and small on plot, script and coherence

By Manohla Dargis  /  NY TIMES NEWS SERVICE , NEW YORK

Deja vu is more than a feeling.Now, it's a movie too.

PHOTOS COURTESY OF BVI

In the cinema of big bangs, few bangs are bigger than those generated by the producer Jerry Bruckheimer. That's especially true when this influential hitmaker (his small-screen credits include the CSI franchise) teams up with the film director Tony Scott, with whom he has made six blockbusters, including the 1980s pop sensation Top Gun. Now comes Deja vu, an action flick with Denzel Washington in which the gaudy pyrotechnics are nowhere near as jaw-dropping as the screenplay that name-checks not one, not two, but three national tragedies against a backdrop of red blood, white uniforms and blue-sky improbability.

It doesn't take long before the filmmakers uncork their signature move and blow something up. In this case, that something is: the 543 men, women and children, including hundreds of sailors who, having gathered aboard an enormous New Orleans ferry, are blown to pieces almost as it pushes off. One minute a grandfatherly type in a veteran's cap is sitting with a small child in his lap; the next, a sailor is soaring through the air, his snowy white uniform cutting a stark picture against the fiery orange backdrop. At once awesome and absurd, the explosion doesn't just rip bodies discreetly apart but also shreds the film, because nothing else in Deja vu has been created with such loving attention to detail.

The dead have just started to be stacked up on the pier when Washington rolls up as Doug Carlin, an agent for the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives. Graced with almost uncanny powers of detection, Doug is the kind of investigator who sniffs the air, sifts the earth and all but walks on water to determine who did what, where, when and why. Standing on the banks of the Mississippi amid the carefully scattered wreckage, not a severed body part in view, he zeroes in on a speck of evidence that would have led straight to the killer if the credited screenwriters, Bill Marsilii and Terry Rossio, hadn't decided to kink up their terrorism plot with a beautiful dead woman and some nutty speculative fiction.

Film Notes:

Deja VuDirected by: Tony ScottStarring: Denzel Washington (Doug Carlin), Paula Patton (Claire Kuchever), Val Kilmer (Agent Pryzwarra), Jim Caviezel (Carrol Oerstadt), Adam Goldberg (Denny), Elden Henson (Gunnars), Erika Alexander (Shanti), Bruce Greenwood (Jack McCready)Running time: 125 minutesTaiwan release: Today


Fantasists of a specific Hollywood kind, Bruckheimer and Scott rarely traffic in reality, even when they seem to want to. Deja vu is more removed from reality than most of their collaborations, which makes their exploitation of Sept. 11, Katrina and Oklahoma City (which earns a couple of vague mentions) less offensive than it might in a film that bore some relation to the real world. Yet Deja vu is so wildly divorced from the here and the now of contemporary politics, policy and people that it's impossible to get worked up by its invocation of these three calamities, though a throwaway shot of a decimated New Orleans neighborhood used purely for some atmospheric flavoring is certainly vulgar in the extreme.

Of course, vulgarity is part of the appeal of both a Jerry Bruckheimer film and a Tony Scott film, which exist purely for an evening's entertainment, for loud noises and flashy pictures, big stars and fast action, violence and yet more violence. Like all their partnerships, Deja vu has been calibrated for minimum thought and maximum diversion; too bad that, unlike Enemy of the State, by far the smartest and slickest of their joint efforts, this new film falls so perilously short. The joke of it is, for all the pricey bangs and booms, the whiplash cinematography and the editing that turns film space into cubistic tableaux, a Bruckheimer-and-Scott partnership is only as good as its screenplay, and this one is a mess.

This story has been viewed 1995 times.
TOP top