A decade after modern Vietnamese painting made a splash on the world scene, critics and galleries say rampant commercialization and a glut of cheap copies are threatening the young art movement.
The original works of Vietnam's best-known artists are fetching small fortunes in Hanoi, Hong Kong and Singapore. But for each authentic work, hundreds of reproductions are being churned out by craftsmen who have almost perfected a tradition of faithfully copying their masters.
Some of Vietnam's top artists themselves have added to the problem by mass-producing works that originally won them critical acclaim, leading to a creative stagnation and drop in art prices, say some galleries.
PHOTOS: AFP
“Many painters turned to the commercial production of their work solely for the marketplace and managed to make a good living doing this,” says Suzanne Lecht, director at Art Vietnam, one of the main galleries in Hanoi.
“Sometimes the influence of money weighs more heavily than the desire to produce a singular work of art.”
Vietnamese visual art, influenced by ancient Chinese and modern French styles, awoke in the 1990s from a long slumber during which the communist regime allowed only socialist realism, art for political purposes.
As Vietnam's doi moi (renewal) reforms kicked in and the country reopened its doors to the outside world, a wave of painters emerged to the delight of art lovers who hailed the works as both fresh and uniquely Vietnamese.
The vibrant and abstract landscapes of Le Thiet Cuong, Thanh Bien's dreamlike depictions of women in traditional ao dai dresses, and the Cubist-influenced lacquer works of Thanh Chuong all earned praise from foreign collectors.
In 1995, a canvas by Do Quang Em sold for more than US$50,000 at Hong Kong's Galerie La Vong, one of a number of galleries devoted to Vietnamese art that sprang up around the Asian region.
The commercial success of Em, whose naturalistic still-lives are said to recall the old Dutch masters, was the spark that led collectors and critics to take the movement seriously, say some experts.
It showed that “Vietnamese art is unique and different from that of other Asian countries,” says Shirley Hui of Galerie La Vong. “It combines local culture and traditions, the French legacy and ancient Chinese philosophy.”
Many Vietnamese artists have continued to explore new creative avenues, dabbling in new styles, motifs and media — but for others the overnight success has amounted to a creative kiss of death, say critics.
“We have some great artists who are doing well and don't produce too much,” says Hui. “But a number of others become commercial and then just keep copying their own work. They will ruin their future in the market.”
New generation
Today the tourist areas of Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City abound with hundreds of galleries that mostly specialize in detailed reproductions of famous Western artists, from Leonardo da Vinci to Vincent Van Gogh to Andy Warhol.
Equally popular, and some say equally kitsch, are the Vietnamese paintings that depict a romanticized vision of a land of lotus flowers, conical hats and flooded rice paddies, of water buffalo and colorful ethnic minority markets.
Some top-end galleries sell original masters, typically for US$3,000 to US$5,000 apiece — but for each original artwork, a gallery down the street will likely sell a cheap imitation, leaving many potential buyers baffled.
For those not intimately familiar with what's real and what's not, the Vietnamese art market can be a minefield.
“Many people are frightened of buying without being sure that it is an original,” says Art Vietnam's Lecht. “There is no governmental body that can provide a certificate of authenticity.”
Despite the plagiarism and the heavy hand of state censorship — Vietnamese artists still need state permits to mount exhibitions — not all is gloomy.
A new generation of more edgy artists is emerging in Hanoi, and increasingly in the bustling southern commercial hub of Ho Chi Minh City, eager to adapt their styles to depict the rapidly changing society around them.
The surrealist works of one rising star, Hanoi's Nguyen Manh Hung, touch on the country's bloody history without being overtly political, using images such as military jets pulling carts filled with rice stalks.
Another newcomer creating a buzz is 32-year-old painter and video artist Hoang Duong Cam, whose bold and vibrant exhibition Filename.disan (heritage) has been shown at Ho Chi Minh City's avant-garde Galerie Quynh.
Described as a comment on technology and culture, and the blurring of East and West, the abstract works mix traditional and modern images, such as the ao dai girl and modern bras, under layers of bold color.
“When I was at university, we were supposed to paint buffalo, ethnic minority people and ao dai girls to get high marks,” says Cam. “As for art movements, we were taught only French impressionism and socialist realism.
“My generation had little access to information for a long time. Now young artists look on the Internet or ask foreign friends to send art magazines to discover what is happening abroad.”
In his works, Cam explains, he tries to depict “the Vietnam of today — between tradition and consumer society”.
Cam, who previously made ends meet as a graphic designer, says proudly, “I am at last a full-time artist.
But he has sympathy for those who primarily paint to pay the bills. “There are many who have to earn their living another way.”
May 6 to May 12 Those who follow the Chinese-language news may have noticed the usage of the term zhuge (豬哥, literally ‘pig brother,’ a male pig raised for breeding purposes) in reports concerning the ongoing #Metoo scandal in the entertainment industry. The term’s modern connotations can range from womanizer or lecher to sexual predator, but it once referred to an important rural trade. Until the 1970s, it was a common sight to see a breeder herding a single “zhuge” down a rustic path with a bamboo whip, often traveling large distances over rugged terrain to service local families. Not only
Ahead of incoming president William Lai’s (賴清德) inauguration on May 20 there appear to be signs that he is signaling to the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and that the Chinese side is also signaling to the Taiwan side. This raises a lot of questions, including what is the CCP up to, who are they signaling to, what are they signaling, how with the various actors in Taiwan respond and where this could ultimately go. In the last column, published on May 2, we examined the curious case of Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) heavyweight Tseng Wen-tsan (鄭文燦) — currently vice premier
The last time Mrs Hsieh came to Cihu Park in Taoyuan was almost 50 years ago, on a school trip to the grave of Taiwan’s recently deceased dictator. Busloads of children were brought in to pay their respects to Chiang Kai-shek (蔣中正), known as Generalissimo, who had died at 87, after decades ruling Taiwan under brutal martial law. “There were a lot of buses, and there was a long queue,” Hsieh recalled. “It was a school rule. We had to bow, and then we went home.” Chiang’s body is still there, under guard in a mausoleum at the end of a path
Last week the Directorate-General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics (DGBAS) released a set of very strange numbers on Taiwan’s wealth distribution. Duly quoted in the Taipei Times, the report said that “The Gini coefficient for Taiwanese households… was 0.606 at the end of 2021, lower than Australia’s 0.611, the UK’s 0.620, Japan’s 0.678, France’s 0.676 and Germany’s 0.727, the agency said in a report.” The Gini coefficient is a measure of relative inequality, usually of wealth or income, though it can be used to evaluate other forms of inequality. However, for most nations it is a number from .25 to .50