Looking behind the curtain, seeing what isn't out on show, has both cachet and appeal. It is also, by definition, difficult and sometimes dangerous. Jeff Hargrove's second Taipei show, which brings his artist's eye to bear on the women who sing at Taipei's red packet cabarets, looks behind the curtain on a number of different levels, and is one of the most interesting photographic exhibitions with a local focus to be shown in some time. The last occasion was probably Chang Chien-chi's (
Jeff Hargrove, a Paris-based artist, has already done one show in Taipei. On that occasion, it was a series of portraits of Taiwanese artists. The stakes have gone up since then, and in turning his eye to the shadow world of Taipei's entertainment district, Hargrove has taken up a considerably tougher challenge. While most artists are hungry for publicity and relatively media savvy, the women who sing in Taipei's red packet cabarets are distinctly camera shy.
PHOTNS COURTESY OF JEFF HARGROVE
Most distinctively, in tackling this secret world, Hargrove totally rejected the hole-in-the-wall surreptitious photography that miniaturized technology has made possible. He does not want to steal images from a hostile environment. In opting to shoot with a 4x5 Deardoff, Hargrove cast aside any pretense of secrecy.
"We became friends," Hargrove said. "When we went in, everyone would come over an talk with us. We weren't like regular clients. They didn't feel they needed to put on their charms for us."
According to Serina Yeh (
The cabarets are seen alternatively as places where old men go for solace and as pits of iniquity in which singing serves only as a front for thinly disguised prostitution. In the complex social environment of the old city, the truth, as you might expect, is a good deal more complex.
"Many of the singers have very interesting, very difficult life stories," said Hargrove, who sees these women as shouldering enormous social pressures simply in order to carry on with their lives.
This situation was put in particular perspective by an article in the Chinese-language China Times last week that almost led to the cancellation of the show, which suggested that the singers of the red packet cabarets were simply "withered old women building fantasies for withered old men." While these are no Britney Spears or Christina Aguilera -- some may even be described as matronly -- Hargrove seeks a beauty that goes beyond skin deep. The strength, sorrow, pride and vulnerability that he has managed to capture in the portrait series can be very moving, and each time you look at them, new depths are revealed.
His style of work, the commitment of time and emotional energy that it requires, goes a long way to explaining what he has achieved. Regarding the many months of preparatory work, Yeh said that it was essential to establish the high level of trust that the photos required. "We hadn't thought [the preparatory period] would be so long," she said. "We had to judge when the time was right to raise the matter of taking the photos. We had to be very sensitive to their feelings."
But the investment, artistically speaking, has paid off handsomely, and Hargrove is well aware of the dividends he has reaped from "working together" with his subjects. "I wanted to show their most intimate feelings," he said.
To warm the singers up to the portrait shot, Hargrove had them sing the song they felt most deeply about -- many of these the common currency of Chinese love songs. "But for many of these women, there is a reason why they choose a certain song," Hargrove said. "I asked them to focus on this feeling when I took the shot."
This was a conscious exercise in self-revelation and Hargrove said that the most moving aspect of this project was the willingness of these women to bare their souls to the camera. "I asked them to sing, because this always raised the level of emotion," Hargrove said. And often, even with the presence of a large-format camera, the photo shoots become powerfully emotional moments for both the subject and the photographer.
The photos themselves, taken on 8x10 Polaroid stock, has a surreal quality that Hargrove said was the reason for giving up his favored black and white stock.
"These singers are a man's dream," he pointed out. "The red packet cabaret has a fantasy quality for the men who visit there." The visual quality of the photographs enhance this, with its over-saturated colors and eerily soft focus, that these women, in the eyes of most who see them, for all their possible imperfections, have an untouchable, ethereal, and eminently nostalgic quality.
His individual style didn't make him an instant hit with the singers he photographed, but a thoughtful approach to his photos reveals the rightness of the path he has chosen.
"Maybe it is not the best photo that has been taken of them," Hargrove said, emphasizing "in their eyes." Certainly, these are not photos of a conventional beauty. But ultimately, these are not conventional portraits. They tell stories of strength in the face of divorce, death, debt, and in the end, a world changed out of all recognition for a generation brought up to expect something completely different.
One aspect of the series that should not be ignored is that these women all work in the same environment -- in this case, the same red packet cabaret. Here lies the big difference with Hargrove's previous work. "The artists I photographed before, they were all very much individuals. These women are all part of a single place, so it is a communal portrait of a special world."
Whatever the negative stereotyping of the world these women live in, and the women themselves, the effect of Hargrove's images is a tonic against prejudice. Even in the trite words of a love song, the powerful spirit of womanhood comes through -- a will to live, a desire to survive, a care for the tawdry trappings that make us human. These portraits of the disenfranchised are powerful images of the complex social environment that is Taiwan.
It seems every few days one bumps into one of those “real man” comments in which Taiwan is urged to “face reality” or similar, and “make a deal,” with the speaker implying that soon it will be too late. “Deal” advocates always present themselves as having a superior grip on reality, and the manly ability to make the “hard choice.” Their testosterone-laden language often echoes that of Taiwan sellout advocates. Note that such commentary always specifies a process (“make a deal, work with, make progress”), never the end state of what occupation by a violent authoritarian colonialist state will entail. In
There are shadowy cabals plotting to sell out Taiwan to be annexed by China, by invasion if necessary. Fortunately, they are buffoons. In 2019, former Bamboo Union gangster and founder of the China Unification Promotion Party (CUPP), Chang An-le (張安樂, colorfully known as “White Wolf”), led a protest at the Legislative Yuan against comments made by then-premier Su Tseng-chang (蘇貞昌) that in the event of an attack by China, he would never surrender, but would protect the nation by fighting to the end, even if he only had a broom. Chang had party members bring a wooden casket that they
Taiwan’s English education system is being pulled apart by three opposing forces. Bilingual Nation 2030 pulls students toward English and global communication. Artificial Intelligence (AI) readiness pulls them toward digital judgment, verification and AI-mediated work. But Taiwan’s old exam culture pulls them back toward memorization, grammar drills, timed reading and correct answers. If the education system keeps using old exams to define success, it risks producing graduates who are neither genuinely bilingual nor genuinely AI-ready, but trained for tasks machines can already perform. The first force is Bilingual Nation 2030. Launched in 2018, the policy aimed to “help Taiwan’s workforce connect
June 1 to June 7 "If all Taiwanese were as afraid of dying as you, then what would happen?” Physician Shih Chiang-nan (施江南) reportedly said this to his wife Chen Chiao-tung (陳焦桐) after she urged him to stop intervening on behalf of Taiwanese soldiers stranded overseas after serving in the Japanese Army during World War II. Shih had clashed with high-ranking officials over the issue, engaged in several heated arguments with Taiwan governor-general Chen Yi (陳儀) and allegedly shouted at general Ko Yuan-fen (柯遠芬), chief of staff of the Taiwan Garrison Command, over
RSS