To create what is being billed as one of the world’s most environmentally conscientious skyscrapers, the building’s developer, the Durst Organization, encouraged its architects to tap waste from some of the world’s dirtiest industries.
The concrete used at One Bryant Park, the angled 54-story tower that opened this year at 42nd Street and the Avenue of the Americas in Manhattan, used 45 percent less cement than would normally be used, replaced by slag from steel mills.
Concrete has existed since the public works of ancient Rome, when it was used to support aqueducts, and engineers love the material for its resilience in earthquakes and its utility in creating buildings of all shapes and sizes.
But as demand for concrete has soared, in part because of the rapid growth of cities in Asia, the environmental costs of the material are getting hard to ignore.
“Concrete is a terrific material, which is why it’s been used for 2,000 years,” said Tim Christ, an architect. “But it’s a very dirty material. The air-quality issues in China we observed during the Olympics derive from concrete construction.”
That’s because every tonne of new portland cement, the most common adhesive ingredient in concrete, releases roughly 1 tonne of greenhouse gases from the kilns that bake it.
The most potent way to reduce that toll is to replace some portland cement with recycled material. Coal ash from power plants and blast-furnace slag are the easiest substitutes to find — and they tend to make concrete more valuable than portland cement alone.
As often occurs with building techniques, the federal government gave this practice an early proving ground. It commissioned Christ’s firm, Morphosis, based in Santa Monica, California, and headed by Thom Mayne, the Pritzker Architecture Prize winner, to design the San Francisco Federal Building in 2001.
“We proposed a 50 percent slag replacement, where 15 percent was common,” said Christ of the building, which was completed last year, surprising critics and passers-by with an array of bends and overhangs.
Previously, use of such a high percentage of slag in the US had mainly been limited to relatively small projects without sophisticated specifications.
The process was also gaining credibility on the East Coast around the same time. The green-minded Durst Organization opened Four Times Square, the Conde Nast Building, in 1999 as a showcase for environmentally responsible techniques, recalled the company’s co-president, Jody Durst.
To that end, the developer specified using coal ash in the building’s columns. The company wanted to use as much recycled material as it could, Durst recalled, but the skeptical contractors limited its use to columns rather than floors.
The material held up so well there, however, that Durst also used slag for the Helena, a 600-unit apartment tower on West 57th Street in Manhattan, which opened in 2005.
By the end of that project, Durst said, contractors had come around.
“I think we paid a premium, but by the end of the job the contractor said he liked the way it handled,” Durst recalled. “The strength properties were superior.”
STANDARD PROCEDURE
The developer’s standard procedure now includes ordering slag or coal ash for concrete.
The two byproducts differ in availability and characteristics. Slag, which is left over in blast furnaces when steel is made, can make up more of the concrete mix than ash without requiring extra chemicals, but it is harder to obtain locally. Developers like to buy supplies locally to reduce travel times and to gain points in the Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design rating system, which certifies a building’s environmental friendliness. Slag also tends to have a lighter color than ash. Ash’s quality can vary more, but testing techniques now generally make it as reliable as slag.
Either material makes concrete stronger, said Christian Meyer, a civil engineering professor at Columbia, by reducing the effect of heat on the integrity of the concrete. Portland cement requires more water, and the resulting concrete may become hotter in warm weather and be more susceptible to cracking. It is also more likely to harden in a mixing truck while a driver sits in traffic on a hot day, making it impossible to pour at the construction site, said Bob Mannino of Pinnacle Construction, Durst’s concrete contractor at One Bryant Park.
Compared with portland cement, slag is denser and is up to 15 percent stronger, said Dave Weber, executive director of the Slag Cement Association.
“In mass concrete, for the base of a building, it can comprise up to 80 percent of the mix,” he said.
The stronger concrete helps developers meet big-city building codes, which now require higher strength to withstand potential terrorist attacks or disasters.
The Freedom Tower at ground zero of the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks and a nearby Forest City Ratner condominium, Beekman Tower, are among prominent developments using recycled material.
The greater solidity also lets developers make thinner walls, allowing for more rentable area, according to architect John Cetra. Cetra’s firm, Cetra/Ruddy, decided to use slag in a condominium building called One Madison Park, which is nearing completion on 23rd Street. Like Durst, he expects to use slag or ash in all urban projects from now on.
“It doesn’t add anything to the cost,” Cetra said. “And it’s used more and more in high-performance concrete, which we like using because it means the structure can be slimmed down a bit so we can conserve space.”
VERSATILITY
As more developers are recognizing the materials’ versatility, supply networks reaching from smelters and coal-fired power plants to concrete makers have been growing.
“Most electric utilities have an agreement with a marketer for storage in domes or silos, and on a daily basis trucks will come get it because the power plant needs to clear out the ash,” said Dave Goss, executive director of the American Coal Ash Association.
Utilities own ash and sell it to concrete mixing companies. Big concrete companies like France’s Lafarge and independent specialists also own and manage stocks of ash and slag, Goss said. There are several ways that such companies agree to sell, store and share profits from the material.
Growing demand for the recycled material has caused it to become costlier. With the US’ relatively few steel mills oversubscribed, said Meyer, some contractors are importing slag from Italy for their projects. Weber of the Slag Cement Association said trade groups and academics are working on developing “ternary blends” that mix slag, ash and other materials for lower transport and processing costs.
More research into concrete’s environmental cost will probably change the industry further in the next 10 years. Even if ash or slag cement become universal, concrete will exact a big toll on the environment, Meyer said, because up to three-quarters of it is aggregated sand or stone, which consumes lots of energy in production. Finding recycled material for aggregate will be the industry’s next challenge.
The most promising contender, Meyer said, is construction debris. At Denver International Airport, which opened in 1995, roadbeds contain concrete from the former Stapleton Airport, he said. So, depending on research into the strength of debris and its chemical reaction with other ingredients, concrete — a 2,000-year-old material — may soon involve recycling buildings that have been around for only a few decades.
Could Asia be on the verge of a new wave of nuclear proliferation? A look back at the early history of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO), which recently celebrated its 75th anniversary, illuminates some reasons for concern in the Indo-Pacific today. US Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin recently described NATO as “the most powerful and successful alliance in history,” but the organization’s early years were not without challenges. At its inception, the signing of the North Atlantic Treaty marked a sea change in American strategic thinking. The United States had been intent on withdrawing from Europe in the years following
My wife and I spent the week in the interior of Taiwan where Shuyuan spent her childhood. In that town there is a street that functions as an open farmer’s market. Walk along that street, as Shuyuan did yesterday, and it is next to impossible to come home empty-handed. Some mangoes that looked vaguely like others we had seen around here ended up on our table. Shuyuan told how she had bought them from a little old farmer woman from the countryside who said the mangoes were from a very old tree she had on her property. The big surprise
The issue of China’s overcapacity has drawn greater global attention recently, with US Secretary of the Treasury Janet Yellen urging Beijing to address its excess production in key industries during her visit to China last week. Meanwhile in Brussels, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen last week said that Europe must have a tough talk with China on its perceived overcapacity and unfair trade practices. The remarks by Yellen and Von der Leyen come as China’s economy is undergoing a painful transition. Beijing is trying to steer the world’s second-largest economy out of a COVID-19 slump, the property crisis and
As former president Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九) wrapped up his visit to the People’s Republic of China, he received his share of attention. Certainly, the trip must be seen within the full context of Ma’s life, that is, his eight-year presidency, the Sunflower movement and his failed Economic Cooperation Framework Agreement, as well as his eight years as Taipei mayor with its posturing, accusations of money laundering, and ups and downs. Through all that, basic questions stand out: “What drives Ma? What is his end game?” Having observed and commented on Ma for decades, it is all ironically reminiscent of former US president Harry