Fri, Mar 04, 2005 page9

• Legacy of arbitrary borders continues to limit sub-Saharan Africa

  • By Simon Teitel
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  The world's economic powers finally appear to be closing ranks behind efforts to address global poverty and economic underdevelopment. At this year's World Economic Forum, within the G8, and elsewhere, the consensus that something needs to be done has been as clear and as it is welcome. But, for some of the world's poorest regions, particularly Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA), a commitment to help may not be enough.

  Basic indicators of economic and social development show SSA lagging far behind other developing areas. The average income per capita of SSA countries in 2000 was less than half that for all developing countries, about 40 percent of the level of East Asian and Pacific developing countries, and less than 25 percent that of Latin America and the Caribbean countries.

  Similarly, life expectancy at birth in SSA countries lagged 16 years behind the developing-country average, 14 years behind countries in South Asia, and 21 years behind countries in East Asia, Latin America and the Caribbean. In combined gross enrollment in primary, secondary and higher education, SSA countries stood 19 percent below the average for developing countries, 11 percent below South Asian countries, 29 percent below East Asia and the Pacific and 32 percent below Latin America and the Caribbean.

  What accounts for this broad-based underdevelopment? Until the late 1800s, most of Africa was unexplored and occupied by hunter-gatherers and practitioners of subsistence agriculture. Land was relatively abundant and allocated by tribal chiefs without regard to Western-style property rights. The only territorial units resembling those that exist today were Ethiopia, Liberia and South Africa.

  During the burst of imperial expansion in Africa that followed national integration and trade liberalization in Europe, colonial powers showed little interest in delineating colonial national boundaries based on cultural or ethnic considerations; they cared only about raw materials and markets. The Berlin Conference of 1885 fixed the borders of Europe's African colonies so that they included within them a large variety of languages, religions, and ethnic groups.

  Most SSA countries attained national independence some time after the end of the World War II, as the British, French, Belgian, and Portuguese empires unraveled (Germany had already lost its colonies after 1918). Thus, SSA countries have only enjoyed independence for a short period in comparison with, say, South America, where countries had their wars of independence around 1810 to 1820 and achieved some type of constitutional government by 1850 to 1880.

  The legacy of arbitrarily drawn borders and limited political centralization meant that in many SSA countries remnants of the colonial experience continue to play a big role in defining the institutional landscape, such as the civil service and public administration, educational system and economic infrastructure. To be sure, many countries adopted English, French, or Portuguese as their official languages, and European missionaries, who often followed in the colonizers' footsteps, had success in transmitting their religious practices to local populations.

  Nevertheless, linguistic variety and ethnic divisions remain more important than in most of the developing world, and tribal affiliation has continued to hinder the emergence of unifying national identities. Moreover, self-rule has not brought many democratically elected regimes. Instead, anti-colonial liberation leaders often developed personality cults and hogged power for decades.

  Monopolization of political power led, in turn, to rampant cronyism and corruption, which stifled economic and social development. Recent data on perceived corruption in public transactions show the SSA countries with the lowest average score for all developing regions. Only Botswana and Namibia achieved respectable scores, while the worst offenders were Cameroon, Uganda, Kenya, Angola, Madagascar and Nigeria.

  Weak national unity has underpinned an even more damaging pattern. Since the 1990s, many of the world's armed conflicts have taken place in SSA countries. Congo and Lesotho each experienced two conflicts during the decade, while civil strife ravaged Sierra Leone, Ivory Coast, Liberia, Congo and Sudan. This deterred not only foreign and domestic investment, but, more fundamentally, the formation of the very institutions needed for successful economic development.

  Sustained economic growth requires, everywhere, the accumulation of physical and human capital, as well as the acquisition of technological capabilities. This process does not occur in a historical vacuum, devoid of the influence of powerful social and political factors. Structure, institutions and policies are critical determinants, as is the availability of qualified technical and administrative personnel.

  Indeed, the availability of a highly qualified bureaucracy in both South Korea and Taiwan -- and before that in their model country, Japan -- was a necessary precondition for achieving rapid economic growth. By contrast, the shortage in SSA of scientific, technical, and administrative skills, such as those of engineers, natural scientists, managers, and technicians, is a key reason why the East Asian "miracle" could not be reproduced there.

  None of the preconditions of economic development will be met in SSA until the legacy of colonialism and weak states that has defined the region is overcome. Developed countries can provide limited help by means of well-focused, untied aid and technical assistance projects.

  But success depends mainly on the emergence of dedicated, talented, and honest national and regional political leaders. Only such leaders can build up the legitimacy needed to unite their countries, and only then will they be able to confront head on the many challenges that the region faces in shaking loose from the shackles of backwardness.

  Simon Teitel is an economic development consultant and visiting research fellow at the International Center for Economic Research (ICER) in Turin.

  Copyright: Project Syndicate
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Roadside saliva tests to begin by end of the year

  • 2

    Torrential rain expected this week, the CWA says

  • 3

    Monkeys down Brothers to take 2-0 lead in series

  • 4

    Registration for NT$10,000 to open on Nov. 5

  • 5

    Urban mining could evade China’s grip