People tend to think of work-family conflict as something that only women experience and assume that it pushes women to quit their jobs.
However, new research shows that men feel it just as much as women do and that it also undercuts their commitment to their employer.
An article published this week in Harvard Business Review looks at why both men and women feel work-family conflict, but why men’s feelings on this remain largely invisible.
The authors, Robin Ely of Harvard Business School and Irene Padavic at Florida State University, studied a global consulting firm for 18 months.
In interviews with the research team, which also included Erin Reid of McMaster University, the men expressed profound sadness and guilt over not being there for their children and their partners.
It is not the only study to reveal that men feel work-family conflict — but it is remarkable for the portrait it paints of silent male suffering, and the way in which male silence and female openness conspire to maintain the status quo.
One working dad painted a bleak portrait of his son playing alone with a toy train, while a nanny looked coldly on. Another seemed sad that his young daughter always asked for his wife at bedtime — never for him.
Yet while these men felt work-family conflict deeply, they also tended to suppress those feelings — minimizing their own feelings or displacing them onto women.
One described falling “chemically, deeply” in love with his newborn daughter and said that it helped him “understand” why some women would not want to go back to work after having kids.
His takeaway was not that he was entitled to his own mixed feelings, but that women must have a hard time balancing work and family.
Others distanced themselves from their fears using humor, or by emphasizing that however bad they had felt before, they felt better now — now that they are not on a six-month assignment in a foreign country, now that only one of their kids cries when they leave for work, now that the seven-year-old can “almost” make his own breakfast (Pop Tarts).
By contrast, the women were more frank about the work-family conflicts they felt. They did not hide from them, or project them onto someone else.
The women were also more likely to take action to try to resolve the conflict, like swapping a client-facing role for one with more-predictable hours. As a result, though, the women gave up power in the firm — and saw their progress stall.
Women made up 37 percent of junior associates, but only 10 percent of partners; and women who made it to partner took two years longer to get there than men did.
While senior leaders assumed it was women who struggled with the firm’s 24-7 culture, men and women reported equally that the relentless pace was crushing — and unnecessary.
Consultants spoke of working through the night to make 100-slide presentations they were all too aware the client could not use, had not asked for and probably would not even read, but no one at the firm seemed to think it was possible to stop producing them.
If it sounds a little like a cult, that is because it kind of is — in which work is a kind of religion and devotees show their faith not by shaving their heads or wearing hair shirts, but by working all the time.
Men made it clear that working this way took a toll on their commitment to the firm.
One dad said he “wanted to quit then and there” when work caused him to miss his son’s soccer game — and his son to burst into tears.
Another said he was “overworked and underfamilied,” adding: “If I were a betting man, I’d bet that a year from now I’m working somewhere else.”
That was what happened. In fact, while the firm assumed women had a higher turnover rate, this was not true — looking at three years of data showed men were just as likely to quit as women.
Nonetheless, when the researchers presented their findings to the firm’s leaders — that the culture of overwork was hurting both men and women, but that women were paying a disproportionate price for it — the managers rejected the conclusion as well as the proposed gender-neutral solutions.
They said that work-family conflict was women’s problem, and that any solution must target women specifically. (Since female-specific solutions only seem to derail women’s careers, adding yet another was not likely to help.)
We cannot keep pretending, in the face of mounting evidence, that work-family conflict is only a woman’s problem, or that the only reason more women are not working 24-7 is because of their children.
It is closer to the truth to say that no one wants to work 24-7, because it is, frankly, a miserable way to live.
Instead of offering women yet more poisoned chalices in the form of flex-time programs that only mark them for punishment, managers must target dysfunctional work cultures that hinge on over-selling and over-delivering, driving both men and women to seek other employment arrangements.
Talented, hard-working people have options. They also, quite frequently, exercise them.
Sarah Green Carmichael is an editor with Bloomberg Opinion. She was managing editor of ideas and commentary at Barron’s and an executive editor at Harvard Business Review, where she hosted the HBR Ideacast.
This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of Bloomberg LP and its owners.
DEVELOPING TALENT: The electronics contractor is looking to recruit people to work in core tech fields and emerging industries like electric cars and robotics Hon Hai Precision Industry Co (鴻海精密), the world’s largest contract electronics maker, has launched a recruitment drive, offering a monthly salary of no less than NT$45,000 (US$1,485) to university graduates. For those with a master’s degree, the starting pay would be NT$52,000 per month at the minimum, while doctorate degree holders would receive at least NT$60,000 a month, Hon Hai said a statement issued early this week. The latest recruitment drive is aimed at attracting talent in core technology fields — artificial intelligence, semiconductors and next-generation mobile communications — and emerging industries — electric vehicles, digital healthcare and robotics, the
MRT TRAVEL FALLS: In February, ridership on the Taipei MRT System fell 8.96 percent from an average of 2.01 million per day in January Scooter sales jumped 13 percent last month as more commuters turned to two-wheelers to avoid public transportation amid the COVID-19 pandemic, the latest statistics showed. Sales expanded to 74,493 units last month, compared with 65,913 units in February, statistics released on Wednesday by Kwang Yang Motor Co (光陽工業) and the Ministry of Transportation and Communications showed. In the first quarter, aggregate sales slid 0.51 percent year-over-year to 186,627 units, from 187,580 units, data showed. Kwang Yang, the nation’s biggest scooter manufacturer, continued to lead the market by selling 24,136 vehicles last month, growing 6.12 percent from 20,785 units in the previous month, while
Asustek Computer Inc (華碩), the nation’s leading PC vendor, yesterday launched its first dual-screen gaming laptop powered by Intel Corp’s latest central processing units (CPUs). The PC manufacturer’s announcement closely followed the US chipmaker’s unveiling of its 10th Generation Core H-series, the fastest commercial mobile processors with speeds of up to 5 gigahertz. Although Asustek’s Zephyrus Duo 15, the highlight of its Republic of Gamers line, is not the company’s first laptop with two screens, it is its first designed specifically for gaming. Nestled between the primary display panel and the keyboard, the secondary display, which Asustek calls the ScreenPad Plus, is angled
NO ILL EFFECT: Last month’s data mainly reflected deals made in February, when the spread of COVID-19 was still relatively mild in Taiwan, housing brokers said Housing transactions in the six special municipalities totaled 19,824 units last month, up 7.8 percent from a year earlier, brokers said, citing government data. Last month’s data mainly reflected deals made in February, when the pinch of the COVID-19 pandemic was not yet evident, they said. Taoyuan posted the largest improvement, with housing transactions soaring 36.6 percent year-on-year to 3,676 units, local government data showed. Taiwan Realty Co (台灣房屋) attributed the pickup to the completion of two presale residential projects in the municipality. Houses in Taoyuan have increasingly gained in popularity in the past few year years due to relatively affordable home prices and