Artists outraged by artificial intelligence (AI) that copies in seconds the styles they have sacrificed years to develop are waging battle online and in court.
Fury erupted in the art community last year with the release of generative AI programs that can convincingly carry out commands such as drawing a dog like cartoonist Sarah Andersen would, or a nymph the way illustrator Karla Ortiz might do.
Such style-swiping AI works are cranked out without the original artist’s consent, credit or compensation — the three C’s at the heart of a fight to change all that.
Photo: AFP
In January, artists including Andersen and Ortiz filed a class-action lawsuit against DreamUp, Midjourney and Stable Diffusion, three image-generating AI models programmed with art found online.
Andersen said that she felt “violated” when first she saw an AI drawing that copied the style of her “Fangs” comic book work.
She fired off an indignant reaction on Twitter; it went viral, and other incensed artists reached out to her with stories of their own.
Backers of the suit hope to establish legal precedent governing generative AI models that copy artists’ styles.
Artists want AI creators to be required to secure permission for works used in training software, with an option to remove it. They also want suitable compensation.
“There is room for a conversation about what that would look like,” Ortiz said.
Compensation could take the form of a licensing model and would need to be appropriate, she said..
It would be wrong for artists to “get a couple of cents, while the company gets millions” of dollars, added Ortiz, whose resume includes working for Marvel Studios.
On social networks, artists are sharing tales of jobs being lost to generative AI.
The suit says that a video-game designer named Jason Allen last year won a Colorado State Fair competition with art created using Midjourney.
“Art is dead, dude. It’s over. AI won. Humans lost,” Allen was quoted as telling the New York Times.
The Mauritshuis Museum in the Netherlands sparked controversy by displaying an AI-generated image inspired by Vermeer’s Girl With a Pearl Earring, while the San Francisco Ballet caused a stir by using Midjourney to generate illustrations used in promotional material for performances of The Nutcracker in December last year.
“It’s sort of a natural consequence of something being easy and cheap and accessible,” Andersen said. “Of course they are going to use that option, even if it is unethical.”
AI companies named in the lawsuit did not respond to requests for comment.
Stability AI founder and CEO Emad Mostaque has portrayed generative software as a “tool” that can tend to “mundane image output” and provide new ways “of ideating for artists.”
Mostaque says that it would allow more people to become artists.
Critics disagree. When a person prompts software to draw in the style of a master, it does not make that person an artist, they say.
Mostaque has said that if people choose to use generative AI unethically or to break the law, “that’s their problem.”
Companies defending themselves from artists’ copyright claims are likely to claim “fair use,” an exception sometimes allowed when a new spin is put on a creation or when it is only briefly excerpted.
“The magic word used in the US court system is ‘transformative,’” lawyer and developer Matthew Butterick said. “Is this a new use of the copyrighted work, or does it replace the original in the marketplace?”
Artists are turning not just to the courts, but to technology to defend themselves against generative AI.
Prompted by artists, a team at the University of Chicago last week launched their “Glaze” software to help protect original works.
The program adds a layer of data over images that, while invisible to the human eye, “acts as a decoy” for AI, said Shawn Shan, the doctoral student in charge of the project.
That still leaves the onus on artists to adopt Glaze. Butterick predicts a “cat-and-mouse game” as AI makers figure out ways around such defenses.
Butterick also worries about the effect of AI on the human spirit.
“When science fiction imagines the AI apocalypse, it’s something like robots coming over the hill with laser guns,” he said. “I think the way AI defeats humanity is more where people just give up and don’t want to create new things, and [it] sucks the life out of humanity.”
A new online voting system aimed at boosting turnout among the Philippines’ millions of overseas workers ahead of Monday’s mid-term elections has been marked by confusion and fears of disenfranchisement. Thousands of overseas Filipino workers have already cast their ballots in the race dominated by a bitter feud between President Ferdinand Marcos Jr and his impeached vice president, Sara Duterte. While official turnout figures are not yet publicly available, data from the Philippine Commission on Elections (COMELEC) showed that at least 134,000 of the 1.22 million registered overseas voters have signed up for the new online system, which opened on April 13. However,
EUROPEAN FUTURE? Albanian Prime Minister Edi Rama says only he could secure EU membership, but challenges remain in dealing with corruption and a brain drain Albanian Prime Minister Edi Rama seeks to win an unprecedented fourth term, pledging to finally take the country into the EU and turn it into a hot tourist destination with some help from the Trump family. The artist-turned-politician has been pitching Albania as a trendy coastal destination, which has helped to drive up tourism arrivals to a record 11 million last year. US President Donald Trump’s son-in-law, Jared Kushner, also joined in the rush, pledging to invest US$1.4 billion to turn a largely deserted island into a luxurious getaway. Rama is expected to win another term after yesterday’s vote. The vote would
ALLIES: Calling Putin his ‘old friend,’ Xi said Beijing stood alongside Russia ‘in the face of the international counter-current of unilateralism and hegemonic bullying’ Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) yesterday was in Moscow for a state visit ahead of the Kremlin’s grand Victory Day celebrations, as Ukraine accused Russia’s army of launching air strikes just hours into a supposed truce. More than 20 foreign leaders were in Russia to attend a vast military parade today marking 80 years since the defeat of Nazi Germany in World War II, taking place three years into Russia’s offensive in Ukraine. Putin ordered troops into Ukraine in February 2022 and has marshaled the memory of Soviet victory against Nazi Germany to justify his campaign and rally society behind the offensive,
Myanmar’s junta chief met Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) for the first time since seizing power, state media reported yesterday, the highest-level meeting with a key ally for the internationally sanctioned military leader. Senior General Min Aung Hlaing led a military coup in 2021, overthrowing Myanmar’s brief experiment with democracy and plunging the nation into civil war. In the four years since, his armed forces have battled dozens of ethnic armed groups and rebel militias — some with close links to China — opposed to its rule. The conflict has seen Min Aung Hlaing draw condemnation from rights groups and pursued by the
RSS