Hong Kong police were wrong to hide identification badges during last year’s pro-democracy protests, while the territory’s watchdog was “inadequate” for investigating complaints against officers, a senior judge said yesterday.
The ruling is a blow to the territory’s pro-Beijing leaders who have defended the police’s actions during the huge and often violent democracy protests, and have dismissed calls to overhaul how officers are monitored.
The ruling by High Court Judge Anderson Chow (周家明) stemmed from a series of judicial review applications brought against police by multiple parties.
Photo: AFP
During the months of clashes last year riot police often refused to wear ID badges, making it all but impossible to identify officers involved in complaints.
Lawyers for an Indonesian journalist who lost an eye to a police baton round, for example, have complained that they have been unable to identify the officer who fired the shot.
No police officer has been sacked over last year’s protests, while the Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) has exonerated the force of any major wrongdoing.
However, Chow said that the police and government breached Article 3 of the Hong Kong Bill of Rights by failing to show identity badges and provide an adequate complaints mechanism.
Article 3 provides that no one shall be subjected to torture, or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment.
“Even in times of public emergencies, however serious, the rights under [Article 3] must still be respected by the government and protected by the courts,” he wrote.
Public anger toward the police rocketed during the protests and the police said many officers were harassed, often though “doxxing” attacks where personal details are leaked online.
As criticism mounted over the identification badges, police brought in a call sign number system for officers — a move later backed by the IPCC.
However, Chow was critical of that move, saying identification “cannot be merely through the internal process of the force.”
“Otherwise, victims of police ill-treatment would be entirely or largely at the mercy of the force,” he wrote.
Chow also had a blunt assessment of the IPCC, which critics have long described as toothless.
“The existing complaints mechanism ... is inadequate to discharge this obligation,” he wrote.
A panel of international experts initially appointed to help the body look into last year’s protests resigned after they said the IPCC did not have the requisite powers to do the job properly.
Chow’s ruling can be appealed by the government.
On the Chinese microblogging platform Sina Weibo, enthusiastic slackers share their tips: Fill up a thermos with whiskey, do planks or stretches in the work pantry at regular intervals, drink liters of water to prompt lots of trips to the toilet on work time, and, once there, spend time on social media or playing games on your phone. “Not working hard is everyone’s basic right,” one commenter wrote. “With or without legal protection, everyone has the right to not work hard.” Young Chinese people are pushing back against an engrained culture of overwork, and embracing a philosophy of laziness known as “touching
‘STUNNED’: With help from an official at the US Department of Justice, Donald Trump reportedly planned to oust the acting attorney general in a bid to overturn the election Former US president Donald Trump was at his Florida resort on Saturday, beginning post-presidency life while US President Joe Biden settled into the White House, but in Washington and beyond, the chaos of the 45th president’s final days in office continued to throw out damaging aftershocks. In yet another earth-shaking report, the New York Times said that Trump plotted with an official at the US Department of Justice to fire the acting attorney general, then force Georgia Republicans to overturn his defeat in that state. Meanwhile, former acting US secretary of defense Christopher Miller made an extraordinary admission, telling Vanity Fair that
Boeing set a target of designing and certifying its jetliners to fly on 100 percent sustainable fuels by 2030, amid rising pressure on planemakers to take climate change seriously. Regulators allow a 50-50 blend of sustainable and conventional fuels, and Boeing on Friday said it would work with authorities to raise the limit. Rival Airbus is considering another tack: a futuristic lineup of hydrogen-powered aircraft that would reach the skies by 2035. The aircraft manufacturers face growing public clamor to cut emissions in the aviation industry, which added more than 1 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide to the atmosphere in 2019, according to
Mongolian Prime Minister Ukhnaagiin Khurelsukh on Thursday resigned following a protest over a hospital’s treatment of a new mother who tested positive for COVID-19. Khurelsukh, whose Mongolian People’s Party holds a strong majority in the parliament known as the State Great Khural, stepped down after accusing Mongolian President Khaltmaagiin Battulga of the Democratic Party of orchestrating a political crisis. A small protest broke out in the capital, Ulan Bator, on Wednesday after TV footage appeared of a woman who had just given birth being escorted in slippers and a thin robe from the maternity ward to a special wing for COVID-19 patients
RSS