Elevating environmental impact assessment (EIA) criteria for solar panels to the status of the parent law might confuse the regulatory system, environmental groups said on Thursday, urging the government to invite more public opinion before amending laws.
The Taiwan People’s Party in August proposed a draft amendment to Article 5 of the Environmental Impact Assessment Act (環境影響評估法), aiming to elevate the legal status of solar panel EIA criteria “to prevent solar panel systems from repeatedly harming the environment.”
Eight of the 10 proposed provisions are almost the same as the eight subparagraphs of Paragraph 7, Article 29 of the Standards for Determining Specific Items and Scope of Environmental Impact Assessments for Development Activities (開發行為應實施環境影響評估細目及範圍認定標準) — regulations subordinate to the act, governed by the Ministry of Environment.
Photo: Taipei Times
The other two draft provisions include one that states that EIAs must be conducted for proposed floating solar panel projects with an installed capacity of 10,000 kilowatts or more, or with a cumulative area of 5 hectares or more.
The other requires an EIA for solar panel projects with at least 20,000 kilowatts of installed capacity or at least 10 hectares of cumulative area, excluding rooftop solar panels.
Environmental groups in a joint news release said EIA criteria for solar panel development projects should be stricter, but should be laid out in EIA-related subsidiary laws in line with other development behaviors, rather than in the act — the parent law — otherwise the regulatory system would be confusing.
EIA criteria for development behavior should evaluate potential environmental risks for proposed sites based on factors such as projects’ scale, location and facilities, they said.
For example, risks posed by a 2 hectare solar panel project would be different for environmentally sensitive areas and regular farmland, they said.
Therefore, other factors such as waterbody types should be considered, as well as project areas, to ensure that EIA resources would be efficiently used to review high-risk projects, the groups said, calling on the legislature and the ministry to communicate more with experts and the public.
“We agree that the review system for solar panels requires discussion and revision, but the current legislation might reduce the issue to political infighting and would not prompt constructive public discussion,” they said.
Citizen of the Earth, Taiwan deputy executive director Huang Fei-yueh (黃斐悅) said the EIA system does not properly assess the primary risks of solar facilities.
The ministry is responsible for pollutant emission control, but risks like habitat fragmentation, landscape destruction and soil erosion are governed by other agencies like the Ministry of Agriculture and the Ministry of the Interior, she said.
EIAs are important to prevent environmental damage, but such issues could not be properly addressed solely through EIAs, Huang said, calling on the government to initiate interagency collaborations to integrate the system.
Department of Environmental Protection Director-General Hsu Su-chih (徐淑芷) said the environment ministry is reviewing the standards and would announce its revisions this month or next month.
The department on Sept. 24 notified central authorities and local governments to make suggestions on the matter by Friday, she said.
The parent law is more stable than its subsidiary laws and should not be arbitrarily revised, particularly because problems found after promulgation would be difficult to remediate, Hsu said.
EIA criteria for floating solar panel projects should be established in the standards by the ministry, she said, adding that more hearings would be held to communicate with the public.
Temperatures in northern Taiwan are forecast to reach as high as 30°C today, as an ongoing northeasterly seasonal wind system weakens, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said. CWA forecaster Tseng Chao-cheng (曾昭誠) said yesterday that with the seasonal wind system weakening, warmer easterly winds would boost the temperature today. Daytime temperatures in northern Taiwan and Yilan County are expected to range from 28°C to 30°C today, up about 3°C from yesterday, Tseng said. According to the CWA, temperature highs in central and southern Taiwan could stay stable. However, the weather is expected to turn cooler starting tonight as the northeasterly wind system strengthens again
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA) yesterday expressed “grave concerns” after Singaporean Prime Minister Lawrence Wong (黃循財) reiterated the city-state’s opposition to “Taiwanese independence” during a meeting with Chinese Premier Li Qiang (李強). In Singapore on Saturday, Wong and Li discussed cross-strait developments, the Singaporean Ministry of Foreign Affairs said in a statement. “Prime Minister Wong reiterated that Singapore has a clear and consistent ‘one China’ policy and is opposed to Taiwan independence,” it said. MOFA responded that it is an objective fact and a common understanding shared by many that the Republic of China (ROC) is an independent, sovereign nation, with world-leading
COOLING OFF: Temperatures are expected to fall to lows of about 20°C on Sunday and possibly 18°C to 19°C next week, following a wave of northeasterly winds on Friday The Central Weather Administration (CWA) on Sunday forecast more rain and cooler temperatures for northern Taiwan this week, with the mercury dropping to lows of 18°C, as another wave of northeasterly winds sweeps across the country. The current northeasterly winds would continue to affect Taiwan through today, with precipitation peaking today, bringing increased rainfall to windward areas, CWA forecaster Liu Pei-teng (劉沛滕) said. The weather system would weaken slightly tomorrow before another, stronger wave arrives on Friday, lasting into next week, Liu said. From yesterday to today, northern Taiwan can expect cool, wet weather, with lows of 22°C to 23°C in most areas,
Taiwan sweltered through its hottest October on record, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said yesterday, the latest in a string of global temperature records. The main island endured its highest average temperature since 1950, CWA forecaster Liu Pei-teng said. Temperatures the world over have soared in recent years as human-induced climate change contributes to ever more erratic weather patterns. Taiwan’s average temperature was 27.381°C as of Thursday, Liu said. Liu said the average could slip 0.1°C by the end of yesterday, but it would still be higher than the previous record of 27.009°C in 2016. "The temperature only started lowering around Oct. 18 or 19
RSS