The leading candidates for the Chinese Nationalist Party’s (KMT) chairperson election next week underestimate China’s threat and mistakenly view the so-called “1992 consensus” as a protective umbrella, a US think tank wrote.
The front-runners — former KMT lawmaker Cheng Li-wen (鄭麗文), former KMT vice chairman Hau Lung-bin (郝龍斌) and KMT Legislator Lo Chih-chiang (羅智強) — show that the KMT has little awareness of Beijing’s intentions and would likely resist US calls to boost defense spending or bolster deterrence, former CIA analyst and Jamestown Foundation president Peter Mattis wrote in his analysis titled Mainlander Narratives Dominate Kuomintang Leadership Race.
All three contenders base cross-strait policy on the “1992 consensus,” he wrote.
Photo: Fang Pin-chao, Taipei Times
The “1992 consensus” is a term former Mainland Affairs Council chairman Su Chi (蘇起) in 2006 admitted making up in 2000. It refers to a tacit understanding between the KMT and the Chinese government that both sides of the Strait acknowledge there is “one China,” with each side having its own interpretation of what “China” means.
The Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) does not acknowledge the existence of that “consensus.”
The candidates tend to view the People’s Republic of China (PRC) positively, while expressing skepticism toward the US and the ruling DPP government’s US policy, particularly on trade, Mattis said.
They see Taiwan’s security as dependent on its relationship with Beijing rather than with Washington, as evidenced by their belief that the “1992 consensus” ensures peace, he wrote.
Mattis cited examples that showed the candidates’ position on cross-strait relations, such as Lo referring to the administration of former president Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九) as an era in which Taiwan was very secure, and Cheng saying that “crushing Taiwan independence and fascism” and adhering to the “1992 consensus” would bring a “century of peace.”
Hau took a more cautious line, saying that Beijing must recognize that the “1992 consensus” is not equivalent to accepting China’s “one country, two systems,” and pledging to form a national defense think tank focused on the defense of the Republic of China (ROC) if he were elected, Mattis said.
All three candidates oppose raising defense spending to 5 percent of GDP, instead favoring stable cross-strait relations as the foundation of national security, he said.
Cheng said that “reconciliation” with China is the best defense, Lo called a 5 percent budget “unaffordable,” while Hau said Taiwan must “prepare for war to avoid war,” and emphasized peace and opposition to independence, Mattis said, adding that none proposed alternative defense measures.
The three candidates share a waisheng (外省) background, which refers to people who followed the KMT army to Taiwan after World War II, he said.
Cheng and Hau are children of military officers, and Lo is from a family who evacuated from Dachen Island in 1955 — reflecting a lack of internal debate over the party’s direction, he added.
Mattis quoted Cheng as saying that under KMT leadership, Taiwanese should “proudly say, ‘I am Chinese,’” while Lo said: “I am Taiwanese, I am Chinese — my China is the Republic of China.”
Meanwhile, Hau has urged retired generals not to attend Chinese military parades and stressed that the ROC’s role in WWII “must not be erased,” Mattis said, adding that Hau had called on Beijing to acknowledge the ROC’s existence.
All three candidates are wary of Washington, the report said.
Cheng has warned that excessive reliance on the US could turn Taiwan into a “bargaining chip” between Beijing and Washington, while Hau has advocated a “three nots” policy: “Pro-US, but not submissive; engaging China, but not servile; and friendly with Japan, but not obsequious,” he said.
Hau appears to be the preferred choice of the party, having received endorsements from local faction leaders and media personality Jaw Shaw-kong (趙少康), the report said, adding that Lo was backed by Ma, while Cheng, seen as the “dark horse,” was endorsed by former legislative speaker Wang Jin-pyng (王金平).
Under these candidates, the KMT is unlikely to align with US expectations on defense or preparedness, Mattis said.
“For the KMT, the best way to resist US pressure would be to deepen ties with Beijing,” Mattis wrote, urging Washington to avoid fueling anti-US sentiment and to better understand the party’s internal power dynamics.
In response to the report, Cheng yesterday said that Taiwan faces turbulent times and uncertainty, and that the priority should be to ease hostility, bolster unity and cooperation, and restore hope for the nation’s future.
“The most pressing and fundamental task is to ensure peace across the Taiwan Strait,” she said. “Without peace, young people have no future. Only through cross-strait cooperation can we generate greater strength.”
Meanwhile, Lo said that Taiwan’s best path for survival and development is to maintain engagement with the US and China, being “neither servile nor arrogant” in its relationship with the two.
Hau’s office said it had no comment about the report.
Additional reporting by Lin Hsin-han
Eight Chinese naval vessels and 24 military aircraft were detected crossing the median line of the Taiwan Strait between 6am yesterday and 6am today, the Ministry of National Defense said this morning. The aircraft entered Taiwan’s northern, central, southwestern and eastern air defense identification zones, the ministry said. The armed forces responded with mission aircraft, naval vessels and shore-based missile systems to closely monitor the situation, it added. Eight naval vessels, one official ship and 36 aircraft sorties were spotted in total, the ministry said.
INCREASED CAPACITY: The flights on Mondays, Wednesdays, Fridays and Sundays would leave Singapore in the morning and Taipei in the afternoon Singapore Airlines is adding four supplementary flights to Taipei per week until May to meet increased tourist and business travel demand, the carrier said on Friday. The addition would raise the number of weekly flights it operates to Taipei to 18, Singapore Airlines Taiwan general manager Timothy Ouyang (歐陽漢源) said. The airline has recorded a steady rise in tourist and business travel to and from Taipei, and aims to provide more flexible travel arrangements for passengers, said Ouyang, who assumed the post in July last year. From now until Saturday next week, four additional flights would depart from Singapore on Monday, Wednesday, Friday
The Ministry of National Defense yesterday reported the return of large-scale Chinese air force activities after their unexplained absence for more than two weeks, which had prompted speculation regarding Beijing’s motives. China usually sends fighter jets, drones and other military aircraft around the nation on a daily basis. Interruptions to such routine are generally caused by bad weather. The Ministry of National Defense said it had detected 26 Chinese military aircraft in the Taiwan Strait over the previous 24 hours. It last reported that many aircraft on Feb. 25, when it spotted 30 aircraft, saying Beijing was carrying out another “joint combat
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA) today said that if South Korea does not reply appropriately to its request to correct Taiwan’s name on its e-Arrival card system before March 31, it would take corresponding measures to alter how South Korea is labeled on the online Taiwan Arrival Card system. South Korea’s e-Arrival card system lists Taiwan as “China (Taiwan)” in the “point of departure” and “next destination” fields. The ministry said that it changed the nationality for South Koreans on Taiwan’s Alien Resident Certificates from “Korea” to “South Korea” on March 1, in a gesture of goodwill and based on the
RSS