The government is considering joining the International Criminal Court (ICC), in part to increase deterrence of a Chinese attack or invasion.
Supporters also say it would help to universalize the international legal system, which has a low presence in Asia, and increase Taiwan’s global participation as Beijing works to keep it as isolated as possible.
The court was established by the Rome Statute, which defined four core international crimes: genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes and crimes of aggression. It has operated since 2002, prosecuting dozens of alleged war criminals. In March the ICC issued an arrest warrant for Russian President Vladimir Putin, over the forced deportation of children from Ukraine.
Photo: Reuters
Taiwan joining the ICC would allow investigation and warrants against Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) under international law if he ordered or oversaw acts of war or war crimes against Taiwan on its territory.
Supporters have said this could help deter Xi from acting on his intention to annex Taiwan.
Taiwan joining the ICC “alone may not deter a decision to attack Taiwan,” National Chengchi University associate professor Kevin Chang (張佳康) said. “But with China trying to assert leadership in the world, this is a significant calculation China has to make.”
In his New Year’s address yesterday, Xi said China’s “reunification” with Taiwan was inevitable, striking a stronger tone than he did last year, when he said only that people on either side of the Taiwan Strait are “members of one and the same family.”
Due to the warrant, Putin did not travel to the BRICS conference in South Africa earlier this year as he faced the risk of arrest and deportation to The Hague if he landed in the ICC member state.
Professor Jonathan Hafetz, of Seton Hall Law School in the US, said he did not think Taiwanese membership of the ICC would have a strong deterrent effect alone, but would probably introduce “another dimension to the larger geopolitical landscape that China would have to navigate.”
The proposal was formally recommended by an independent annual review of Taiwan’s human rights efforts earlier this year. There have since been several discussions among members of Taiwan’s judiciary, government and legal profession.
One mechanism for Taiwan to seek ICC membership is to sign on to the Rome Statute.
The Statute is not a UN treaty, but the UN secretary-general is the administrator of its membership, and it is unclear whether he could or would refuse Taiwan.
Under the second mechanism, Taiwan could unilaterally declare acceptance of ICC jurisdiction over Taiwan’s territory.
Only Ukraine and Palestine have joined by declaration, with Palestine later signing the Rome Statute.
Legal experts said it was not clear how the ICC would respond to a state with undetermined status attempting the same.
Taiwan is not a UN member state and is only recognised by 13 other countries.
“I believe that [rejecting Taiwan] would be extremely risky on the ICC’s part because that would equate to a definitive determination on the question of Taiwan’s statehood and thereby exclude the whole of Taiwan from the reach of international criminal justice,” Chang said.
Beijing is not party to the ICC, and any investigation in the event of an attack would see little cooperation from China, but it still wields global influence.
“I think China could try to undercut the legitimacy of any ICC action by underscoring the selective nature of international criminal justice and criticising it as a tool of Western powers that is applied inconsistently,” Hafetz said. “China would also likely argue that any recognition by the ICC of jurisdiction over Taiwan … is illegitimate.”
With Taiwan heading to presidential and legislative elections, imminent movement on the proposal is unlikely, but the Guardian understands there are high-level discussions taking place in the government.
The Department of Human Rights and Transitional Justice, which is tasked with responding to the annual human rights review, told the Guardian the ICC recommendation needed “more assessment from relevant departments.”
Ford Liao (廖福特), a research professor at Academia Sinica, said there were domestic and international political considerations.
“We have to find first a domestic consensus,” Liao said. “I think before we make a declaration there needs to be some political communication with the ICC and several states who are members, to understand what their views are… I would say European states will play a major part on this issue. They don’t want another Ukraine.”
When reached for comments, the campaign team for the Democratic Progressive Party’s presidential candidate Vice President William Lai (賴清德) said that if elected he would be “happy to see the judicial community continue to discuss any opportunities that can further integrate Taiwan with the international judicial system.”
A spokeswoman for the Taiwan People’s Party said its chairman and presidential candidate Ko Wen-je (柯文哲) believes Taiwan should establish “more connections with the world in all aspects, so as to make Taiwan safer.”
She said the party was “optimistic” about talks on Taiwan signing the Rome Statute and it becoming “an additional security barrier.”
The Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) did not respond to multiple requests for comment.
The Coast Guard Administration (CGA) yesterday said it had deployed patrol vessels to expel a China Coast Guard ship and a Chinese fishing boat near Pratas Island (Dongsha Island, 東沙群島) in the South China Sea. The China Coast Guard vessel was 28 nautical miles (52km) northeast of Pratas at 6:15am on Thursday, approaching the island’s restricted waters, which extend 24 nautical miles from its shoreline, the CGA’s Dongsha-Nansha Branch said in a statement. The Tainan, a 2,000-tonne cutter, was deployed by the CGA to shadow the Chinese ship, which left the area at 2:39pm on Friday, the statement said. At 6:31pm on Friday,
The Chinese People’s Liberation Army Navy’s (PLAN) third aircraft carrier, the Fujian, would pose a steep challenge to Taiwan’s ability to defend itself against a full-scale invasion, a defense expert said yesterday. Institute of National Defense and Security Research analyst Chieh Chung (揭仲) made the comment hours after the PLAN confirmed the carrier recently passed through the Taiwan Strait to conduct “scientific research tests and training missions” in the South China Sea. China has two carriers in operation — the Liaoning and the Shandong — with the Fujian undergoing sea trials. Although the PLAN needs time to train the Fujian’s air wing and
Taiwanese celebrities Hank Chen (陳漢典) and Lulu Huang (黃路梓茵) announced yesterday that they are planning to marry. Huang announced and posted photos of their engagement to her social media pages yesterday morning, joking that the pair were not just doing marketing for a new show, but “really getting married.” “We’ve decided to spend all of our future happy and hilarious moments together,” she wrote. The announcement, which was later confirmed by the talent agency they share, appeared to come as a surprise even to those around them, with veteran TV host Jacky Wu (吳宗憲) saying he was “totally taken aback” by the news. Huang,
The American Institute in Taiwan (AIT) put Taiwan in danger, Ma Ying-jeou Foundation director Hsiao Hsu-tsen (蕭旭岑) said yesterday, hours after the de facto US embassy said that Beijing had misinterpreted World War II-era documents to isolate Taiwan. The AIT’s comments harmed the Republic of China’s (ROC) national interests and contradicted a part of the “six assurances” stipulating that the US would not change its official position on Taiwan’s sovereignty, Hsiao said. The “six assurances,” which were given by then-US president Ronald Reagan to Taiwan in 1982, say that Washington would not set a date for ending arm sales to Taiwan, consult
RSS