The Judicial Yuan should first communicate with the public how artificial intelligence (AI) would assist judges in writing rulings, and what measures it would take to avoid erroneous and biased judgements, before using it in the legal system, legal professionals and legal justice advocates said yesterday.
Representatives from several groups, including the Taiwan Bar Association and Judicial Reform Foundation, have expressed concern after the judicial branch last month announced that it would begin using generative AI to draft rulings on cases involving fraud, money laundering or unsafe driving once it completes a system test this week.
The Judicial Yuan also plans to expand the use of AI in drafting rulings on civil lawsuits involving compensation for damage caused by traffic accidents and debt cancelations and liquidation.
Photo: Chen Yu-fu, Taipei Times
It said the AI system that it would use is “specifically trained to produce drafts for rulings,” rather than being merely a draft generator, adding that the system is “a smart tool that can generate content using corresponding indictments and instantly analyze criminal facts and evidence in them.”
“The system would transform the way judges compose rulings. However, the Judicial Yuan still has many unanswered questions about this major policy change,” the groups said yesterday.
The Judicial Yuan last week said the system was trained using a large number of indictments and court rulings, but it did not indicate the time range from which legal documents were gathered for the training, they said.
The system’s alleged ability to instantly analyze criminal facts and evidence to produce drafts is questionable if it simply generates content for draft rulings from court judgements and indictments and not from relevant files in the cases as well, the groups said.
The Judicial Yuan also failed to explain how a third-party contractor built the database to train the AI system, and whether the data were stored and managed by the contractor or by the Judicial Yuan, they said.
The public has the right to know how the contractor avoids problems caused by inadequate or biased information in the database when tweaking the parameters of the AI system, and how the Judicial Yuan and the contractor would settle liability issues whenever there are disputes, they said.
Although the Judicial Yuan defended the use of AI in the justice system, saying that judges have the ultimate authority to determine the facts, apply the law and sentence in each case, the system might not accurately record changes to the generative content, they said.
“To dismiss the public’s doubts, the Judicial Yuan should offer further explanations on whether judges still have a final say on the factors leading to their judgements, as well as other issues,” they said.
Attorneys, prosecutors and other stakeholders should be allowed to try to access the database that is used to train the AI system, they said, adding that this would allow the public to jointly examine the bias and risks that might exist in the database.
Although AI has been used in other countries to help compile evidence in legal cases, with the quality of the work under strict scrutiny, it has yet to be used in the international community to help judges draft rulings and assist them in making decisions, the groups said.
A Purdue University study showed that 40 percent of people would not be able to detect errors in AI content that has an accuracy rate of less than 50 percent, a phenomenon that has been identified as “artificial hallucination,” the groups said.
“The AI system creates draft rulings after judges click on whether defendants entered a plea deal and which laws were used to rule on the case. While the judges issue rulings, the reasons leading to the rulings are generated by AI, which might contain errors that cannot be detected by users. The Judicial Yuan did not explain how such risks could be avoided,” the groups said.
Meanwhile, technology experts have warned that the extensive use of AI in the US justice system, particularly in helping judges in sentencing based on risks of defendants becoming repeated offenders, might reinforce the prejudice and racial inequality that already exist in the justice system, the groups said.
Using AI to help judges in their rulings could cause them to overlook cultural factors, situations facing the stakeholders and their intent, which are crucial factors for judges to consider when reaching a decision and cannot be reproduced by AI, the groups said.
Taipei and New Taipei City government officials are aiming to have the first phase of the Wanhua-Jungho-Shulin Mass Rapid Transit (MRT) line completed and opened by 2027, following the arrival of the first train set yesterday. The 22km-long Light Green Line would connect four densely populated districts in Taipei and New Taipei City: Wanhua (萬華), Jhonghe (中和), Tucheng (土城) and Shulin (樹林). The first phase of the project would connect Wanhua and Jhonghe districts, with Chiang Kai-shek Memorial Hall and Chukuang (莒光) being the terminal stations. The two municipalities jointly hosted a ceremony for the first train to be used
MILITARY AID: Taiwan has received a first batch of US long-range tactical missiles ahead of schedule, with a second shipment expected to be delivered by 2026 The US’ early delivery of long-range tactical ballistic missiles to Taiwan last month carries political and strategic significance, a military source said yesterday. According to the Ministry of National Defense’s budget report, the batch of military hardware from the US, including 11 sets of M142 High Mobility Artillery Rocket Systems (HIMARS) and 64 MGM-140 Army Tactical Missile Systems, had been scheduled to be delivered to Taiwan between the end of this year and the beginning of next year. However, the first batch arrived last month, earlier than scheduled, with the second batch —18 sets of HIMARS, 20 MGM-140 missiles and 864 M30
Representative to the US Alexander Yui delivered a letter from the government to US president-elect Donald Trump during a meeting with a former Trump administration official, CNN reported yesterday. Yui on Thursday met with former US national security adviser Robert O’Brien over a private lunch in Salt Lake City, Utah, with US Representative Chris Stewart, the Web site of the US cable news channel reported, citing three sources familiar with the matter. “During that lunch the letter was passed along, and then shared with Trump, two of the sources said,” CNN said. O’Brien declined to comment on the lunch, as did the Taipei
A woman who allegedly attacked a high-school student with a utility knife, injuring his face, on a Taipei metro train late on Friday has been transferred to prosecutors, police said yesterday. The incident occurred near MRT Xinpu Station at about 10:17pm on a Bannan Line train headed toward Dingpu, New Taipei City police said. Before police arrived at the station to arrest the suspect, a woman surnamed Wang (王) who is in her early 40s, she had already been subdued by four male passengers, one of whom was an off-duty Taipei police officer, police said. The student, 17, who sustained a cut about