The recently released Taiwanese streaming show Women In Taipei (台北女子圖鑑) is being panned online for its stereotypical depictions of the differences between northern and southern Taiwan, with some people harassing its two screenwriters online.
Adapted from the popular Japanese TV series Tokyo Girl, which aired from 2016 to 2017, Women In Taipei debuted last month on Disney+ with an all-star cast featuring Kuei Lun-mei (桂綸鎂), Wang Po-chieh (王柏傑), Rhydian Vaughan (鳳小岳) and Chang Hsiao-chuan (張孝全).
The drama follows the life of Lin I-shan (林怡姍), played by Kuei. Lin, who was born in Tainan and moved to Taipei for work, struggles with relationships, her job and life as she strives to become the woman she aspires to be.
Photo courtesy of Disney+
The first three episodes that have been aired so far have generated heated discussions about cultural comparisons between urban and rural life, and north and south Taiwan.
Taipei is depicted as a cold and detached concrete jungle with lines such as “authentic Taipei people would not go sticking their noses into other people’s business” or “girls in Taipei are afraid of poverty, ugliness and failure.”
The differences between the north and south in the series are “untrue, hackneyed and stereotypical,” an online commentator said.
To highlight the difference between Tainan’s Yongkang District (永康), where Lin grew up, and Taipei’s Yongkang Street (永康街), where she works, the show incorrectly depicts Yongkang District as rural, showing fish farms that do not exist in the area, people said.
Some people said it was likely the screenwriters have never been to Tainan, while others said the series depicted Tainan residents as slow.
Some people have harassed the screenwriters on social media.
Award-winning screenwriter Wu Luo-ying (吳洛纓) called the behavior “cyberbullying” in a post on Facebook on Saturday, adding that people harassing the writers do not “truly understand the role and decisionmaking power of writers in the film and television industry.”
The production team and the streaming platform should face criticism from the audience as well, she said, adding that screenwriters often have to satisfy demands from executive producers to get paid.
The audience usually praises actors and directors for a hit show, but blame screenwriters for an unsatisfactory one, she said.
People familiar with the show said that some parts of the story were added by the production company, citing a scene in which Lin wears makeup for a job interview that “makes her look like she is not from Taipei” and is rejected for the job.
The negative feedback has generated a wave of memes and discussions on social media, which can be seen as a successful example of “negative marketing,” some people said.
Tu Cheng-che (杜承哲), a doctor at Cheng Ching Hospital’s thoracic surgery division, posted a meme of the show on Facebook featuring six celebrities from Tainan, including K-pop idol Chou Tzu-yu (周子瑜) and supermodel Lin Chi-ling (林志玲).
“I just wanted to show that both Taipei and Tainan are good,” he wrote in the post.
Additional reporting by I Hui-tzu and CNA
NEW AGREEMENT: Malaysia approved imports last year after nearly two years of negotiations and inspections to meet quarantine requirements, officials said Up to 3.6 tonnes of pomeloes from Taiwan cleared Malaysian customs on Friday, in the first shipment of Taiwanese pomeloes to Malaysia. Taiwan-grown pomeloes are popular in domestic and overseas markets for their tender and juicy taste, the Ministry of Agriculture’s Animal and Plant Health Inspection Agency said. The fruit is already exported to Japan, Canada, Hong Kong, Singapore and the Philippines, it added. The agency began applying for access to the Malaysian market in 2023, compiling data on climate suitability, pests and diseases, and post-harvest handling, while also engaging in nearly two years of negotiations with Malaysian authorities and submitting supplementary
PEAK MONTHS: Data showed that on average 25 to 27 typhoons formed in the Pacific and South China seas annually, with about four forming per month in July and October One of three tropical depressions in the Pacific strengthened into a typhoon yesterday afternoon, while two others are expected to become typhoons by today, Central Weather Administration (CWA) forecaster Lee Ming-hsiang (李名翔) said yesterday. The outer circulation of Tropical Depression No. 20, now Typhoon Mitag, has brought light rain to Hualien, Taitung and areas in the south, Lee said, adding that as of 2pm yesterday, Mitag was moving west-northwest at 16kph, but is not expected to directly affect Taiwan. It was possible that Tropical Depression No. 21 would become a typhoon as soon as last night, he said. It was moving in a
Tigerair Taiwan and China Airlines (CAL) today announced that several international flights were canceled or rescheduled due to Typhoon Ragasa. The Central Weather Administration (CWA) has maintained sea and land warnings for the typhoon. Its storm circle reached the Hengchun Peninsula (恆春半島) on Taiwan's southern tip at 11am today. Tigerair Taiwan said it canceled Monday's IT551/IT552 Taoyuan-Da Nang, IT606/IT607 Taoyuan-Busan and IT602 Taoyuan-Seoul Incheon flights. Tomorrow, cancelations include IT603 Seoul Incheon-Taoyuan, as well as flights between Taoyuan and Sapporo, Osaka, Tokyo Narita, Okinawa, Fukuoka, Saga, Tokyo Haneda, Nagoya, Asahikawa and Jeju. On Wednesday, the IT321/IT322 Kaohsiung-Macau round-trip would also be canceled. CAL announced that today's
Three tropical depressions yesterday intensified into tropical storms, with one likely to affect Taiwan as a typhoon, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said. The three storms, named Mitag, Ragasa and Neoguri, were designated as storms No. 17 to 19 for this year, the CWA said. Projected routes indicate that Ragasa is most likely to affect Taiwan, it said. As of 2am today, Ragasa was 1,370km east-southeast of Oluanpi (鵝鑾鼻) on the southernmost tip of Taiwan. It was moving west-northwest before turning northwest, slowing from 11kph to 6kph, the agency said. A sea warning for Ragasa is unlikely before Sunday afternoon, but its outer rim