France’s upper house of parliament on Thursday rejected a bill to ban children aged 16 and younger from attending bullfights, which has sparked emotional debate.
In a 237 to 64 vote, the French Senate dominated by the right rejected the legislation that sought to protect children from “traumatic” scenes, but enraged aficionados of the centuries-old tradition.
French legislation bans cruelty to animals and bullfighting is outlawed in most of France.
Photo: AP Photo
However, corrida is allowed in the south in cities such as Bayonne, Nimes and Beziers where it is regarded as a cultural tradition, despite complaints from activists.
“Is it acceptable for minors to witness the suffering of a living being when their understanding of the values of compassion and benevolence is still being formed?” said Senator Samantha Cazebonne, who authored the bill.
“We have a duty to protect their innocence,” she added.
Another senator, Guillaume Gontard, added: “Adults standing up and applauding blood is an important symbol. And the responsibility of adults is to protect children.”
However, many others spoke in defense of the tradition and some even accused the supporters of the bill of “targeting” bullfighting itself. “Let’s respect our identities, let’s respect our culture and let parents choose how to pass it on!” Senator Laurent Burgoa said.
French Minister of Justice Didier Migaud said the state must not intervene in family matters “at the risk of being paternalistic, or even invasive.”
Although public opinion favors outlawing bullfighting in France, a bid to ban the practice altogether failed in 2022, with a majority of lawmakers wary of stirring up the southern heartlands.
The French National Assembly lower house never voted on that bill.
Many so-called “bull towns” depend on the shows for tourism and see the culture of bull-breeding and the spectacle — idolized by authors and artists from Ernest Hemingway to Pablo Picasso — as part of their way of life.
Anti-bullfight activists slammed the rejection of the bill.
“Once again, France has missed the opportunity to comply with the recommendations of the Committee on the Rights of the Child, which explicitly recommended banning minors from bullfighting and related spectacles,” said Claire Starozinski, president of the Alliance Anticorrida, a group which campaigns for the abolition of bullfighting.
“The best interests of the child have been sacrificed on the altar of tradition, denial and opportunism,” she added.
The Union of French Bullfighting Towns (UVTF) praised the move.
“The Senate has taken an important step on the road to definitive protection of bullfighting in France,” it said in a statement.
“The UVTF is grateful to the senators who have upheld the rights of the bullfighting cultural community,” it said.
Omar Marmoush’s stunning long-range strike on Tuesday upstaged Kevin de Bruyne on the Manchester City great’s Etihad farewell. Marmoush let fly from about 30m to put City ahead in their 3-1 win against AFC Bournemouth in the Premier League. The victory moved Pep Guardiola’s team up to third in the standings and left qualification for the UEFA Champions League in their own hands heading into the last round of the season. “It’s really important. To be in the Champions League after what happened [this season] will be really nice,” the City manager said. De Bruyne was making his final home appearance for City before
TIGHT FINISH: Napoli only needed to do the same as or better than Inter, who won their game against Como 2-0 on the same day, leaving Napoli with a one-point lead The two players who Antonio Conte wanted more than any others secured Napoli their second Serie A title in three years on Friday. Scott McTominay scored with an acrobatic bicycle kick before halftime and Romelu Lukaku doubled the lead with a solo goal after the break in the decisive 2-0 home win over Cagliari. Conte became the first coach to win the Italian championship with three different teams. “Everyone contributed to this — but the coach most of all,” Napoli captain Giovanni Di Lorenzo said. “Napoli needed him to get back on top. He’s phenomenal.” Comparing it to his three Serie A titles won
The journey of Taiwan’s badminton mixed doubles duo Ye Hong-wei and Nicole Chan at the Malaysia Masters in Kuala Lumpur came to an end in the semi-finals yesterday after they suffered a 2-0 loss to China’s Feng Yanzhe and Huang Dongping. Ye, 25, and Chan, 20, teamed up last year and are currently ranked No. 23 in the world. The Taiwanese shuttlers took on China’s second seeds in the mixed doubles event, but proved no match for Feng and Huang, losing the match 10-21, 7-21. In the first half of the first game, the pairings were neck and neck at 6-7 until Ye
SSC Napoli coach Antonio Conte has dragged the team back from disaster and restored them to the top of Italian Serie A, but his future at the Scudetto winners is in doubt even after a triumphant season. The fiery 55-year-old has exceeded preseason expectations and bolstered his reputation as a serial winner by guiding Napoli to their fourth Scudetto, and second in three seasons. However, he might well be on his way in the summer after just one season at the helm as his charged relationship with Napoli owner Aurelio De Laurentiis has simmered throughout the campaign. Conte has said
RSS