Foreign residents have expressed dissatisfaction with the outcome of a well-publicized legal case in which US citizen Richard Hartzell (
Diane Baker, a US citizen living in Taipei for the past 13 years, said Hartzell's case had been an exception and had not led to a change in the legislation which requires foreigners to renew their driver's license every year.
"How could they [the Motor Vehicle Supervision Department] (MVSD,
Baker said that when she first applied for a driver's license in 1991, it had been issued for seven years. But when it came up for renewal in 1998, it was "only good for one year."
Baker is not alone in her frustrations.
Prior to a change in the law in 1998, any foreigner residing in Taiwan with a legitimate alien resident certificate (ARC) was eligible to apply for a driver's license good for six years -- the same as local Taiwanese citizens.
The law was changed by the Ministry of Transportation and Communications (MOTC) to prevent foreigners who stay in Taiwan illegally from using their driver's licenses as their identification cards.
Under the new law a foreigner's driver's license expires at the same time as his or her ARC.
In Hartzell's case, he had to have his driver's license renewed every year because his ARC was valid for just one year.
However, Baker's situation is different.
"My ARC is valid for two years, but they insisted on issuing me a driver's license only good for one year. The implementation of the regulation really depends on who processes your papers. Results may vary according to different time and people. It is ridiculous," said Baker.
Hartzell's victory was not gained easily. He went through three appeals before he earned his six-year driver's license. Though he actually won his case in the first two petitions at the Taipei City government's Commission for Examining and Petitions and Appeals (CEPA,
"The existing regulation is merely an administrative order, which lacks any legal binding. We therefore thought there was room for Hartzell to argue. Based on the principle of international mutual benefits, there should not be any grounds to have such a restriction on the issuance of driver's licenses to foreign residents in Taiwan," said a CEPA official.
Documents show that there are no restrictions in the US to restrain the issuance of driver's licenses to Taiwanese residing in the US. Any Taiwanese, as long as he/she is a legal resident of the country, is qualified to apply for an American driver's license.
Hsu Hsiu-lung (徐秀龍), an official of the Taipei Bureau of Transportation -- the direct supervisory unit of the MVSD -- said they had handled the case based on MOTC regulations.
"But ironically, the CEPA stood up for the petitioner. How can we enforce the law in the future if we can not stand our ground by observing the regulations?" added Hsu.
The case highlights the sometimes contradictory stances between the central and local governments in terms of law enforcement.
When quizzed about the episodes, an MOTC official said that he had not been informed of the case. "If such an incident occurred, it should be considered as an exceptional case," he said. "But there will be no more exceptions like this, because we will turn this administrative order into a legal issue to avoid any further ambiguity."
The legislation, however, raises questions about the government's professed drive toward internalization and globalization.
"We have been dealing with a barrage of complaints from foreigners. We [the clerks] do not benefit from this regulation either. Carrying out current regulations means we have to undertake a heavier workload. Why not make our lives easier by sticking to the old rule?" said an employee of the Kaohsiung City government.
"I will not support this legislation," said DPP lawmaker Chen Chi-mai (
"The reason given by the MOTC -- to curb unlawful foreign residents to use their driver's licenses as identification cards -- is preposterous. In Taiwan, everyone knows that driver's licenses are not the same as identification cards," added Chen.
Taiwan’s Lee Chia-hao (李佳豪) on Sunday won a silver medal at the All England Open Badminton Championships in Birmingham, England, a career best. Lee, 25, took silver in the final of the men’s singles against world No. 1 Shi Yuqi (石宇奇) of China, who won 21-17, 21-19 in a tough match that lasted 51 minutes. After the match, the Taiwanese player, who ranks No. 22 in the world, said it felt unreal to be challenging an opponent of Shi’s caliber. “I had to be in peak form, and constantly switch my rhythm and tactics in order to score points effectively,” he said. Lee got
‘CROWN JEWEL’: Washington ‘can delay and deter’ Chinese President Xi Jinping’s plans for Taiwan, but it is ‘a very delicate situation there,’ the secretary of state said US President Donald Trump is opposed to any change to Taiwan’s “status quo” by force or extortion and would maintain that policy, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio told the Hugh Hewitt Show host on Wednesday. The US’ policy is to maintain Taiwan’s “status quo” and to oppose any changes in the situation by force or extortion, Rubio said. Hewitt asked Rubio about the significance of Trump earlier this month speaking with Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (台積電) chairman C.C. Wei (魏哲家) at the White House, a meeting that Hewitt described as a “big deal.” Asked whether the meeting was an indication of the
‘RELATIVELY STRONG LANGUAGE’: An expert said the state department has not softened its language on China and was ‘probably a little more Taiwan supportive’ China’s latest drills near Taiwan on Monday were “brazen and irresponsible threats,” a US Department of State spokesperson said on Tuesday, while reiterating Washington’s decades-long support of Taipei. “China cannot credibly claim to be a ‘force for stability in a turbulent world’ while issuing brazen and irresponsible threats toward Taiwan,” the unnamed spokesperson said in an e-mailed response to media queries. Washington’s enduring commitment to Taiwan will continue as it has for 45 years and the US “will continue to support Taiwan in the face of China’s military, economic, informational and diplomatic pressure campaign,” the e-mail said. “Alongside our international partners, we firmly
KAOHSIUNG CEREMONY: The contract chipmaker is planning to build 5 fabs in the southern city to gradually expand its 2-nanometer chip capacity Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電), the world’s biggest contract chipmaker, yesterday confirmed that it plans to hold a ceremony on March 31 to unveil a capacity expansion plan for its most advanced 2-nanometer chips in Kaohsiung, demonstrating its commitment to further investment at home. The ceremony is to be hosted by TSMC cochief operating officer Y.P. Chyn (秦永沛). It did not disclose whether Premier Cho Jung-tai (卓榮泰) and high-ranking government officials would attend the ceremony. More details are to be released next week, it said. The chipmaker’s latest move came after its announcement earlier this month of an additional US$100 billion
RSS