Thu, Dec 09, 1999 page3

• Kaohsiung Eight trial pointed way to Taiwan's future

  SYMBOLIC VICTORY Although the court-martial of the Kaohsiung Eight in 1980 ended with their being given lengthy prison sentences, the trial was seen as a victory

  • By Irene Lin / STAFF REPORTER
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  At the time of their arrest, much of the general public saw the so-called Kaohsiung Eight -- the main group of defendants charged with fomenting the 1979 Kaohsiung Incident -- as anti-social criminals who had conspired to overthrow the government.

  Ironically, however, it was the public trial before a martial law court that ultimately made it possible for six men and two women accused to alter their images as criminals and, most importantly, to convey the idea -- the dream -- of an independent Taiwan to the public.

  In practical terms, it was a court-martial (Taiwan was under martial law at the time) on charges of sedition, which led to lengthy jail terms for the eight. However, participants believed that via an open trial, they had succeeded in raising public awareness of the right to self-determination for both themselves and Taiwan.

  

  Shih Ming-teh, one of the Kaohsiung Eight -- six men and two women -- during the court-martial trial in 1980. Shih is currently a DPP legislator.

  FILE PHOTO

  "Over eighteen million Taiwan people have to be awakened to the fact that Taiwan is a de facto independent country, which was an untold truth for thirty years," Shih Ming-teh (施明德), one of the eight accused, told the court during the military trial, which took place March 18-28, 1980.

  "The reason we started Formosa magazine (美麗島) was to press the government to make improvements on issues of civilian living standards, and issues of democratic reform," Shih, who is now a DPP lawmaker, said. "Publishing the magazine is a way to push for democracy."

  Three months after the Kaoh-siung Incident -- a large march which eventually turned violent when police and demonstrators clashed -- the eight accused were tried by a military court for their roles in the incident.

  Under the charge they were facing -- sedition -- the death penalty was mandatory. However, none were sentenced to death -- even though Shih had defiantly requested it for himself during his testimony; he received a life sentence instead. The other seven sentences ranged from 10 to 14 years' imprisonment.

  However, the sentences were actually seen as a victory by the team of defense lawyers.

  "At that time, anyone tried by a military court was supposed to get the death sentence, unless granted clemency by the president," said Chen Chi-sen (3紕~2), an attorney who led the defense team of 15 lawyers. "We couldn't let them die -- it was our only goal to keep these people alive. For that reason, we felt we had won the case."

  Confessions extracted prior to the trial were used as primary evidence against the eight accused. Throughout the trial, however, the defense lawyers kept challenging the legality of the confessions, hinting that they were extracted through torture or other abusive means.

  Chen Shui-bian (3?糮), now a DPP presidential candidate but then the youngest member of the defense team, was one of the most outspoken on this point.

  "Your honor, please investigate the legality of the confessions," he said at one stage. "If they were extracted by torture, not given of their own free will, the charges brought against the accused are clearly dubious and we can stop ourselves from wasting any more time debating the facts of this case."

  Chen's use of the word "torture" reportedly stunned the court into a few moments of silence as the audacity of his remarks sank in. It was a seminal moment, and from then on, the rest of the defense team took turns raising questions about the legality of the confessions.

  Chen Chi-sen said the primary aim of the defense strategy was to convince the court of the inadmissibility of the confessions. But he admitted that they were concerned about pushing the issue too far, in case it provoked a backlash.

  "We had to overturn their confessions, which were seen as very powerful evidence. But we also had to restrain ourselves from going too far. Otherwise, our efforts would have been in vain," Chen said.

  Although handled by a military court, it was an open trial which the press was allowed to cover. During the nine-day trial, newspaper sales generally rose in proportion to coverage given to the trial, sparking intense competition between the two major dailies, China Times and the United Daily News.

  The intense media coverage had a deep impact on the public's perception of the accused and the incident itself. In reading newspaper reports of the trial, few failed to be impressed with the well-organized and well-presented arguments put forward by the accused and their defense lawyers.

  Above all, many people, especially the younger generation, grew inspired by the opposition activists' passionate pursuit of the belief that the people of Taiwan, not China or the US, should have the final say over their own fate.

  The current Taipei County Commissioner Su Tseng-chang (蘇-s昌), a member of the defense team, summed up the trial's impact on society succinctly: "It allowed the public to hear the truth about the incident. And when more and more people came out to support our ideals, the KMT was forced to realize it was facing an irresistible trend."

  For your information

  Trial of the Kaohsiung Eight

  When: March 18-28, 1980 The accused: *Huang Hsin-chieh *Lin Hung-hsuan *Annette Lu *Shih Ming-teh *Yao Chia-wen *Chang Chun-hung *Chen Chu *Lin Yi-hsiung Charge: Attempted sedition. Formosa magazine and the Kaohsiung Incident were a means used by the accused to assemble civilians in an attempt to overthrow the government. Sentences: Shih: life sentence Huang: 14-year imprisonment
• Most Popular

  • 1

    International concerns raised after Lai’s flight blocked

  • 2

    Actor Darren Wang handed six months for obtaining others’ personal data

  • 3

    Pet cats outnumber pet dogs, survey shows

  • 4

    Starlink reluctant to operate in Taiwan

  • 5

    China teases new aircraft carrier, vows to build up islands