The Constitutional Court yesterday struck down a rule requiring female firefighters to be at least 1.6m tall, saying that it contravened the Constitution.
Rules governing the civil service entrance examination for police and firefighters stipulate a height requirement of 1.65m for men and 1.6m for women, or 1.58m and 1.55m respectively for indigenous male and female candidates.
In 2018, a woman surnamed Chen (陳) passed the certification test for firefighters, but was eliminated from the program after a second physical exam showed her to be 1.1cm short of the height requirement.
Photo: Liao Yao-tung, Taipei Times
She filed an administrative appeal and after it was dismissed, asked the Constitutional Court to rule on the matter, arguing that the height requirement and being told to take a second physical examination contravened her rights.
Chen’s attorney during oral arguments on Jan. 16 said that the height limits have no scientific basis and deprived the plaintiff of her right to join the civil service.
The second physical exam ordered by Chen’s instructors at the academy stemmed from the provision of the regulation allowing such tests to be taken again “for cause,” a broad and vague phrase that infringes on the principle of legal clarity, her attorney said.
Lawyers representing the Ministry of Examination and the Ministry of the Interior said that the height requirement was to help ensure police and firefighters are physically capable of performing their duties and can use standard-issue equipment.
National Fire Agency Director-General Hsiao Huan-chang (蕭煥章) told the court that firefighters are expected to meet physical standards to minimize operational risks and that short people are not suitable for the job.
Indigenous candidates have separate height standards because they are shorter on average than other Taiwanese, Hsiao said, adding that using a common standard could be racially discriminatory.
However, the court said that the height limits would exclude female candidates from becoming first responders more often than it would males, contravening the equal protection principle in Article 8 of the Constitution.
The height requirement must be removed within a year of the judgement, it said.
The other part of the lawsuit concerning the rule authorizing government departments to order a second physical exam for cause was dismissed, as the court did not find the meaning of “cause” to be unclear.
Chen said that she wanted to become a firefighter to help people such as her ill mother, adding that she was dumbstruck that she could be barred from joining the service due to her height.
LEVERAGE: China did not ‘need to fire a shot’ to deny Taiwan airspace over Africa when it owns ‘half the continent’s debt,’ a US official said, calling it economic warfare The EU has raised concerns about overflight rights following the delay of President William Lai’s (賴清德) planned state visit to the Kingdom of Eswatini after three African nations denied overflight clearance for his charter at the last minute. Taiwanese allies Paraguay and Saint Kitts and Nevis, as well as several US lawmakers and the Inter-Parliamentary Alliance on China (IPAC) condemned China for allegedly pressuring the countries. Lai was scheduled to fly directly to Taiwan’s only African ally from yesterday to Sunday to celebrate the 40th anniversary of King Mswati III’s accession and his 58th birthday, but Seychelles, Mauritius and Madagascar suddenly revoked
The number of pet cats in Taiwan surpassed that of pet dogs for the first time last year, reaching 1,742,033, a 32.8 percent increase from 2023, the Ministry of Agriculture said yesterday, citing a survey. By contrast, the number of pet dogs declined slightly by 1.2 percent over the same period to 1,462,528, the ministry said. Despite the shift, households with dogs still slightly outnumber those with cats by 1.2 percent. However, while the number of households with multiple dogs has remained relatively stable, households keeping more than two cats have increased, contributing to the overall rise in the feline population. The trend
China on Wednesday teased in a video an aircraft carrier that could be its fourth, and the first using nuclear power, while making an allusion to Taiwan and vowing to further build up its islands, as it looks to boost maritime power, secure resources and bolster territorial claims. The video, issued on the eve of the 77th founding anniversary of the Chinese People’s Liberation Army Navy, featured fictional officers with names that are homophones of three commissioned aircraft carriers, the Liaoning (遼寧), Shandong (山東) and Fujian (福建). Titled Into the Deep, it showed a 19-year-old named “Hejian” (何劍) joining the group, sparking
ESWATINI TRIP: The ‘irresponsible actions’ of three African nations set a dangerous precedent and they should be held accountable, a US representative said The US Senate Foreign Relations Committee on Thursday urged Washington not to normalize Chinese pressure, while a US lawmaker called on the US government to hold countries accountable for yielding to Beijing’s pressure to block President William Lai’s (賴清德) planned trip to Eswatini. Lai had been scheduled to visit Eswatini to attend birthday events for King Mswati III of Eswatini this week, but on Tuesday, the eve of his planned departure on Wednesday, the Presidential Office said the trip was “suspended” after the Seychelles, Mauritius and Madagascar unexpectedly withdrew overflight permission. “China reportedly pressured Mauritius, Seychelles, and Madagascar to deny airspace access
RSS