A US court has dealt a new blow to the healthcare reform law seen as US President Barack Obama’s proudest domestic achievement, declaring its centerpiece provision unconstitutional.
The Eleventh Circuit appeals court, based in Atlanta, ruled on Friday that the law’s individual mandate, which requires everyone to own health insurance in the US’ mostly private system or pay a penalty, exceeded the US Congress’ powers.
However, the court ruled that the remainder of the healthcare law, which extended coverage to an extra 32 million people and was a long-held dream of Democrats, was within the bounds of the US Constitution.
About 50 million Americans lack basic health insurance. As a result, hospitals and taxpayers are forced to pay about US$43 billion a year to cover the costs of those who are treated but cannot pay.
The ruling increased the likelihood that the US Supreme Court will be called upon to rule on the healthcare law’s constitutionality, possibly as soon as next year, in the heat of a presidential election campaign.
Republicans strongly oppose the law, which they have dubbed “Obamacare,” as an infringement on individual liberty, and have sworn to repeal it.
By a 2-1 margin, the Eleventh Circuit affirmed a ruling by a lower Florida court that the individual mandate was unconstitutional, in a case brought by 26 state governors and attorneys general, most of them Republican.
However, the judges overturned another part of the Florida court’s ruling that the entire healthcare law, passed last year, was unconstitutional.
“The individual mandate exceeds Congress’s enumerated commerce power and is unconstitutional,” Chief Judge Joel Dubina wrote. “This economic mandate represents a wholly novel and potentially unbounded assertion of congressional authority: the ability to compel Americans to purchase an expensive health insurance product they have elected not to buy, and to make them re-purchase that insurance product every month for their entire lives.”
The White House said it strongly disagreed with the decision and was confident that the law would ultimately be upheld as constitutional.
It also pointed out that four courts, including the Sixth Court of Appeals, had endorsed the law.
“Those who claim this provision exceeds Congress’ power to regulate interstate commerce are incorrect,” said Stephanie Cutter, a special assistant to Obama.
She said those who chose not to buy insurance in the US private medical system hurt everyone else, because taxpayers end up subsidizing their care when the uninsured are taken to emergency rooms.
The White House also justifies the individual mandate by saying that without it people would wait until they get sick to apply for coverage, which would cause insurance premiums to rise.
However, the ruling cheered Republicans, who see the healthcare law as an unacceptable intrusion by government into individual freedoms.
A Ministry of Foreign Affairs official yesterday said that a delegation that visited China for an APEC meeting did not receive any kind of treatment that downgraded Taiwan’s sovereignty. Department of International Organizations Director-General Jonathan Sun (孫儉元) said that he and a group of ministry officials visited Shenzhen, China, to attend the APEC Informal Senior Officials’ Meeting last month. The trip went “smoothly and safely” for all Taiwanese delegates, as the Chinese side arranged the trip in accordance with long-standing practices, Sun said at the ministry’s weekly briefing. The Taiwanese group did not encounter any political suppression, he said. Sun made the remarks when
The Taiwanese passport ranked 33rd in a global listing of passports by convenience this month, rising three places from last month’s ranking, but matching its position in January last year. The Henley Passport Index, an international ranking of passports by the number of designations its holder can travel to without a visa, showed that the Taiwan passport enables holders to travel to 139 countries and territories without a visa. Singapore’s passport was ranked the most powerful with visa-free access to 192 destinations out of 227, according to the index published on Tuesday by UK-based migration investment consultancy firm Henley and Partners. Japan’s and
BROAD AGREEMENT: The two are nearing a trade deal to reduce Taiwan’s tariff to 15% and a commitment for TSMC to build five more fabs, a ‘New York Times’ report said Taiwan and the US have reached a broad consensus on a trade deal, the Executive Yuan’s Office of Trade Negotiations said yesterday, after a report said that Washington is set to reduce Taiwan’s tariff rate to 15 percent. The New York Times on Monday reported that the two nations are nearing a trade deal to reduce Taiwan’s tariff rate to 15 percent and commit Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) to building at least five more facilities in the US. “The agreement, which has been under negotiation for months, is being legally scrubbed and could be announced this month,” the paper said,
MIXED SOURCING: While Taiwan is expanding domestic production, it also sources munitions overseas, as some, like M855 rounds, are cheaper than locally made ones Taiwan and the US plan to jointly produce 155mm artillery shells, as the munition is in high demand due to the Ukraine-Russia war and should be useful in Taiwan’s self-defense, Armaments Bureau Director-General Lieutenant General Lin Wen-hsiang (林文祥) told lawmakers in Taipei yesterday. Lin was responding to questions about Taiwan’s partnership with allies in producing munitions at a meeting of the legislature’s Foreign Affairs and National Defense Committee. Given the intense demand for 155mm artillery shells in Ukraine’s defense against the Russian invasion, and in light of Taiwan’s own defensive needs, Taipei and Washington plan to jointly produce 155mm shells, said Lin,
RSS