In a climax to one of the most controversial legal sagas in Taiwan's history, three men dubbed the Hsichih Trio walked free from the Taiwan High Court yesterday after the court overturned their murder convictions and ruled that they should be released immediately.
But the judge indicated that their ordeal is not quite over.
PHOTO: SEAN CHAO, TAIPEI TIMES
"The court has decided to overturn the murder convictions of the defendants and they shall be released immediately," Judge Yeh Teng-juei (
"But the court also decided to ban them from changing addresses or traveling outside the country until the final verdict in this case is available," Yeh said.
The prosecution has 20 days to decide whether to appeal after receiving their copy of the verdict. The Supreme Court normally hears appeals in such cases within a week after an appeal is requested.
The No. 17 courtroom burst into loud applause when Yeh finished reading the verdict that released Su Chien-ho (蘇建和), Liu Bing-lang (劉秉郎) and Chuang Lin-hsun (莊林勳).
The trio had been incarcerated at the Taipei Detention House for more than 11 years. All three were 19 years old when first detained.
Tsai Kuo-tsai (
"First of all, the fingerprints and hair collected at the crime scene did not match theirs. Their individual testimonies did not match either," Tsai said. "In addition, the court believed that the trio had no connection to the kitchen knife believed to have been the murder weapon."
That knife was "lost" during legal hearings involving another suspect in the case, Wang Wen-hsiao (
Wang was executed on Jan. 11, 1992, under Military Law after confessing and pleading guilty to the murder.
Immediately after yesterday's hearing, the plaintiffs' and the defendants' lawyers held press conferences in the conference room of the Taiwan Bar Association next to the court building.
"We sincerely hope that this is the last miscarriage of justice in Taiwan," said defense counsel Su You-chen (
The defendants said at Su's press conference that they were grateful for the result but it had been too long in coming.
"I have given most of my youth for this case and I am glad that we were finally proved innocent today," said Su Chien-ho.
Asked whether he was worried that the plaintiffs may appeal, Su said he had nothing to fear.
"The truth is the truth. My statement will remain the same even if there is another hearing or trial," he said.
"It was a bit late but it finally came," Liu said.
Chuang simply stood up, bowed and said, "Thank you all for your support."
Lin Hsien-tung (
"A lot of people care about this case for humanitarian reasons. But I am asking the public to try to understand how the victims' families feel," Yang said.
The plaintiffs are Wu Tang-tang (吳唐糖) and Wu Tang-chieh (吳唐接) -- mother and older brother respectively of victim Wu Ming-han (吳銘漢) -- and Wu Tung-yen (吳東諺), 17-year-old handicapped son of Wu Ming-han and his wife, Yeh Ying-lan (葉盈蘭), who was murdered with him.
"If they are innocent, then who are the murderers?" asked Wu Tang-tang.
An unclear forensic report and the weakness of the evidence against the trio were the main focuses of controversy in the case.
These incongruities prompted the former state public prosecutor-general, Chen Han (陳涵), to file three extraordinary appeals to the Supreme Court on the trio's behalf.
In March 1991, Wu and Yeh were brutally murdered in their apartment home in Hsichih, Taipei County.
The police arrested four suspects, Su, Liu, Chuang and Wang, on Aug. 14, 1991.
Prosecutors charged them with murder on Oct. 4 of that year.
Su, Liu and Chuang were sentenced to death after the first trial at the Shihlin District Court on Feb. 18, 1992.
Other than Chen's three requests for extraordinary appeals -- all of which failed to sway the courts to change the verdict from guilty to not guilty -- defense counsel Su You-chen also filed an appeal to the Supreme Court on Aug. 21, 1998.
On Sept. 23, 1999, the Supreme Court accepted the appeal and ordered the Taiwan High Court to prepare to hold rehearings and to have a retrial. Yesterday's ruling was the culmination of that ordered retrial.
The first rehearing was held on Nov. 16, 2000.
UKRAINE, NVIDIA: The US leader said the subject of Russia’s war had come up ‘very strongly,’ while Jenson Huang was hoping that the conversation was good Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) and US President Donald Trump had differing takes following their meeting in Busan, South Korea, yesterday. Xi said that the two sides should complete follow-up work as soon as possible to deliver tangible results that would provide “peace of mind” to China, the US and the rest of the world, while Trump hailed the “great success” of the talks. The two discussed trade, including a deal to reduce tariffs slapped on China for its role in the fentanyl trade, as well as cooperation in ending the war in Ukraine, among other issues, but they did not mention
Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi yesterday lavished US President Donald Trump with praise and vows of a “golden age” of ties on his visit to Tokyo, before inking a deal with Washington aimed at securing critical minerals. Takaichi — Japan’s first female prime minister — pulled out all the stops for Trump in her opening test on the international stage and even announced that she would nominate him for a Nobel Peace Prize, the White House said. Trump has become increasingly focused on the Nobel since his return to power in January and claims to have ended several conflicts around the world,
CALL FOR SUPPORT: President William Lai called on lawmakers across party lines to ensure the livelihood of Taiwanese and that national security is protected President William Lai (賴清德) yesterday called for bipartisan support for Taiwan’s investment in self-defense capabilities at the christening and launch of two coast guard vessels at CSBC Corp, Taiwan’s (台灣國際造船) shipyard in Kaohsiung. The Taipei (台北) is the fourth and final ship of the Chiayi-class offshore patrol vessels, and the Siraya (西拉雅) is the Coast Guard Administration’s (CGA) first-ever ocean patrol vessel, the government said. The Taipei is the fourth and final ship of the Chiayi-class offshore patrol vessels with a displacement of about 4,000 tonnes, Lai said. This ship class was ordered as a result of former president Tsai Ing-wen’s (蔡英文) 2018
GLOBAL PROJECT: Underseas cables ‘are the nervous system of democratic connectivity,’ which is under stress, Member of the European Parliament Rihards Kols said The government yesterday launched an initiative to promote global cooperation on improved security of undersea cables, following reported disruptions of such cables near Taiwan and around the world. The Management Initiative on International Undersea Cables aims to “bring together stakeholders, align standards, promote best practices and turn shared concerns into beneficial cooperation,” Minister of Foreign Affairs Lin Chia-lung (林佳龍) said at a seminar in Taipei. The project would be known as “RISK,” an acronym for risk mitigation, information sharing, systemic reform and knowledge building, he said at the seminar, titled “Taiwan-Europe Subsea Cable Security Cooperation Forum.” Taiwan sits at a vital junction on
RSS