Covert meetings, whispered threats and mysterious phone calls — warnings of reprisals by authorities from shadowy messengers are hounding Hong Kong’s civil society as China flattens a pro-democracy movement.
Unlike the Chinese mainland, Hong Kong long hosted a vibrant landscape of citizens’ groups who cultivated rights advocacy, union mobilization and civil disobedience as a key fabric of the once-outspoken city.
But a national security law imposed by Beijing in 2020 to snuff out dissent has knee-capped the sector, leaving people fearful that the law’s vaguely defined crimes will be used to target their work.
Photo: AFP
More than 50 civil society groups specializing on issues ranging from labor to education have since announced their closure or been shuttered after national security arrests.
Often the pre-emptive shutdowns came after staff were subjected to a shadowy campaign of threats and intimidation, according to five people with firsthand knowledge.
The warnings typically arrived via phone calls and messages from so-called “middlemen,” who assumed a conversational tone while revealing knowledge of each recipient’s personal life. Some came face to face.
Veteran NGO worker Mario — using a pseudonym due to fears for his safety — said his colleagues received disconcerting messages from several middlemen last summer.
“They would tell you different stories but at some point the conversation would reach the same conclusion: you must shut down,” he said.
A month after first contact, Mario’s organization made the decision to close.
‘WE RESPECT CIVIL SOCIETY’
Hong Kong’s civil society groups have in recent years been labeled “anti-China elements” by officials and state media.
Beijing has made clear it believes they were a key part of democracy protests that exploded in 2019 with huge rallies and frequent clashes with police. The national security law’s vague language, combined with the middlemen’s warnings, suddenly made the threat of lengthy jail terms very real for people like Mario.
“Every normal thing civil society did in the past three decades is now subject to political reprisal,” he said.
Shuttered organizations range from the city’s largest trade union to Amnesty International, as well as the Hong Kong Alliance — which used to organize the annual vigil remembering victims of China’s Tiananmen Square crackdown in 1989.
Hong Kong’s leader Carrie Lam (林鄭月娥) has repeatedly denied that a deliberate campaign targeting organizations is taking place, insisting “we respect civil society.”
China’s ruling Communist Party and its Liaison Office in Hong Kong have openly accused some groups of violating the law, calling the collapse of these organizations “a choice of their own making.”
Both China’s Public Security Ministry and its Hong Kong and Macau Affairs Office did not respond to requests for comment.
The city’s Security Bureau and the Committee for Safeguarding National Security also declined to comment on what they called “allegations by individuals.”
NEW SHERIFF IN TOWN
Under a “One Country, Two Systems” principle that Beijing agreed to before the 1997 handover by Britain, Hong Kong was allowed to retain key freedoms and autonomy for 50 years.
These included the city being left to police itself using its own laws.
The national security law changed all that, toppling the legal firewall that existed between the financial hub and Beijing.
Among the legislation’s many precedent-setting provisions was a clause empowering the mainland’s security apparatus to operate openly in Hong Kong.
Days after the law’s enactment, mainland security officials requisitioned a hotel for their staff — unbound by local laws — as they conducted investigations on perceived threats to China.
The middlemen are regarded as an extension of this new sheriff in town, according to two sources who said they had been contacted directly.
Both described similar face-to-face meetings but asked for key details to be omitted to maintain anonymity. The meetings were held in a pre-booked private room at public businesses and featured a Cantonese-speaking man claiming to be a mainland security agent. The conversations stayed largely polite but could flip — with one source saying the agent he met sounded at times “as if he was interrogating me.”
Another said the middleman asked what he thought about disbanding his group, citing various possible security law breaches.
“At first I thought it would be silly to disband when we didn’t know what offenses we have committed,” he said. “But when he could name a very specific charge, we started to worry.”
The messengers possessed personal information, both recalled, dropping details of their relatives and daily habits into conversation.
It wasn’t possible to independently verify the sources’ accounts.
‘APPROACH OF INTIMIDATION’
The use of middlemen to channel information and deliver political messages is not new. Beijing’s presence in Hong Kong is maintained through the Liaison Office, which has played an increasingly prominent advisory role in recent years — at times calling in local establishment politicians to be briefed by Chinese officials.
For opposition figures, Beijing preferred using middlemen, according to Ted Hui (許志?), a former opposition lawmaker now in Australia.
Such meetings were commonplace — mainly as intelligence-gathering for authorities’ decisions — until one year before the 2019 protests, he said.
“But after the security law came in, it became an approach of intimidation... So under the table, they can send those middlemen to say things the government cannot openly say.”
More than 160 people have been arrested under the national security law so far — most of them opposition politicians, journalists and rights workers.
Against the backdrop of these detentions, the slow-burn whisper campaign has been an effective tool to shut down organizations critical of the government.
“We are so inexperienced that many of us decided to disband under these threats,” said Connie, a rights worker who said she received a call from a stranger giving her a deadline to quit.
Oliver, another rights worker, said he got a text message from someone posing as a “friend” warning he could be arrested.
With so many other groups shuttering and new arrests each month, Oliver felt compelled to take the threat seriously and decided to fold. “If all those big groups... were not spared, how could you be?”
On Facebook a friend posted a dashcam video of a vehicle driving through the ash-colored wasteland of what was once Taroko Gorge. A crane appears in the video, and suddenly it becomes clear: the video is in color, not black and white. The magnitude 7.2 earthquake’s destruction on April 3 around and above Taroko and its reverberations across an area heavily dependent on tourism have largely vanished from the international press discussions as the news cycle moves on, but local residents still live with its consequences every day. For example, with the damage to the road corridors between Yilan and
Gaotai Mountain (高台山) and the three Daotian Peaks (小中大島田山回來) afford visitors a truly rewarding hike in Hsinchu County (新竹). Located in the foothills just beyond the charming Neiwan Old Street (內灣老街), the hike is well suited for hikers in a fair to good physical condition. It’s also a good introduction to the foothills of northwest Taiwan, along with some more adventurous — but still not terribly dangerous — rope and scrambling sections. As a bonus, there are Japanese ruins, hot springs and river tracing destinations such as Meihua Waterfall (梅花瀑布) and Bilin Waterfall (比麟瀑布) all located nearby. WHISPERING PINES The first section of
With William Lai’s (賴清德) presidential inauguration coming up on May 20, both sides of the Taiwan Strait have been signaling each other, possibly about re-opening lines of communication. For that to happen, there are two ways this could happen, one very difficult to achieve and the other dangerous. During his presidential campaign and since Lai has repeatedly expressed his hope to re-establish communication based on equality and mutual respect, and even said he hoped to meet with Chinese leader Xi Jinping (習近平) over beef noodles and bubble tea. More dramatically, as explored in the May 2 edition of this column,
Tiffany Chang (張芳瑜) is a force to be reckoned with. Crowned Miss Taiwanese American in 2022, she made history last year as the first Taiwanese winner of Miss Asia USA. She’s also a STEM student at Stanford and an aspiring philanthropist — the kind of impressive accolades that has earned her the moniker “light of Taiwan.” At the end of March, Chang returned to Taipei, to “see the people that support me because ultimately that’s what made me win.” She says her Taiwanese supporters shower her with praise: “you inspire us, and you make us feel proud of our Taiwanese heritage,”