Lin Tzu-yi (林祖儀) had already placed the order for a full page ad in the New York Times when the criticisms began. It was supposed to be due on Saturday for Monday’s paper, but he and other organizers had to delay the ad to address the concerns.
The original idea was to crowdfund an immediate response to WHO Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus publicly accusing Taiwan of launching a “racist campaign” against him. Tedros’ comments came in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic. Taiwan has done a stellar job in containing the virus despite still being barred from the WHO.
“At first, we just wanted to strike back at Tedros,” Lin tells the Taipei Times.
Screengrab from https://taiwancanhelp.us/
Within hours, the campaign raised over NT$19 million, nearly five times its goal of NT$4 million, with 26,980 people donating and, at one point, crashing the Web site zeczec.com, the crowdfunding platform. Although people publicly questioning the effectiveness of the ad and the timing of it in the middle of a global pandemic, the team pushed through while closely interacting with its supporters, many of whom felt it would make Taiwan seem petty to just sling mud back at Tedros and the organization he heads.
Thousands of messages and comments later, the ad that appeared yesterday in both print and online did not mention Tedros at all, instead invoking the government’s favorite phrase “Taiwan Can Help” while highlighting Taiwan’s isolation from the WHO and commenting on how the nation can share its expertise in fighting the pandemic. An interactive Web site, www.taiwancanhelp.us, was also launched, and Lin says this is just the beginning as the team will collaborate with other interested parties to continue to raise international awareness for Taiwan.
Lin says the surplus cash will be divided between international and domestic COVID-19 relief efforts as well as additional Internet advertising.
Screengrab from https://taiwancanhelp.us/
“The strength of the few of us organizers is very limited,” Lin says in response to the criticism. “There are surely better ways to go about this that we haven’t thought of. I hope that more people can pitch in, as there’s a lot more to do. This is just the beginning.”
TONING IT DOWN
Due to the political influence of China, Taiwan is not a member of the WHO and has been barred from attending the World Health Assembly since the Democratic Progressive Party took power in 2016.
Photo: CNA
Taiwan’s relationship with the WHO worsened when the pandemic broke out and the nation continued to be shut out of the organization despite its success in combating the virus.
Taiwan’s political isolation is old news, but netizens seemed especially annoyed when Tedros accused Taiwan of racist campaigns against him during a press conference in Geneva on Wednesday last week. President Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) not only slammed the claims as baseless but invited him to visit the country. Netizens followed suit and began posting about Taiwan’s positive qualities such as its democracy, LGBTQ rights, food and scenery under the hashtag #ThisAttackComesFromTaiwan.
Lin was also one of the organizers behind the crowdfunded full page ad that appeared in the New York Times in March 2014 to alert the world about the student-led Sunflower movement protests. That time, he says the process went smoothly as it was a more straightforward issue about Taiwan’s visibility and democracy.
Photo by reader via the Liberty Times
The first draft of what became the current ad was a long letter addressed to Tedros, directly commenting on his accusations, his organization’s recent missteps as well as its isolation of Taiwan. While many pitched in, the ad also drew criticism on the crowdfunding page as people commented that it would cause the opposite effect by making Taiwan look like it was boasting.
Others questioned why the international community would care about Taiwan’s beef with Tedros, and some were unhappy that the ad claimed to come from “the people of Taiwan.” The language was changed accordingly to just represent the 26,890 contributors.
“In the end, we realized that we didn’t need to get into a verbal slugfest with Tedros,” popular YouTuber Ray Du (督省瑞) and one of the main organizers of the campaign, wrote yesterday.
The team then put out two versions of a gentler, much shorter letter that emphasized that “Taiwan can help” — a slogan that the government has been using over the past few years to combat the nation’s political marginalization.
They let the contributors vote on the final version.
“In 2014, there was much less dispute,” Lin says. “Most of the comments were on issues like aesthetics. This time, there was non-stop interaction and exchanges with the supporters. [The crowdfunding platform] told us this is the first time they’ve seen so much discussion and input go into a project.”
LINGERING QUESTIONS
However, many continued to question the effectiveness of pouring so much money into a print ad, despite its supporters — including Lin — believing that it is a worthy venture for Taiwan’s international stature and visibility. Some wondered if it would be a better idea to use all the funds toward helping other countries battle the coronavirus.
One of the main issues was why people in the US would care about Taiwan’s exclusion from the WHO when their lives are at risk due to the pandemic, as well as the declining influence of print media. How many people would the ad actually reach?
Taiwan’s success battling COVID-19 and its problems with the WHO have been covered in the international media. To cite just a few examples, the New York Times reported on Taiwan’s protest against Tedros’ accusations last week and CNN on Tuesday ran a piece on how countries with female leaders seem to find more success in battling COVID-19 — leading the story with Taiwan and its recent donation of face masks to various countries in need.
Lin says that the New York Times is still one of the world’s more reputable publications, especially to those in power, and that his team will also place online advertising in different publications as well as keep the taiwancanhelp.us Web site running. He stresses that the print ad is just the beginning, and hopes this turns into a vibrant movement.
Tsai has thanked the 26,890 contributors for their efforts, and former US ambassador to the UN Samantha Power posted it to Twitter, calling it a “powerful ad” and emphasized that “Taiwan has been fighting [COVID-19] alone.”
And the ad actually garnered a direct response from the WHO, claiming through a 13-point statement that the organization has maintained regular technical exchanges with Taiwanese health authorities over several decades.
Taiwan’s representative office in Geneva on Tuesday criticized the statement as misleading the world to believe that WHO has maintained full exchanges with Taiwan.
Taiwan’s English education system is being pulled apart by three opposing forces. Bilingual Nation 2030 pulls students toward English and global communication. Artificial Intelligence (AI) readiness pulls them toward digital judgment, verification and AI-mediated work. But Taiwan’s old exam culture pulls them back toward memorization, grammar drills, timed reading and correct answers. If the education system keeps using old exams to define success, it risks producing graduates who are neither genuinely bilingual nor genuinely AI-ready, but trained for tasks machines can already perform. The first force is Bilingual Nation 2030. Launched in 2018, the policy aimed to “help Taiwan’s workforce connect
“Taiwan’s Opposition Leader Comes to US With a Message Straight Out of Beijing” read a May 31 headline in the Wall Street Journal. Top US administration officials and members of Congress almost certainly read the WSJ, and if there was a bullet point takeaway that people in Washington should absorb ahead of Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Chair Cheng Li-wun’s (鄭麗文) arrival in DC on June 9, that headline is it. The last few columns have discussed this very topic, and the timing is not coincidental. While those top officials likely do not read the Taipei Times, judging by the number
With weighty, anxiety-inducing geopolitical topics dominating the headlines, checking in on the wild and weird state of local politics can take some of the edge off. This November’s elections will determine who will be in charge of fixing potholes in your neighborhood, not the potholes in Taiwan’s complicated geopolitical space. Recently, after an online interview with a Taipei-based journalist, I commented that Taipei journalists never go further than the MRT can take them. He laughed and agreed. Naturally, the Taipei mayoral race is eating up much of the press attention. TAIPEI CITY Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) candidate Puma Shen (沈伯洋) has
As someone who normally steers clear of books with “transcendence” or “metaphysics” in their subtitles, this reviewer — a casual observer of local belief systems since the 1990s — found Fabian Graham’s Money God Temples in Taiwan a challenging read. Those who’ve only dipped their toes into temple culture will likely need to parse several sections with special care if they’re to keep up with the author, a British ethnographic researcher whose previous books have investigated religious practices among ethnic Chinese in Southeast Asia. This scholarly volume examines a facet of Taiwan’s religious landscape that didn’t exist a century ago, and
RSS