With his wispy beard, high forehead and light voice, whimsical humor and unpretentious lifestyle, Ho Chi Minh achieved a worldwide fame denied to many other Asian nationalist leaders when his country battled the might of the US in the Vietnam War.
This biography, by the recently retired Liberal Arts Professor of East Asian Studies at Pennsylvania State University, is a massive achievement by any standards.
Sources for such a work have always been problematic. Firstly, Ho himself wrote two autobiographies, together with many newspaper and magazine articles containing information about his life, but all under a variety of assumed names.
These have to be considered alongside the massive amount of official material published in Vietnam on the revolutionary leader's life and times -- one account is in 10 volumes. Where these differ, which is to be believed? Can either category be trusted as objective?
If anyone is fitted for the task of unraveling all this, it is William Duiker. He's the author of 13 books prior to this one, nine of them about modern Vietnam. Interestingly, he was earlier in life a US foreign service officer, and as such served for a time in Taiwan.
Ho was born Nguyen Sinh Cung in 1890, the son of a provincial teacher of the Confucian classics. (Vietnam had been part of the Chinese empire for a thousand years prior to setting up as an independent state in AD 939). He died in 1969, when over 100,000 people attended his funeral.
The problem of names in Vietnamese is always difficult for foreigners owing to the custom of giving children a "milk name" at birth, and then another name, signifying the parents' hopes, in adolescence. Ho's second name, following in this tradition, was Nguyen Tat Thanh ("he who will succeed"). During the period of his youthful revolutionary activity he was known as Nguyen Ai Quoc.
In his youth he traveled extensively, and as a result had an international perspective not shared by the senior government officials in Vietnam who succeeded him.
During a period as a seaman prior to the First World War, for instance, he looked in on many countries, and lived briefly in the US (in New York and Boston, working in the latter as a pastry chef at the Parker House Hotel), and in London. His main experience of foreign life, however, was in France where he became active in socialist politics, calling for the release of his country from French rule 50 years before it was achieved.
Ho Chi Minh has somehow managed the impossible -- to be remembered not as a Marxist ideologue but instead as a man of the people, someone who stood up for the weak and the oppressed, and who is venerated for the simplicity of his tastes rather than the grandeur of his political designs.
This simplicity of lifestyle was very marked. As leader of the nation, he chose to live in a small garden hut rather than the palace, raking leaves and feeding his fish every day as a form of relaxation, as well as a way of remaining loyal to his rural origins. He also requested a simple funeral, to be followed by cremation. But the sections containing these wishes were quickly erased from his last testament by Party leaders, and his body was instead embalmed. It remains on display in the mausoleum in Ba Dinh square in Hanoi, attracting some 15,000 visitors a week.
There is evidence that Ho embraced Marxism-Leninism at least partly as a means to rid his country of the French colonial presence. When asked, in 1945, why he didn't adopt the ideals of democracy instead, and hence retain the friendship of the US (a country he claimed to admire), Ho replied that it was only in Moscow that he had received any practical offers of support, thereby implying it was largely a means to a patriotic end.
William Duiker, however, sees Ho as having been both revolutionary and patriot. He was certainly a man willing to qualify theory in order to achieve what was practical. His motives for decisions were usually tactical, often to the dismay of fellow communists, both in Vietnam and elsewhere.
Some commentators have seen it as typical of Ho Chi Minh's idealism, and his innocence of the realities of power, that he believed the French might leave Vietnam voluntarily after the Second World War. But this is not as naive as it sounds. By 1950 the British had quit India, and the Dutch Indonesia. Vietnam's fate, though, was to prove more bitter, and in the 1960s it tragically became the surrogate battleground for opposing Cold War ideologies.
Ho is perceived by many as having been a pragmatist and a humanist, broadly tolerant of views opposed to his own. The contrast between his style and that of his immediate successor, Le Duan, is marked, says Duiker. Between 1969 and 1986, Le Duan's policies of nationalizing industry and commerce and collectivizing agriculture, immediately following a decade of war, led to the collapse of the economy and the flight abroad of hundreds of thousands of the country's citizens, the pitiable "Vietnamese boat people."
Duiker concludes by noting that the myth of Ho is today being used to prop up a regime in Vietnam that has little to offer its people in the new millennium. The new generation of Vietnamese, he says, have the same attitude to Ho as young Americans busy on the Internet might have to Abraham Lincoln -- a venerable figure (Duiker uses the adjective "quaint"), but one who fought along battle-lines that are no longer very meaningful.
This, however, is a distinguished book, magnificently produced, and both scholarly and highly readable. It naturally gives a comprehensive account of the independence movement in Vietnam, and should be read alongside Duong Van Mei Elliott's superb account of one Vietnamese family's experiences over four generations in the twentieth century, The Sacred Willow, published in 1999 by Oxford University Press.
June 2 to June 8 Taiwan’s woodcutters believe that if they see even one speck of red in their cooked rice, no matter how small, an accident is going to happen. Peng Chin-tian (彭錦田) swears that this has proven to be true at every stop during his decades-long career in the logging industry. Along with mining, timber harvesting was once considered the most dangerous profession in Taiwan. Not only were mishaps common during all stages of processing, it was difficult to transport the injured to get medical treatment. Many died during the arduous journey. Peng recounts some of his accidents in
“Why does Taiwan identity decline?”a group of researchers lead by University of Nevada political scientist Austin Wang (王宏恩) asked in a recent paper. After all, it is not difficult to explain the rise in Taiwanese identity after the early 1990s. But no model predicted its decline during the 2016-2018 period, they say. After testing various alternative explanations, Wang et al argue that the fall-off in Taiwanese identity during that period is related to voter hedging based on the performance of the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP). Since the DPP is perceived as the guardian of Taiwan identity, when it performs well,
The Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) on May 18 held a rally in Taichung to mark the anniversary of President William Lai’s (賴清德) inauguration on May 20. The title of the rally could be loosely translated to “May 18 recall fraudulent goods” (518退貨ㄌㄨㄚˋ！). Unlike in English, where the terms are the same, “recall” (退貨) in this context refers to product recalls due to damaged, defective or fraudulent merchandise, not the political recalls (罷免) currently dominating the headlines. I attended the rally to determine if the impression was correct that the TPP under party Chairman Huang Kuo-Chang (黃國昌) had little of a
At Computex 2025, Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang (黃仁勳) urged the government to subsidize AI. “All schools in Taiwan must integrate AI into their curricula,” he declared. A few months earlier, he said, “If I were a student today, I’d immediately start using tools like ChatGPT, Gemini Pro and Grok to learn, write and accelerate my thinking.” Huang sees the AI-bullet train leaving the station. And as one of its drivers, he’s worried about youth not getting on board — bad for their careers, and bad for his workforce. As a semiconductor supply-chain powerhouse and AI hub wannabe, Taiwan is seeing
RSS