Some physicians in the past few weeks have expressed frustration over a verdict issued last month by the Taichung District Court, which ordered an obstetrician and a hospital to pay NT$14 million (US$431,101) in compensation for medical malpractice in delivering a baby who died after birth.
The court said in the verdict that the mother had received prenatal checkups at a hospital in Taichung and during the labor induction on June 28, 2019, the obstetrician found meconium (the baby’s first feces) in the amniotic fluid.
Although there was a risk of meconium aspiration syndrome (MAS) — a condition in which a newborn breathes a mixture of meconium and amniotic fluid, which can lead to respiratory distress, severe illness or death — the obstetrician attempted a vacuum-assisted vaginal delivery, but to no avail, the court said.
Following a prolonged labor and an increased risk of MAS, the obstetrician later suggested a caesarean section (C-section), but the newborn was found to have a slow heartbeat, cyanosis, poor blood circulation and metabolic acidosis, and therefore was intubated and transferred to a neonatal intensive care unit at another hospital.
The newborn died of meconium aspiration pneumonia and respiratory failure in the evening, while an autopsy showed that he had subgaleal hemorrhage, a condition often associated with vacuum extraction.
The parents of the newborn filed a lawsuit, saying the infant died due to the obstetrician’s negligence.
The court ruled that the obstetrician was at fault for performing vacuum extraction given the circumstances and that subgaleal hemorrhage might have worsened the newborn’s illness.
The parents should be paid medical fees, funeral expenses and about NT$12 million for “parent support” — meaning financial support that the child could have given his parents after they retire — in compensation, it ruled.
The Taiwan Association of Obstetrics and Gynecology on June 28 issued a statement criticizing the verdict.
Association chairman Huang Jian-pei (黃建霈) said finding meconium in amniotic fluid is common, occurring in about 20 percent of births, and it is not among the 20 reasons for a C-section covered by the National Health Insurance.
If the verdict is upheld, it would set an example, and more obstetricians might practice defensive medicine, while medical students might be discouraged from pursuing high-risk specialties, he said.
Social media influencer Bluepigeon (蒼藍鴿), a former National Taiwan University Hospital (NTUH) pediatrician, said the verdict was “extremely chilling,” and assuming a newborn would grow up and financially support their parents is problematic.
NTUH obstetrician Shih Jin-chung (施景中) said the large sum of compensation is unreasonable and a big blow to physicians of high-risk specialties such as neurosurgeons and cardiovascular surgeons.
A quarter of physicians already practice aesthetic medicine and the verdict adds insult to injury, he said.
Pediatrician and Taiwan Primary Care Association president Lin Yung-zen (林應然) said the verdict would affect medical students’ career choices.
Based on the “parent support” logic, there should be a law asking patients whose lives were saved to pay doctors for the rest of their lives, Lin said.
The potential effects of the ruling on Taiwan’s healthcare need to be carefully considered. It might further erode trust in the doctor-patient relationship and more parents might choose to sue in similar cases, instead of applying for the government’s no-fault childbirth accident emergency relief. It might also encourage physicians to practice defensive medicine and worsen the existing shortage of physicians in some departments including surgery, obstetrics and gynecology, pediatrics, and emergency medicine.
US President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) were born under the sign of Gemini. Geminis are known for their intelligence, creativity, adaptability and flexibility. It is unlikely, then, that the trade conflict between the US and China would escalate into a catastrophic collision. It is more probable that both sides would seek a way to de-escalate, paving the way for a Trump-Xi summit that allows the global economy some breathing room. Practically speaking, China and the US have vulnerabilities, and a prolonged trade war would be damaging for both. In the US, the electoral system means that public opinion
They did it again. For the whole world to see: an image of a Taiwan flag crushed by an industrial press, and the horrifying warning that “it’s closer than you think.” All with the seal of authenticity that only a reputable international media outlet can give. The Economist turned what looks like a pastiche of a poster for a grim horror movie into a truth everyone can digest, accept, and use to support exactly the opinion China wants you to have: It is over and done, Taiwan is doomed. Four years after inaccurately naming Taiwan the most dangerous place on
Wherever one looks, the United States is ceding ground to China. From foreign aid to foreign trade, and from reorganizations to organizational guidance, the Trump administration has embarked on a stunning effort to hobble itself in grappling with what his own secretary of state calls “the most potent and dangerous near-peer adversary this nation has ever confronted.” The problems start at the Department of State. Secretary of State Marco Rubio has asserted that “it’s not normal for the world to simply have a unipolar power” and that the world has returned to multipolarity, with “multi-great powers in different parts of the
President William Lai (賴清德) recently attended an event in Taipei marking the end of World War II in Europe, emphasizing in his speech: “Using force to invade another country is an unjust act and will ultimately fail.” In just a few words, he captured the core values of the postwar international order and reminded us again: History is not just for reflection, but serves as a warning for the present. From a broad historical perspective, his statement carries weight. For centuries, international relations operated under the law of the jungle — where the strong dominated and the weak were constrained. That
RSS