Since the killing of two brave police officers in Tainan last week, many Taiwanese have been questioning the limits on police conduct stipulated in the Act Governing the Use of Police Weapons (警械使用條例), as well as regulations pertaining to the death penalty and open prisons.
Article 4, Paragraph 1 of the act states that officers are allowed to use their firearms, and articles 6 and 9 define under which circumstances they can do so.
Article 6 states that “police shall properly use police weapons in case of emergency, and shall not exceed the necessary degree of force.”
The term “necessary degree of force” usually refers to the “least intrusive means,” which might be the main reason that officers are hesitant to use their firearms.
Similar to the “right of self-defense” defined in the Criminal Code, the use of force by police is considered legitimate as long as their actions pass the “necessity test.”
Some Criminal Code academics have proposed a three-step test to assess whether the use of force in self defense is legitimate in any given situation.
First, the victim of an attack should attempt to dodge the attack. If this does not resolve the situation, they can block the attack, and if that is not enough, they may hit back.
In practice, it is difficult to asses whether a person acting in self-defense is following the appropriate procedure.
Article 9 states that “police should avoid using lethal force unless the situation is so imminent that the lives of officers or bystanders are being threatened.”
The act is often cited by plaintiffs who claim compensation after officers use force against them.
As the saying goes, there is “no name on the bullet.”
When officers are in imminent danger, it is extremely difficult for them to ensure that they cause as little harm as possible to the attacker.
Some suggest that the act be amended by adding that police are only criminally and civilly liable if they cause death or injury to a suspect due to “willful intent” or “gross negligence.”
However, “gross negligence” is an ambiguous legal concept. Although judges can appoint expert witnesses to assist them in clarifying whether an act of negligence was “gross,” rulings are still based on judges’ free evaluation of evidence, and in practice, judges tend to hold officers who have caused the death of a suspect accountable.
The judicial recognition of “gross negligence” might be unfavorable to police officers.
Chao Hsuey-wen is an assistant professor.
Translated by Eddy Chang
Sometimes When there is a choice to be made, none of the options are good. The choice between hooking up with communism — in its Chinese iteration, the one that bugs Taiwan the most — and neofascism, of the back-to-the-roots Italian variety or any other kind, is such a choice. The good news is that Taiwan does not have to choose. It neither needs to cozy up to China — the successes of President Tsai Ing-wen’s (蔡英文) administration, despite its shortcomings, are evidence of that — nor does it need to embrace Italy under its likely new leader, Italian lawmaker Giorgia
For many years, the military’s defense of the Taiwan Strait has been centered around the doctrine of establishing “air and maritime supremacy and repulsing landing forces.” However, after the legislature passed the Sea-Air Combat Power Improvement Plan Purchase Special Regulation (海空戰力提升計畫採購特別條例) last year, the doctrine was altered to “air defense, counterattack, and establish air and maritime supremacy,” with repelling landing forces removed from the equation. Despite the changes to the defense doctrine, landing operations and anti-landing operations still feature at the core of the military’s plans for the defense of the nation. The primary reason that peace in the Taiwan Strait has prevailed
In a China-US war over Taiwan, paradoxically the greatest loss of life could be inflicted on the Muslim Uighurs. Uighurs constitute 45 percent of the Xinjiang population of 25 million people, with over 1 million incarcerated in internment camps in accordance with a policy initiated under Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平). Another half-million children have been placed in state-run boarding schools. Forced sterilization has led to a 24 to 60 percent drop in the birthrate, leading officials from many countries to describe the mass detention as genocide. Estimated annual death rates in the camps of between 5 and 10 percent could
Starting from November, and in line with recent amendments to the Compulsory Automobile Liability Insurance Act (強制汽車責任保險法), electric bicycles (e-bikes) and other small electric two-wheeled vehicles must be licensed with mounted license plates before they can be ridden on the road. This change should resolve some existing problems, such as the difficulty that e-bike owners have faced in receiving help to find their bikes if they are stolen, and the difficulty that road users have in holding anyone accountable when an accident occurs. It would also allow the more than 600,000 e-bikes that are currently being ridden on Taiwan’s roads to