The future of coal looks like an ice cream truck parked half a kilometer down a mine shaft in China’s Shanxi Province. The yellow-and-white vehicle is equipped with a 5G router from Huawei Technologies to gather data for the mine’s control center, where technicians monitor high-definition feeds on a screen the size of a two-story house.
They are tracking temperature and methane concentrations, while keeping watch over the black lumps zipping along conveyor belts on the way up to waiting trucks.
The data collection would previously have been done by workers down in the pit, but Yangquan Coal Industry Group has managed to eliminate some of those workers and virtualize the least appealing aspect of mine labor.
Illustration: Louise Ting
“It will take time, but in the future, miners will wear suits and white shirts,” said Han Weihai, manager of Huawei’s mine projects in Shanxi. “People no longer want to work in a mine, especially young people with college degrees.”
When Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) in September announced that China would be carbon neutral by 2060, he gave coal a four-decade transition.
Perhaps coal would have a longer transition if China’s vast and politically powerful coal industry can find a way to capture the planet-warming pollution generated by burning the fuel, or find other ways around the national policy.
The long transition buys China time to use up its vast coal resources and figure out how to gradually shut down an industry that still employs, directly and indirectly, tens of millions of people.
Nowhere shows this high-tech trajectory for China’s coal sector better than the Xinyuan mine.
A NEW GENERATION
Next-generation mining jobs pay as much as 100,000 yuan (US$15,300) per year, which is more than miners of previous generations could have dreamed of making. For some workers, that salary is for sitting behind a desk at a facility that looks like a college campus, with a basketball court, a table tennis facility and a library. The company organizes outdoor movie nights in the summer, and running races in the spring and autumn.
The operation produces about 2.2 million tonnes of coal per year, less than one-10th of a percent of China’s demand. That much coal could generate as much as 5 million tonnes of carbon dioxide when it is burned, even as Xinyuan employs emission-reducing techniques such as using methane instead of coal in its boilers.
Coal’s long exit is part of a two-speed approach proposed by climate scientists at Tsinghua University. Citing the inertia of energy and economic systems, they proposed allowing coal power plants to continue being built until about 2030, when China will be richer and replacement technologies would have advanced. The plan then calls for the ongoing transition to solar and nuclear to accelerate sharply.
Easing off coal slowly would reduce abrupt shocks that risk bringing unrest, the Chinese Communist Party’s (CCP) biggest nightmare, by dulling the inevitable pain to China’s army of coal workers.
“The industry will cut jobs, but it should be slow and gradual,” said Wang Haigang, deputy general manager at the Xinyuan mine.
His mine had 3,000 workers in 2012, and by 2025 plans to have fewer than 1,000.
“It might take a long time, but we’re aiming for a future in which no workers need to work underground,” Wang added.
Keeping coal alive while reducing the number of miners might also solve another headache for China, where climate policies governing 1.4 billion people are planned in Beijing, but need to be implemented by dozens of local governments.
The central government has long struggled with the question of how to get local officials to embrace plans for restructuring industries that many of those officials rely on for income.
New mining technology would allow provincial governments to keep earning money that could be used to develop post-coal industries.
That is happening in Jinzhong, the city nearest the Xinyuan mine, which in 2018 invested 11.5 billion yuan on a medical research center, an industrial park for logistics companies and other major projects.
Chinese state-owned utilities are betting on coal’s longevity by building new coal-fired power plants, with their fleets set to expand about 10 percent by 2025.
Just last year, China opened the US$30 billion Haoji Railway line, a 2,000km conduit to haul 180 million tonnes of coal per year directly from central mining basins to energy-hungry regions in the southeast.
However, the coal industry and local governments that support it might be too optimistic about the remaining timeline. China needs to stop building coal power plants immediately if it wants to meet the 2060 pledge, the Draworld Environment Research Center and the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air said.
That goal would require whittling China’s coal fleet down to 680 gigawatts (GW) by 2030, a reversal of the 1,300GW expansion currently planned.
Before long, an uncomfortable truth could push to the forefront: China’s national target of reaching net-zero emissions might not be compatible with another generation of coal.
The climate researchers and the coal industry envision two parallel universes. In one, the use of fossil fuels is drastically reduced and China pivots quickly to renewable energy. In the other, coal is phased out slowly as new technologies are used to reduce their environmental effects.
China’s coal bosses know that their regions might struggle to recover if the first scenario comes to pass.
In the northeastern city of Fuxin, locals have been extracting coal since the 1700s. When the CCP took over in 1949, then-Chinese leader Mao Zedong (毛澤東) made Fuxin central to his efforts to modernize the nation. Working the mines was an economic necessity, but also a source of patriotic pride.
Coal owned the city. At its peak, more than 500,000 of the city’s 700,000 residents either worked for the mining bureau or were family members.
The bureau ran hospitals, schools and sports facilities. Everything revolved around the Haizhou mine, the largest open-pit coal resource in Asia.
By 2005, easy-to-reach fuel was tapped out and the mine declared bankruptcy. Thousands of workers were dismissed with little money.
For three days, they protested in the streets, lining the road that led to the city’s administration, said Zhu Yu, who had been working at the mine for eight years at the time.
He eventually received a severance package equal to about three month’s wages. After the mine went through a restructuring, he managed to get a job there, with a severe pay cut, but older workers and those who could not pass a health check were not so lucky.
“They had no other skills, no education and no preparation. If the mine that they worked for all their life won’t hire them, how could they expect other companies to?” he said, gazing at the defunct mine, which has been turned into a museum. “We sacrificed our health and our youth for a job that’s supposed to last our whole lives, but suddenly we’re told the promise is no longer valid?”
Fuxin is still struggling to adapt.
From the rim of the Haizhou pit, wind turbines can still be seen on a distant hill, sounding both a note of hope for the future and a death knell for the resource that built the city.
Manufacturing and technological advances, driven largely by Chinese factories, have lowered the cost of wind and solar power to a point where they are competitive or even cheaper than coal without subsidies.
However, assembling solar panels and wind turbine parts is not generating as many jobs as mining did.
From Shanxi, where the high-tech mine is located, to such other heavyweight coal regions as Inner Mongolia, Shaanxi and Xinjiang, local officials are trying to figure out how to avoid Fuxin’s fate for as long as possible.
In China, it is not corporate dynasties like Koch Industries that are lobbying for fossil fuels, it’s provincial party leaders and heads of state-owned enterprises. These local figures rely on the industry to generate jobs and economic growth, and to maintain their power and personal wealth.
They are people such as Chen Jinxing (陳進行), former chairman of China Datang Group, one of the country’s biggest coal power generators.
Chen started out as a worker at a coal plant in Shandong Province and spent 40 years rising through the ranks at various state-owned power companies before becoming a top government adviser.
In May, he told China Electric Power News, a trade publication, that coal should play a “foundational role” in stabilizing China’s power supply to help “make sure China is self-sufficient and will never be controlled by others.”
That is an argument that the industry has used for years to lobby for more government support, and one that has gained credence as China becomes increasingly isolated on the global stage.
At the CCP’s National People’s Congress in May, delegates from China’s coal industry submitted proposals that centered on the fuel’s role in providing “energy security,” a term gaining popularity amid growing nationalism.
There is a good reason for the coal industry to think that it can find a way to coexist with the 2060 pledge — the industry has done it before.
When Xi began pursuing more progressive climate policies five years ago, companies began upgrading their plants to trap more of the small particulates that generate smog, and to produce more electricity from every tonne of coal that they burn.
Chinese power companies now brag that their best coal-fired power plants are on the same environmental level as some gas-fired power plants.
They are also banking on technology breakthroughs in areas such as carbon capture and sequestration, which traps and stores the greenhouse gases emitted when coal is burned, to help achieve carbon neutrality.
China is running demonstration projects using the expensive technology, and top researchers have said that they want to scale up to offer an alternative to clean-energy storage as a reliable around-the-clock power source.
Climate experts are wary of both approaches, which seek to mitigate carbon emissions instead of actually eliminating them, but it might be the best that China can do for the foreseeable future.
At least that is what Wang is hoping.
“Coal cannot be replaced in a short period, even if it will one day disappear from our society,” he said.
Additional reporting by Colum Murphy and James Mayger
If social media interaction is any yardstick, India remained one of the top countries for Taiwan last year. President Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) has on several occasions expressed enthusiasm to strengthen cooperation with India, one of the 18 target nations in her administration’s New Southbound Policy. The past year was instrumental in fostering Taiwan-India ties and will be remembered for accelerated momentum in bilateral relations. However, most of it has been confined to civil society circles. Even though Taiwan launched its southbound policy in 2016, the potential of Taiwan-India engagement remains underutilized. It is crucial to identify what is obstructing greater momentum
In terms of the economic outlook for the semiconductor industry, Taiwan has outperformed the rest of the world for three consecutive years. This is quite rare. In addition, Taiwan has been playing an important role in the US-China technology dispute, and both want Taiwan on their side, reflecting the remaking of the nation’s semiconductor industry. Under the leadership of — above all — Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC), the industry as a whole has shifted from a focus on capacity to a focus on quality, as companies now have to be able to provide integration of hardware and software, as well as
US President Joe Biden’s foreign policy on China and the Indo-Pacific region will have huge repercussions for Taiwan. The US Department of State in the final weeks of former US president Donald Trump’s term took several actions clearly aimed to push Biden’s foreign policy to build on Trump’s achievements. Former US secretary of state Mike Pompeo’s announcement on the final day of the Trump administration that the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) was committing “genocide and crimes against humanity” in Xinjiang was welcome, but comes far too late. The recent dropping of “self-imposed” restrictions on meetings between Taiwanese and US officials was
In memory of Diane Baker: one of the last working dance journalists, a true dance aficionado and dear friend. On Friday, through a mutual friend, I received the shocking news that dance critic Diane Baker had passed away suddenly at her apartment in Tianmu, Taipei. The news quickly spread, and messages of concern quickly swarmed in from the dance community in Taiwan and abroad. Her sister Sharon in the US later confirmed that Diane died of a heart attack on Wednesday last week. She was 65. Diane was a dear friend to Taiwan’s dance community. Her frequent appearance at dance performances in