Alphabet Inc’s Google upended plans by European media companies to block it from harvesting data about their readers and slash some of its dominance in online advertising, seven people involved in the talks said last month.
Publishers had expected to use data privacy measures going into effect on Aug. 15 to bar Google from storing insights about readers, sapping the data advantage that has enabled it to dominate a market filled with advertisers hungry for information to target potential customers.
However, Google said it would cut off publishers from a lucrative flow of ads if they follow through with curbing its data collection.
Photo: AFP
Negotiations continue, but Google holds greater leverage, because it dominates in both advertising tools and access to advertisers within the US$100 billion annual global banner ads market.
“You have to basically implement what [Google] expect from you or you’re out of the market — you can’t do without them,” said Thomas Adhumeau, general counsel at S4M, which competes with Google in software for advertisers.
The publishers’ strategy and the discussions have not been previously reported.
Google has repeatedly outmaneuvered Web site owners and its competitors over the past decade to ensure its dominance. In several cases, publishers circumvented Google to attract higher prices for ads, only to see Google reassert itself as an indispensable cog.
Rivals and publishers contend some of Google’s actions were unlawfully anti-competitive, and authorities in the US, the UK, the EU and Australia are considering pursuing penalties this year, with some even mulling breaking up Google.
Media giant News Corp this year publicly complained to Australian regulators about Google gaining an advantage over publishers by harvesting audience data.
Other companies said they would complain if Google does cut off some ads next month.
Google describes the online ads industry as competitive and says its policies aim to square EU privacy law with how its ad tools work.
The EU’s two-year-old General Data Protection Regulation requires companies to get users’ permission or have a legitimate reason before handling their data.
It prompted the Interactive Advertising Bureau of Europe, a consortium involving Google along with its clients and partners, to develop a technical protocol known as the transparency and consent framework (TCF) for ensuring all of them had the appropriate approvals from consumers.
Bureau Chief Executive Townsend Feehan said that pushed by major publishers, the consortium last year agreed to ask users for two separate permissions previously tied together: one to be shown personalized ads, the other to have their personal data collected in a profile.
Some Web sites and apps planned to omit the second permission. That would starve Google’s profile-building, while still allowing those properties to serve up personalized ads from Google’s clients.
However, Google now says consumers must grant both permissions to get personalized ads.
“This is contrary to what was agreed” by the consortium, said Angela Mills Wade, executive director of the European Publishers’ Council.
Chetna Bindra, a senior product manager at Google, said its policy around TCF keeps the status quo.
It “doesn’t change any of our policies for publishers, including our consent policy, which helps ensure users have transparency into and control over how their data is being collected and used to serve personalized ads,” Bindra said.
Some Google rivals, such as advertiser software maker MediaMath, said they might split the data permissions, giving publishers another way to undercut Google.
However, they still would have to forgo its bountiful ad supply.
Media groups Axel Springer SE of Germany and Schibsted ASA of Norway are among those frustrated with Google’s stance.
“We are concerned when big players seek to dictate the ways we should process data,” Schibsted chief privacy officer Ingvild Ness said. “It’s concerning and problematic if we end up in a situation where certain companies become gatekeepers.”
Google uses software, which millions of partner Web sites rely on to display ads, to track readers’ location, characteristics and the pages and content they consume. These profiles allow marketers to target ads to particular users as they browse online.
Publishers, no matter how vast their own audiences, have struggled to compete with the breadth of Google’s profiles.
“When Google harvests that data and enriches their profiles, Google could be seen as bleeding publishers dry one drop at a time,” said Adrien Thil, chief privacy officer at Smart, which competes with Google in publisher software.
Media companies must share revenue with Google to access the unparalleled number of advertiser clients it attracts with its data.
Globally, publishers’ share of Google ad revenue has fallen in half to 16 percent over the past decade, according to a paper released last month by Dina Srinivasan, an antitrust consultant to News Corp.
AI REVOLUTION: The event is to take place from Wednesday to Friday at the Taipei Nangang Exhibition Center’s halls 1 and 2 and would feature more than 1,100 exhibitors Semicon Taiwan, an annual international semiconductor exhibition, would bring leaders from the world’s top technology firms to Taipei this year, the event organizer said. The CEO Summit is to feature nine global leaders from Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電), ASE Technology Holding Co (ASE, 日月光投控), Applied Materials Inc, Google, Samsung Electronics Co, SK Hynix Inc, Microsoft Corp, Interuniversity Microelectronic Centre and Marvell Technology Group Ltd, SEMI said in a news release last week. The top executives would delve into how semiconductors are positioned as the driving force behind global technological innovation amid the artificial intelligence (AI) revolution, the organizer said. Among them,
When she was in fifth grade, Scarlett Goddard Strahan started to worry about getting wrinkles. By the time she turned 10, she and her friends were spending hours on ByteDance Ltd’s TikTok and Google’s YouTube watching influencers tout products for achieving today’s beauty aesthetic: a dewy, “glowy,” flawless complexion. Goddard Strahan developed an elaborate skin care routine with facial cleansers, mists, hydrating masks and moisturizers. One night, her skin began to burn intensely and erupted in blisters. Heavy use of adult-strength products had wreaked havoc on her skin. Months later, patches of tiny bumps remain on her face, and her cheeks turn
Demand for artificial intelligence (AI) chips should spur growth for the semiconductor industry over the next few years, the CEO of a major supplier to Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) said, dismissing concerns that investors had misjudged the pace and extent of spending on AI. While the global chip market has grown about 8 percent annually over the past 20 years, AI semiconductors should grow at a much higher rate going forward, Scientech Corp (辛耘) chief executive officer Hsu Ming-chi (許明琪) told Bloomberg Television. “This booming of the AI industry has just begun,” Hsu said. “For the most prominent
Former Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) chairman Mark Liu (劉德音) yesterday warned against the tendency to label stakeholders as either “pro-China” or “pro-US,” calling such rigid thinking a “trap” that could impede policy discussions. Liu, an adviser to the Cabinet’s Economic Development Committee, made the comments in his keynote speech at the committee’s first advisers’ meeting. Speaking in front of Premier Cho Jung-tai (卓榮泰), National Development Council (NDC) Minister Paul Liu (劉鏡清) and other officials, Liu urged the public to be wary of falling into the “trap” of categorizing people involved in discussions into either the “pro-China” or “pro-US” camp. Liu,
RSS