The nation’s telecoms are not aligning with the government’s eagerness to put Taiwan on the world’s 5G map as they balk at splurging on the expensive wireless technology that has no guarantees for quick returns.
The nation’s five wireless carriers have clearly said that they would not scramble to roll out 5G services, as they face big challenges ahead, including the absence of a profitable business model to sell the revolutionary technology, in spite of all the use cases that have been suggested.
A 5G use case and adoption survey released last week by Gartner Inc found that Internet of Things applications remain the most popular target use case for 5G, followed by video.
About two-thirds of organizations intend to deploy 5G by 2020, it said.
“We know enterprise clients will be early adopters of 5G technology. We also know the benefits of the technology, but people rarely talk about what will be the potential business models,” Chunghwa Telecom Co (中華電信) president Sheih Chi-mau (謝繼茂) said at a Taiwan Communications Society forum on Dec. 14.
“How to make profits from 5G technology is a real challenge for us,” Sheih said. “Whether 5G can create a blue ocean [for telecoms] remains a question mark.”
Local telecoms each burned up to NT$60 billion (US$1.95 billion) to obtain 4G spectrum and build 4G networks. Four years after the launches in 2014, carriers are still struggling to recover those investments.
Stiff price competition has been blamed for telecoms’ plight.
Over the past two years, 4G average revenue per user has dipped 32 percent to NT$555 in the second quarter of this year, government statistics showed.
Taiwan Star Telecom Corp (台灣之星) president Cliff Lai (賴弦五) made a bold forecast, saying that “5G technology will not be a profitable business by 2025.”
“We cannot even find a business case that would allow us to recover 5G investments in the short term,” Lai said at the forum.
Deploying a 5G network remains two to three times more expensive than the rollout of 4G, as telecoms would have to install many more base stations to ensure Internet connectivity to a massive amount of end devices that is 10 to 100 times faster and has a lower latency than 4G, Taiwan Star Telecom said.
Taiwan Mobile Co (台灣大哥大) is also conservative about jumping into capital-intensive 5G technology.
Company president James Jeng (鄭俊卿) said that the firm would not invest heavily in 5G within three years after the release of the 5G spectrum.
“Within the next three years we do not see any scalable business opportunities that are strong enough to support telecoms’ heavy investments on extensive 5G coverage like we did for 2G, 3G and 4G,” Jeng said.
The National Communications Commission has pushed back the issuance of 5G licenses from next year to 2020 due to technological hurdles and expensive telecommunications equipment in the initial phase.
Local telecoms are likely to commercially launch 5G services in the second half of 2020 or in the first half of 2021, about six months after the release of spectrum, Far EasTone Telecommunications Co (遠傳電信) president Yvonne Li (李彬) said.
In other words, Taiwanese telecoms would lag their global peers such as US telecom giants AT&T Inc and Verizon Communications Inc by about two years in offering 5G services. In the US, major wireless service providers have already begun providing 5G services.
Other markets where significant 5G subscriber volume is expected include South Korea, Japan and China, Telefonaktiebolaget L.M. Ericsson said in an annual mobility report released last month.
Flawed government policy has stalled local telecoms’ investment in 5G and they also learned a harsh lesson during the migration to 4G.
WiMAX service providers, the strongest supporters of a government drive to build a local WiMAX ecosystem, were all forced out of the market in 2015 after admitting defeat in a battle for 4G supremacy with LTE technology.
On the cusp of entering the 5G era, the government aims to build a new 5G supply chain in Taiwan by teaming up with global 5G pioneers like Qualcomm Inc, with the ultimate goal of transforming the nation into a “digital economy.”
The Ministry of Economic Affairs has created a 5G Technology Program Office tasked with spurring collaboration to lead local chipmakers, base station suppliers and networking equipment manufacturers into the global 5G market.
The domestic market could serve as a testing ground for the local 5G supply chain if telecoms spearhead the rollout of 5G services, the ministry said.
However, telecoms have not shown interest in the proposition.
“The ministry has built a bad reputation,” Lai said, citing the WiMAX fiasco. “Taiwan should seek to be a smart follower, rather than a 5G leader.”
An index launched a year ago to give investors greater exposure to China’s Internet giants is now the world’s worst-performing major technology gauge. The Hang Seng Tech Index has been on a roller-coaster ride in the past 12 months. The gauge, which marks its first anniversary on Tuesday, was up 59 percent at its February peak, but has since seen more than US$551 billion in market value wiped out amid Beijing’s clampdown on the sector. That has reduced its gain to nearly 6 percent, compared with more than 40 percent for the MSCI World Information Technology Index and the NASDAQ-100 Index. The
EDUCATION AS WELFARE: New regulations threaten to upend the lucrative private education sector that teaches the public school curriculum to paying families China unveiled a sweeping overhaul of its US$100 billion education tech sector, banning companies that teach the school curriculum from earning profit, raising capital or going public. Beijing on Saturday published an array of regulations that together threaten to overturn the sector and jeopardize billions of dollars in foreign investment. Companies that teach school subjects can no longer accept overseas investment, which could include capital from the offshore registered entities of Chinese firms, according to a notice released by the Chinese State Council. Those in violation of that rule must take steps to rectify the situation, the country’s most powerful administrative
‘IN ITS INFANCY’: The company’s 12-inch fab in Arizona is to be its first major overseas chip manufacturing site, while the fab in Japan would be its second, if it is constructed Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) is evaluating the feasibility of constructing a semiconductor fabrication plant in Germany as it continues to expand overseas, it said yesterday. A shareholder at the contract chipmaker’s annual general meeting in Hsinchu City yesterday asked about the possibility following media reports earlier this month that TSMC was approached by the German government about building a chip fab in the country, as Europe joins the US and China in establishing local chip supplies in a bid to avert future chip shortages. “About the German fab, we are seriously looking into it, but it is still in its
The next target for China’s cybersecurity crackdown is to be the pools of data collected by the latest generation of vehicles. This approach risks Beijing shooting itself in the foot, and jeopardizing its ambitious plans to lead the global race for electric and autonomous vehicles. China wants to have control over the information vehicles have about their drivers, the roads they traverse, and the faces and voices they pass, according to a draft law on data-security management for the automotive industry issued in May. It seeks to ensure manufacturers across the auto supply chain keep data in the country and pass