Separated from their mothers, jabbed with metal hooks and sometimes deprived of food — many Thai elephants are tamed by force before being sold to lucrative tourism sites increasingly advertised as “sanctuaries” to cruelty-conscious travelers.
Balanced precariously on her hind legs, two-year-old Ploy holds a ball in her trunk and flings it toward a hoop, one of many tricks she is learning in Ban Ta Klang, a traditional training village in the east.
Here young elephants are “broken” to interact with tens of millions of tourists who visit Thailand every year, many eager to capture social media-worthy encounters of the kingdom’s national animal playing sports, dancing and even painting.
Villagers in Ban Ta Klang who have been working with the large, gentle animals for generations say taming is necessary for safety reasons and that the force is not excessive.
“We do not raise them to hurt them ... if they are not stubborn, we do nothing to them,” mahout Charin said, as he stroked Ploy’s head affectionately and spoke of her as part of his family.
Charin makes about US$350 a month in a profession that was handed down from his father and grandfather. “I have always lived with them,” he added.
However, animal welfare advocates argue the taming technique — where babies are removed from the care of fiercely devoted mothers at the age of two — is cruel and outdated.
It is also little-known, one of many murky aspects of an evolving elephant tourism trade often kept from view of tour operators and travelers.
Elephants were phased out of the logging industry about 30 years ago, leaving their mahouts unemployed.
So they turned to Thailand’s flourishing tourism industry, a burgeoning sector of amusement parks offering elephant rides and performances.
A tamed elephant can now fetch up to US$80,000, a colossal investment that then requires grueling hours of work and increasingly bizarre stunts to be recouped.
Mae Taeng park in the northern city of Chiang Mai receives up to 5,000 visitors per day and charges an entrance fee of about US$50.
Many come to see Suda, who holds a brush in her trunk and paints Japanese-style landscapes for visitors who are able to later buy the prints for up to US$150 before taking an elephant ride through the hills.
As tourists become more aware of the potential cruelty of such activities, a growing number of places have opted to use the term “sanctuary” or “refuge.”
Many do not permit rides or animal performances. Instead, tourists are encouraged to feed, groom and care for elephants, gaining an unforgettable experience with one of nature’s most majestic creatures.
However, charities warn that even seemingly benign options, like bathing them, could still be problematic.
“Bathing with elephants ... is often stressful for elephants and mahouts especially when dealing with groups of excited young people,” Jan Schmidt-Burbach of World Animal Protection (WAP) told reporters.
“The best option is to leave it to the elephant to decide if and how to bath and ask tourists to stand back to observe and enjoy this moment without interference,” he said.
Yet even this might not be enough. Some animal rights experts warn it could be hard to discern the treatment of the animals after the crowds have gone home.
Some have reported cases of elephants at so-called sanctuaries being chained for long hours, forced to sleep on concrete and malnourished.
Of the 220 elephant parks identified across the country, even if many promise ethical tourism, “only a dozen ensure truly satisfactory living conditions,” WAP said.
It is working with ChangChill, a small organization near Chiang Mai, bordered by a river in the middle of rice terraces. In a few months, it changed its methods to give elephants more space, fewer interactions and an environment resembling life in the wild.
“We don’t force them to do what they wouldn’t instinctively do,” director Supakorn Thanaseth said.
As a result, they are “less sick, calmer.” The risk of accidents with tourists has decreased as the animals are less stressed, though mahouts still have a hook in a bag for emergencies.
ChangChill hopes to become profitable in the current high season, but it would only be able to receive around 40 tourists a day to visit its six elephants as part of its aim to put the creatures first. That is a drop in the bucket considering that Thailand has nearly 4,000 “domesticated” elephants.
Thai authorities are reluctant to reintroduce them into natural habitats, as advocated by some nonprofit organizations, because of a lack of space and potential conflict with humans.
The compromise, some argue, is to better regulate the sector and improve standards.
However, there is little impetus to enact more stringent rules that would cut into the Thai tourism industry, which welcomed more than 38 million visitors this year. A committee of several animal welfare associations submitted recommendations to the government last year advocating for stricter controls for elephants in captivity.
Yet, according to activist Sovaida Salwala from Friends of the Asian Elephants, a nonprofit that helped compile the report, their requests “remain unanswered so far.”
In fact, there is some evidence the animals’ situation is getting worse. Schmidt-Burbach said their last research in 2015 found some 1,771 elephants whose welfare was in question. “There are 357 more elephants in poor conditions compared to our 2010 study,” he said.
‘TRAVEL FREELY’: Visitors from 10 countries deemed low-risk would be allowed into Thailand, while others must still undergo a week of quarantine at a hotel Thailand plans to fully reopen to vaccinated tourists from countries deemed low risk from Nov. 1, the country’s leader said on Monday, citing the urgent need to save the kingdom’s ailing economy. Before the COVID-19 pandemic, Thailand attracted nearly 40 million visitors a year drawn to its picturesque beaches and robust nightlife, with tourism making up almost 20 percent of its national income. However, pandemic-related travel restrictions have left the economy battered, contributing to its worst performance in more than 20 years. Thai Prime Minister Prayuth Chan-ocha announced that the country would be reopening its borders to vaccinated tourists travelling by air from
LEFT ALONE: The US withdrawal from Afghanistan has firmed up a belief among Arab leaders that they must chart their own course, such as saving their economies While Syrian President Bashar al-Assad is still shunned by the West, who blame him for a decade of brutal war in Syria, a shift is under way in the Middle East, where Arab allies of the US are bringing him in from the cold by reviving economic and diplomatic ties. The extension of al-Assad’s two-decade-old presidency in an election in May did little to break his pariah status among Western states, but fellow Arab leaders are coming to terms with the fact that he retains a solid grip on power. The US’ chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan has firmed up a belief among
Vaccination is highly effective at preventing severe cases of COVID-19, even against the Delta variant of SARS-CoV-2, a vast study in France has shown. The research published yesterday — focusing on prevention of severe COVID-19 and death, not infection — looked at 22 million people over 50 and found those who had received jabs were 90 percent less likely to be hospitalized or die. The results confirm observations from the US, the UK and Israel, but researchers say it is the largest study of its kind so far. Looking at data collected starting in December last year, when France launched its vaccination campaign,
TWO-TIER DIPLOMACY? Jean-Pierre Thebault said ‘rebuffing a country like France is almost sending a message that there are trusted partners and other partners’ Australian officials lied and raised the risk of confrontation in Asia by crafting a secret submarine deal with the US and Britain that undermined trust in democratic alliances, French Ambassador to Australia Jean-Pierre Thebault said on Friday. France is determined to protect its interests in the Indo-Pacific region and to put “muscle” into Europe’s geopolitical strategy toward an increasingly assertive China, Thebault said in an interview before heading back to his post in Canberra. “The way you treat your allies does resonate in the region,” Thebault said in a gilded chamber in the French Ministry of Foreign Affairs building on the banks