A US judge on Monday struck a first blow against the US National Security Agency’s (NSA) bulk collection of telephone records, ruling it breaches citizens’ privacy to an “almost Orwellian” degree that is probably unconstitutional.
The scathing ruling by a US federal judge in Washington was stayed pending appeal, but if upheld it could lead to the spy agency being barred from indiscriminately gathering metadata on millions of private calls.
While not a final judgment, the ruling put the US administration on the back foot at the start of what will no doubt be a protracted series of legal challenges to the NSA’s global surveillance network.
It was also seized upon by fugitive intelligence leaker Edward Snowden to support his case that he is a whistleblower exposing official overreach, rather than a traitor endangering US security.
“I cannot imagine a more indiscriminate and arbitrary invasion than this systematic and high-tech collection and retention of personal data on virtually every single citizen,” US District Court Judge Richard Leon said.
Leon argued that US founding father James Madison, one of the authors of the US Constitution, would be “aghast” at the government’s “almost Orwellian” breach of citizens’ rights to privacy.
He also took aim at US government claims that the scale of data-gathering was necessary to thwart terrorist plots.
“The government does not cite a single instance in which analysis of the NSA’s bulk metadata collection actually stopped an imminent attack, or otherwise aided the government in achieving any objective that was time-sensitive in nature,” Leon wrote.
The NSA refused to comment on the ruling. The US Department of Justice said it was examining the ruling.
“We believe the program is constitutional as previous judges have found,” a Justice Department spokesman said. “We have no further comment at this time.”
Two plaintiffs, Larry Klayman and Charles Strange, brought a case against US President Barack Obama’s administration after Snowden revealed the vast scale of the NSA’s digital dragnet.
Documents provided by Snowden to the Guardian revealed that the NSA had compelled US telecom giant Verizon to provide agents with its clients’ telephone call metadata.
Subsequent leaks from his vast trove of classified documents suggest that other telephone and Internet providers have also provided private details on both US and foreign clients.
Leon’s ruling would bar the US government from continuing to siphon off metadata without judicial approval, but he did not issue an immediate injunction against the practice. Instead the case will go to appeal.
“In the months ahead other ... courts, no doubt will wrestle to find the proper balance consistent with our constitutional system,” Leon said in a written judgment.
Obama’s administration has condemned Snowden’s leaks and insists that collecting metadata — the time, duration and destination of calls, but not their content — is not unconstitutional.
US spy chiefs say that by joining the dots between archived calls and terrorist suspects they can keep the US safe, but this case will not be the last legal challenge the program faces.
On Friday last week, an official panel handed Obama a secret review of the NSA’s electronic surveillance program along with more than 40 recommendations to install safeguards and limit its scope. However, the administration is not expected to significantly curtail the NSA’s mission, despite international outrage, and Snowden remains a fugitive granted temporary asylum in Russia.
Leon said the appeal process would take at least six months and delayed his order “in light of the significant national security interests at stake ... and the novelty of the constitutional issues.”
Snowden, who worked as a contractor for the NSA, expressed satisfaction in a statement passed to the New York Times by journalist Glenn Greenwald.
“I acted on my belief that the NSA’s mass surveillance programs would not withstand a constitutional challenge and that the American public deserved a chance to see these issues determined by open courts,” Snowden said. “Today, a secret program authorized by a secret court was, when exposed to the light of day, found to violate Americans’ rights. It is the first of many.”
The Electronic Frontier Foundation, which campaigns for Internet freedoms, welcomed the ruling.
“It shows that the judiciary is looking at this program and does not agree that it is legal,” foundation attorney Kurt Opsahl said.
An Australian university student who has never visited China and has only a modest social media following would seem an unlikely target for the Chinese government. However, when a Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs spokesman personally denounced Drew Pavlou at a news conference, it was just the next phase in an extraordinary campaign against the 21-year-old that has fueled concerns over China’s targeting of critics overseas. Pavlou first placed himself in the superpower’s sights when in July last year he organized a small sit-in at the University of Queensland, where he studies, to protest against various Chinese government policies. Since then, the Global
‘ASKED TO MOVE OUT’: Indonesian coast guard personnel argued with a Chinese vessel over territorial claims after it entered the country’s exclusive economic zone An Indonesian patrol ship confronted a Chinese coast guard vessel that spent almost three days in waters where Indonesia claims economic rights and that are near the southernmost part of China’s disputed claims to the South China Sea. The Indonesian Maritime Security Agency on Friday night detected Chinese ship 5204 entering Indonesia’s exclusive economic zone (EEZ) in what Indonesia calls the North Natuna Sea. The agency sent a patrol ship that closed within 1km of the Chinese coast guard vessel and they communicated to affirm their position and their nation’s claims to the area, Indonesian Maritime Security Agency head Aan Kurnia said. “We
BEFORE WINTER COMES: Snow cuts off roads into Ladakh for four months or more each year, so the crunch is on to get food, tents and high-altitude equipment to Leh From deploying mules to large transport aircraft, the Indian military has activated its entire logistics network to transport supplies to thousands of troops for a harsh winter along a bitterly disputed Himalayan border with China. In the past few months, one of India’s biggest military logistics exercises in years has brought vast quantities of ammunition, equipment, fuel, winter supplies and food into Ladakh, a region bordering Tibet that India administers as a union territory, officials said. The move was triggered by a border standoff with China in the snow deserts of Ladakh that began in May and escalated in June into hand-to-hand
Since her personal telephone number was posted online, Hong Kong democracy advocate and Hong Kong Confederation of Trade Unions chairperson Carol Ng has received menacing calls from strangers and been bombarded with messages calling her a “cockroach.” She is not alone. A sophisticated and shady Web site called HK Leaks has ramped up its “doxxing” — where people’s personal details are published online — of Hong Kong democracy advocates, targeting those it says have broken Hong Kong’s National Security Law. Promoted by groups linked to the Chinese Chinese Communist Party and hosted on Russia-based servers, HK Leaks has become the most prominent “doxxing”