A plan to toughen Hong Kong’s copyright law has sparked protests from artists, who say it will stifle free speech, criminalize satire and threaten the city’s growing status as a major arts hub.
More than 1,700 artists have signed a petition urging the government to shelve proposed amendments to the Copyright Act, while pro-democracy lawmakers have launched a filibuster campaign to delay its passage into law.
“The proposed law will create an environment of fear and will lead artists to self-censor themselves,” performance artist and graphic designer Ger Choi (蔡芷筠), one of the organizers of the petition, said.
Some petitioners claim the amendments are politically motivated, after candidates in a March leadership poll were viciously — and humorously — parodied in social media including Facebook and various blogs.
Hong Kong chief executive-elect Leung Chun-ying (梁振英) was mocked as a comic-book super hero from the new Hollywood blockbuster The Avengers, while his rival, Henry Tang (唐英年), was depicted as former British prime minister Margaret Thatcher in the Iron Lady.
Artists fear that creating such commentary based on copyrighted material will be a criminal offense under the new law, planned at a time when the territory is cementing its status as a regional arts hub, illustrated by the glittering Hong Kong International Art Fair that opened on Thursday.
At present, copyright infringement occurs when the work causes significant damage to the copyright holder, but the government wants to broaden the rules to cover any reuse that could “affect prejudicially” the owner.
It also updates the law for the digital age by criminalizing “any unauthorized communication of copyright works” on the Internet.
Such moves are welcomed by some.
In April, the Hong Kong Motion Pictures Industry Association complained that pirated movie clips posted on the YouTube video sharing site resulted in losses of US$308 million.
However, others say that the amendments are heavy-handed and open to strict interpretations that could stifle creativity and erode the semi-autonomous territory’s cherished freedoms.
They are also dumbfounded at the government’s suggestion that artists should obtain consent from the copyright holder if they want to create a derivative work.
“Are they saying Duchamp should get permission from Da Vinci before he creates the Mona Lisa parody? We wouldn’t have seen the work if that was the case,” Choi said, referring to Marcel Duchamp’s Mona Lisa with a mustache parody.
“We wonder whether these bureaucrats come from Mars,” added the artist, who also sits on the government’s Arts Development Council.
Songwriter and film director Calvin Poon (潘源良) agreed that the territory — a regional powerhouse of cinema and pop music — needed modern copyright laws, but he said the bill threatened to throw the baby out with the bath water.
“If we don’t protect our intellectual property, we will be on the losing end eventually,” the winner of the Best Original Song prize at the recent Hong Kong Film Awards said. “Our copyright laws are outdated and reforms are needed ... The question is how we could promote freedom and at the same time make our laws on par with international standards.”
The Copyright Act already allows for “fair dealing” with a protected work for educational purposes or “criticism, review and news reporting,” as long as “sufficient acknowledgement” is made of the original material.
However, Choi said this was not enough.
“We want a clear exemption for secondary creation. We want a comprehensive review of the Copyright Act,” she said.
The government has promised to listen to the artists’ concerns, but it says the proposed legislation makes no mention of parody and will not place further limitations on artists’ freedom to create secondary works.
PRECARIOUS RELATIONS: Commentators in Saudi Arabia accuse the UAE of growing too bold, backing forces at odds with Saudi interests in various conflicts A Saudi Arabian media campaign targeting the United Arab Emirates (UAE) has deepened the Gulf’s worst row in years, stoking fears of a damaging fall-out in the financial heart of the Middle East. Fiery accusations of rights abuses and betrayal have circulated for weeks in state-run and social media after a brief conflict in Yemen, where Saudi airstrikes quelled an offensive by UAE-backed separatists. The United Arab Emirates is “investing in chaos and supporting secessionists” from Libya to Yemen and the Horn of Africa, Saudi Arabia’s al-Ekhbariya TV charged in a report this week. Such invective has been unheard of
‘TERRORIST ATTACK’: The convoy of Brigadier General Hamdi Shukri resulted in the ‘martyrdom of five of our armed forces,’ the Presidential Leadership Council said A blast targeting the convoy of a Saudi Arabian-backed armed group killed five in Yemen’s southern city of Aden and injured the commander of the government-allied unit, officials said on Wednesday. “The treacherous terrorist attack targeting the convoy of Brigadier General Hamdi Shukri, commander of the Second Giants Brigade, resulted in the martyrdom of five of our armed forces heroes and the injury of three others,” Yemen’s Saudi Arabia-backed Presidential Leadership Council said in a statement published by Yemeni news agency Saba. A security source told reporters that a car bomb on the side of the road in the Ja’awla area in
US President Donald Trump on Saturday warned Canada that if it concludes a trade deal with China, he would impose a 100 percent tariff on all goods coming over the border. Relations between the US and its northern neighbor have been rocky since Trump returned to the White House a year ago, with spats over trade and Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney decrying a “rupture” in the US-led global order. During a visit to Beijing earlier this month, Carney hailed a “new strategic partnership” with China that resulted in a “preliminary, but landmark trade agreement” to reduce tariffs — but
SCAM CLAMPDOWN: About 130 South Korean scam suspects have been sent home since October last year, and 60 more are still waiting for repatriation Dozens of South Koreans allegedly involved in online scams in Cambodia were yesterday returned to South Korea to face investigations in what was the largest group repatriation of Korean criminal suspects from abroad. The 73 South Korean suspects allegedly scammed fellow Koreans out of 48.6 billion won (US$33 million), South Korea said. Upon arrival in South Korea’s Incheon International Airport aboard a chartered plane, the suspects — 65 men and eight women — were sent to police stations. Local TV footage showed the suspects, in handcuffs and wearing masks, being escorted by police officers and boarding buses. They were among about 260 South
RSS