The internationally respected South African jurist who wrote a UN report on Israel-Palestinian clashes won’t be attending an important Jewish rite of passage for his grandson, but did not confirm reports he was put off by possible protests by Jews angered by conclusions he drew about Israel.
All Richard Goldstone would say on Saturday was that after discussions with a South African Jewish group that has sharply criticized his findings that Israel committed war crimes in Gaza last year, he decided not to attend the bar mitzvah.
“In the interests of my grandson, I will not be attending the bar mitzvah ceremony,” the retired member of South Africa’s highest court said in an e-mail on Saturday. “At this time, I am not prepared to say more than that after consultation with the rabbi and leaders of the congregation at the Sandton Synagogue, to which the South African Zionist Federation was a party.”
The Zionist Federation has called Goldstone’s UN report “flawed and biased.” The group’s chairman, Avrom Krengel, said he could not comment on the bar mitzvah until after the affair under an agreement with the Goldstone family. Neither he nor Goldstone would say when the bar mitzvah, a milestone heavy with religious, cultural and family meaning at which 13-year-olds traditionally come of age, was scheduled.
“It is a day of celebration and we don’t want to detract from it,” Krengel said.
Harelle Isaacs, office manager at the synagogue, said: “As far as we’re concerned, Judge Goldstone is welcome on our premises. No one has asked him not to come. We actually don’t know where that’s coming from.”
Talk of protests has roiled on blogs.
In a statement on Friday, South Africa’s Jewish Board of Deputies said it was concerned the bar mitzvah “would turn into a divisive issue within the Jewish community.”
In what could be taken as a veiled rebuke at any planned protest, the board called for tolerance, and said the exercise of the right to free speech must take “into account, with due sensitivity and understanding, the feelings of others.”
Goldstone is a respected figure in South Africa. In addition to serving on the country’s Constitutional Court, Goldstone once chaired a South African commission of inquiry into apartheid-era political violence, and was a prosecutor for the UN War Crimes Tribunal for Yugoslavia and Rwanda. He currently holds a visiting post at Georgetown University in Washington.
He has faced heavy criticism at home and abroad, however, for his Gaza report. Some of the criticism from fellow Jews has been especially pointed, but other Jews have supported him.
The US said the report did not fully deal with the role of the Palestinian militant group Hamas in the conflict. It also objected to a recommendation that Israeli actions be referred to the International Criminal Court, saying such moves could damage efforts to restart peace talks.
Goldstone has expressed disappointment at the criticism and rejected any suggestion politics played a role in the findings in his 575-page report.
“We believe deeply in the rule of law, humanitarian law, human rights and the principle that in armed conflict civilians should to the greatest extent possible be protected from harm,” Goldstone told the UN Human Rights Council in Geneva last year.
The council commissioned the report.
FRENCH AID: Paris has sent a navy ship and aircraft from Reunion Island with some pollution control equipment, but rough seas are spreading the oil spill The operator of a Japanese bulk carrier which ran aground off Mauritius in the Indian Ocean yesterday apologized for a major oil spill, which officials and environmentalists say is creating an ecological disaster, as police prepared to board the ship. The MV Wakashio, operated by Mitsui OSK Lines, struck the reef on Mauritius’ southeast coast on July 25. “We apologize profusely and deeply for the great trouble we have caused,” Mitsui OSK Lines executive vice president Akihiko Ono said at a news conference in Tokyo. The company would “do everything in their power to resolve the issue,” he said. At least 1,000 tonnes of
They stand as eyesores to most passers-by and potential public health risks to authorities, decaying buildings wrapped in tangles of exposed wire, studded with protruding leaky plastic pipes, vegetation billowing from cracks and terraces where particulates from polluted air have accumulated over time. With skyscrapers and ultramodern developments on every side, some of these “nail houses” are also sitting on land worth millions of dollars in Shenzhen’s inferno of a property market, where new-unit and second-hand home prices rival London. In battles over land and development, the nail house phenomenon has become widespread throughout China over the past two decades, with owners
BEYOND CULTURE: The US State Department was expected to announce that the Chinese government-funded institutes would have to register as foreign missions US President Donald Trump’s administration is increasing scrutiny of a long-established Chinese-government funded program that is dedicated to teaching Chinese language and culture in the US and other nations, the latest escalation of tensions with Beijing. The US Department of State was expected to announce as soon as yesterday that Confucius Institutes in the US — many of which are based on college campuses — would have to register as “foreign missions,” according to people familiar with the matter who asked not to be identified. The designation would amount to a conclusion that the institutes are “substantially owned or effectively controlled” by
SHOW OF SOLIDARITY: The publisher’s ‘Apple Daily’ newspaper has had to raise the number of copies printed from 70,000 to 550,000 to meet a huge surge in demand They have occupied Hong Kong’s central business district, marched by the hundreds of thousands through the territory’s streets and endured tear gas and pepper spray in pitched battles with riot police. Hong Kong’s pro-democracy supporters are now wielding a new protest weapon: their stock-market trading accounts. To show support for Jimmy Lai (黎智英), the publisher and outspoken government critic who was on Monday arrested under the territory’s new national security legislation, Hong Kongers have been piling into shares of his media company Next Digital. The result: a more than 1,100 percent surge in two days that propelled the stock to a seven-year