When US and Pakistani officials said this week that one conspirator in the foiled plan to bomb trans-Atlantic airliners was a "liaison" to al-Qaeda, they suggested that his arrest proved the group was linked to the scheme. Rashid Rauf, a Briton, had trained in the group's camps in the 1990s and was "a key al-Qaeda operative," one Pakistani official said.
But counterterrorism experts said on Saturday that the focus of government officials and the public on al-Qaeda, a term today with deep connotations but elusive meaning, may be misplaced.
They say the Qaeda label remains useful shorthand for the news media and for officials who want to tap the powerful emotions associated with the Sept. 11 attacks. But to suggest that the terrorist threat today is represented by the organization directly commanded by Osama bin Laden is to oversimplify a complex international movement, the specialists say.
"If you think of al-Qaeda as the group that did 9/11, I don't think it's a very useful question," said Marc Sageman, a former CIA officer and author of a 2004 book closely studied in intelligence agencies, Understanding Terror Networks.
"There is no such thing as al-Qaeda as it existed before we went to Afghanistan and destroyed it," Sageman said.
As the latest plot suggests, he said, that does not mean total victory is at hand.
"We won the war against the old al-Qaeda. But we're not winning against the global social movement that al-Qaeda was part of, because more and more kids are joining the movement," he said.
Michael Scheuer, a former head of the CIA unit that focuses on bin Laden, says there may be more left of the old al-Qaeda than Sageman thinks. But he, too, doubts that bin Laden had anything to do with the airliner plot and emphasizes al-Qaeda's role as the inspiration and support for a broader movement.
"There are an amazing number of people who are connected to al-Qaeda" through training or funding, Scheuer said. "But the connection is not command and control."
Some government officials acknowledge privately that Washington has been slow to consider the possibility that the international jihad movement is without any central organization.
"We're still wrapped up in thinking that this is a hierarchical organization," said one intelligence official who spoke on condition of anonymity.
"We have a major problem out there, because the fact is that there is no command and control, and there are so many copycats out there," the intelligence official said.
Top US officials said in their first comments after news of the arrests in Britain that the scheme bore "the hallmarks" of al-Qaeda.
Media coverage dwelt at length on the possibility of ties to the group. Then the identification on Friday of Rauf appeared to nail down a connection.
Speculation about a possible role of another suspected militant still being sought in Pakistan, Matiur Rehman, an explosives expert, has added to the notion of a Qaeda role, though few agree on whether he is linked with the group's operations in Pakistan.
Rehman is a "person of interest" in the airliner plot but it is unclear whether he played a role, the intelligence official said. Even top intelligence officials are uncertain about what is left of al-Qaeda beyond its top two leaders, Osama bin Laden and Ayman al-Zawahiri, who are believed to be in hiding in Pakistan.
"Those of us in the counterterrorism community debate this all the time: What do we mean when we say `al-Qaeda'?" said Brian Fishman, of the Combating Terrorism Center at the US Military Academy. "There's a lot of disagreement."
The West Point center has published a study of al-Qaeda documents that include an almost comically bureaucratic set of personnel rules on salary and vacation. One reads: "The salary of a married Mujahed brother is 1,000 Pakistani rupee [US$16.59]. The bachelor Mujahed qualifies for a round-trip ticket to his country after one year from joining the organization."
The date of the documents is uncertain, but they clearly were written when al-Qaeda was based in Afghanistan between 1996 and 2001 and had the greatest freedom of action, Fishman said.
"It really looked like a corporate organization," he said. "But even then, bin Laden and Zawahiri saw their job as inspiring a movement of youth around the world. They were under no illusion that they could topple the United States on their own."
In fact, al-Qaeda was not for long the stable and hierarchical organization implied by its personnel policies. Much of the discussion of the group this week focused on the similarities between the foiled trans-Atlantic plot and an earlier failed scheme dating from 1994, the so-called Bojinka plan to bring down 11 airliners over the Pacific.
But contrary to widespread belief, said Paul Pillar, a former CIA analyst now at Georgetown University, neither the Bojinka plot nor the 1993 attack on the World Trade Center were, strictly speaking, al-Qaeda operations.
Both took place before bin Laden moved from Sudan to establish his base in Afghanistan in 1996 and intelligence officials believe neither was directed by him.
Ramzi Yousef, who is now imprisoned in Colorado, was involved in both the 1993 World Trade Center bombing and the Bojinka plot, in which Yousef's uncle, Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, also played a role. Only in 1998 did Mohammed formally join al-Qaeda, but his later role as the chief architect of the Sept. 11 attacks has led to the association of the group with the earlier plots.
Nonetheless, the invocation of al-Qaeda, and the still-chilling image of bin Laden, have provided an effective way to encapsulate and personalize the otherwise overwhelming threat of terrorism. In the same way, the image of Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, the head of the loosely affiliated branch of al-Qaeda in Iraq, came to stand for the entire Iraqi insurgency.
But the insurgency has continued uninterrupted since al-Zarqawi was killed in June. Similarly, the larger terrorist threat would likely not be significantly diminished if bin Laden and al- Zawahiri were killed, most specialists believe.
References to al-Qaeda by US officials have unmistakable political implications, as demonstrated by the Bush administration's bitterly disputed attempts to link former Iraqi president Saddam Hussein to al-Qaeda to justify the invasion of Iraq.
There are also legal implications, stemming in part from the congressional authorization of military force approved days after the Sept. 11 attacks, which targeted those who "planned, authorized, committed, or aided" those attacks rather than terrorists generally.
But the focus on al-Qaeda reflects a natural human tendency to paint the enemy in understandable terms, Fishman said.
"The world is simpler when we have one enemy," he said. "When we talk about a social movement and self-radicalizing, homegrown groups, that's nothing like we have faced in the past."
Three years after a deadly virus struck India’s endangered Asiatic lions in their last remaining natural habitat, conservationists are hunting for new homes to help booming prides roam free. The majestic big cats, slightly smaller than their African cousins and with a fold of skin along their bellies, were once found widely across southwest Asia. Hunting and human encroachment saw the population plunge to just 20 by 1913, and the lions are now found only in a wildlife sanctuary in India’s western Gujarat State. Following years of concerted government efforts, the lion population in Gir National Park has swelled to nearly 700, according
A rogue overgrown sheep found roaming through regional Australia has been shorn of his 35kg fleece — a weight even greater than that of the famous New Zealand sheep Shrek, who was captured in 2005 after six years on the loose. The merino ram, dubbed Baarack by rescuers, was discovered wandering alone with an extraordinarily overgrown wool coat, and was promptly shorn to save his life. Kyle Behrend, from the Edgar’s Mission farm sanctuary, said that it appeared Baarack was “once an owned sheep” who had escaped. Merino sheep do not shed their fleece and need to be shorn at least annually, as
DMZ SWIM: Over more than three hours, South Korean surveillance cameras caught him eight times and audible alarms sounded twice, but border guards did not notice A North Korean defector wore a diving suit and fins during a daring six-hour swim around one of the world’s most fortified borders and was only caught after apparently falling asleep, a Seoul official said. South Korean forces did not spot the man’s audacious exploit, despite his appearance several times on surveillance cameras after he landed and triggered alarms, drawing heavy criticism from media and opposition lawmakers. Even after his presence was noticed, the man — who used diving gear to make his way by sea around the Demilitarized Zone (DMZ) that divides the Korean Peninsula — was not caught for another
‘GRAVE CONCERN’: A critic of the government died immediately following his complaints of torture at the hands of security forces, a human rights group said Students on Friday clashed with police in Bangladesh’s capital, Dhaka, as anger mounted at the death of a writer and government critic in a high-security jail. At least 18 police and an unknown number of protesters were injured in the clashes, authorities and witnesses said, amid international demands for an independent investigation into the death of Mushtaq Ahmed. An Agence France-Presse correspondent witnessed police using batons and firing tear gas at students who staged a torchlight march calling for “justice” near the University of Dhaka. At least six students who allegedly attacked security forces with torches were detained, police said. More protests were planned