Throwing down a new challenge to the British government's tactics against terrorism, a High Court judge ruled on Wednesday that so-called control orders -- a form of house arrest without trial -- were incompatible with European human rights laws.
The government is expected to appeal the ruling, issued by Justice Jeremy Sullivan, while civil rights groups depicted it as a victory in a sharpening duel over the state's efforts to amass ever greater powers, ostensibly to combat terrorism.
The debate began after the Sept. 11 attacks on New York and the Pentagon. But it has become more intense in Britain following last July's bomb attacks in London.
If the government's appeal fails, it will mean the authorities will have to seek some other mechanism to continue holding the six suspects -- a Briton and five Iraqis -- whose cases prompted the ruling.
In his decision, Sullivan said control orders conflict with the right to liberty under the European Convention on Human Rights. The authorities, thus, had no power to make the orders, he ruled.
Control orders provide for the electronic tagging of terrorism suspects who have not been charged with a crime, and for their confinement to their homes for most of the day. So-called controlees may be forced to relinquish their passports and permit unrestricted searches of their homes.
The government of British Prime Minister Tony Blair has displayed increasing irritation with the European human rights legislation, which was drawn up in 1950 and written into British law in 1998.
Control orders were introduced after Britain's highest court, the Law Lords, ruled in 2004 that indefinite detention of foreign terror suspects in prisons contravened the European convention. The orders can be used against Britons and foreigners.
Natalia Garcia, a lawyer for people held under control orders, said her clients were "prisoners without rights who have not been charged with an offense and who, it is now clear, are denied their liberty for political reasons."
The government argues that protecting the public against terror attacks and controlling the movements of suspects should prevail.
With much pomp and circumstance, Cairo is today to inaugurate the long-awaited Grand Egyptian Museum (GEM), widely presented as the crowning jewel on authorities’ efforts to overhaul the country’s vital tourism industry. With a panoramic view of the Giza pyramids plateau, the museum houses thousands of artifacts spanning more than 5,000 years of Egyptian antiquity at a whopping cost of more than US$1 billion. More than two decades in the making, the ultra-modern museum anticipates 5 million visitors annually, with never-before-seen relics on display. In the run-up to the grand opening, Egyptian media and official statements have hailed the “historic moment,” describing the
‘CHILD PORNOGRAPHY’: The doll on Shein’s Web site measure about 80cm in height, and it was holding a teddy bear in a photo published by a daily newspaper France’s anti-fraud unit on Saturday said it had reported Asian e-commerce giant Shein (希音) for selling what it described as “sex dolls with a childlike appearance.” The French Directorate General for Competition, Consumer Affairs and Fraud Control (DGCCRF) said in a statement that the “description and categorization” of the items on Shein’s Web site “make it difficult to doubt the child pornography nature of the content.” Shortly after the statement, Shein announced that the dolls in question had been withdrawn from its platform and that it had launched an internal inquiry. On its Web site, Le Parisien daily published a
UNCERTAIN TOLLS: Images on social media showed small protests that escalated, with reports of police shooting live rounds as polling stations were targeted Tanzania yesterday was on lockdown with a communications blackout, a day after elections turned into violent chaos with unconfirmed reports of many dead. Tanzanian President Samia Suluhu Hassan had sought to solidify her position and silence criticism within her party in the virtually uncontested polls, with the main challengers either jailed or disqualified. In the run-up, rights groups condemned a “wave of terror” in the east African nation, which has seen a string of high-profile abductions that ramped up in the final days. A heavy security presence on Wednesday failed to deter hundreds protesting in economic hub Dar es Salaam and elsewhere, some
Flooding in Vietnam has killed at least 10 people this week as the water level of a major river near tourist landmarks reached a 60-year high, authorities said yesterday. Vietnam’s coastal provinces, home to UNESCO world heritage site Hoi An ancient town, have been pummeled by heavy rain since the weekend, with a record of up to 1.7m falling over 24 hours. At least 10 people have been killed, while eight others are missing, the Vietnamese Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment said. More than 128,000 houses in five central provinces have been inundated, with water 3m deep in some areas. People waded through
RSS