Dictators and democrats will have rubbed elbows this weekend at a Moscow meeting of the Commonwealth of Independent States, where the most pressing question may well be whether the Russian-led organization shouldn't just be shut down for good.
The loose grouping of 12 former Soviet republics has long been rent by disputes -- between Azerbaijan and Armenia over the Nagorno-Karabakh enclave, between Georgia and Russia over mutual accusations of support for separatists and terrorists.
But it has never appeared so untenable as it does today, following the uprisings against the entrenched leaderships of Georgia, Ukraine and Kyrgyzstan. The CIS puts democratically elected leaders such as Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili and Ukrainian President Viktor Yushchenko in the same club as Belarusian President Alexander Lukashenko -- whom the US has branded the last dictator in Europe -- and the Turkmen autocrat, President Saparmurat Niyazov, best known abroad for the cult of adoration he's built to himself and his family.
PHOTO: EPA
"The CIS is a pointless organization for today. It brings together absolutely different countries with diametrically opposed interests," said Levan Ramishvili, an analyst at Georgia's independent Freedom Institute.
Sunday's meeting comes amid a spiraling diplomatic spat between Ukraine and Belarus, where five Ukrainians have been jailed for taking part in a protest. And it comes less than a month since Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili, Moldovan President Vladimir Voronin, Ukrainian President Viktor Yushchenko and the leaders of other former Soviet republics joined their voices in challenging Russia to make good on its six-year-old pledge to withdraw troops and weaponry from Georgia and Moldova.
The CIS clearly has more quarrels than shared vision among its members. Saakashvili was staying away from yesterday's meeting, as well as today's Victory in Europe day celebration in Moscow, because Georgia failed to win agreement on the withdrawal of Russian bases. Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliev is staying away because of the attendance of the Armenian leader, and because yesterday was a day of mourning, marking a key battle during the six-year war between Armenia and Azerbaijan over the disputed enclave of Nagorno-Karabakh.
"If the CIS is going to survive, then it will be merely as a consultative council of heads of state, which doesn't obligate anyone to anything," said Stanislav Shushkevich, the Soviet-era parliamentary speaker in Belarus who together with Russia's Boris Yeltsin and Ukraine's Leonid Kravchuk signed the 1991 document that dissolved the Soviet Union.
"There's only one problem: Does the leader of a democratic state really want to confer with dictators?"
The most vocal recent criticism of the CIS has come from countries such as Ukraine and Georgia, where pro-Western leaders have come to power and hopes of shedding Russian influence are high.
But even President Vladimir Putin has thrown doubt on the future of the CIS, telling reporters in the Armenian capital Yerevan earlier this year that the forum had been created for the "civilized divorce" of the former Soviet republics, in contrast to the European Union, which was built to foster real cooperation.
Other officials have been no more sanguine.
"There is no good in the CIS as it is now -- ineffectual and unable to function," said Ilyas Omarov, the spokesman for the Kazakh Foreign Ministry.
The group's attempts to be more than a talk shop have often only fostered more discord. Its peacekeepers have been accused of destabilizing conflict zones in the former Soviet Union, and its election monitors -- deployed to provide a counterbalance to Western-dominated observer missions from such groups as the Council of Europe and the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe -- have consistently given high marks to blatantly fraudulent ballots. Pavel Borodin, secretary of the Russia-Belarus union, said the CIS would have to radically change its focus to survive -- but survive it would.
"The CIS will be reborn as a purely economic organization," he said. "This is a market of 300 million consumers. There's nowhere else to turn."
Putin made much the same point to German journalists this week, singling out the shared energy system, transport network and other infrastructure dating back to Soviet times as strong incentives to deepen economic cooperation.
"These are all natural advantages that the past has give us," Putin said. "Not to use this, I think, would be simply stupid."
Yet the plans to remove trade barriers between member states that have dominated the CIS agenda since its creation have never gotten off the ground. Attempts at forging closer economic ties have been hampered by the stark differences between the sizes of the member economies and their levels of development, as well as fears of Russian domination.
"The CIS is a system that has completed all of its set tasks, and there is no hope for its development," Ukrainian Economic Minister Sergei Teryokhin said.
LANDMARK CASE: ‘Every night we were dragged to US soldiers and sexually abused. Every week we were forced to undergo venereal disease tests,’ a victim said More than 100 South Korean women who were forced to work as prostitutes for US soldiers stationed in the country have filed a landmark lawsuit accusing Washington of abuse, their lawyers said yesterday. Historians and activists say tens of thousands of South Korean women worked for state-sanctioned brothels from the 1950s to 1980s, serving US troops stationed in country to protect the South from North Korea. In 2022, South Korea’s top court ruled that the government had illegally “established, managed and operated” such brothels for the US military, ordering it to pay about 120 plaintiffs compensation. Last week, 117 victims
China on Monday announced its first ever sanctions against an individual Japanese lawmaker, targeting China-born Hei Seki for “spreading fallacies” on issues such as Taiwan, Hong Kong and disputed islands, prompting a protest from Tokyo. Beijing has an ongoing spat with Tokyo over islands in the East China Sea claimed by both countries, and considers foreign criticism on sensitive political topics to be acts of interference. Seki, a naturalised Japanese citizen, “spread false information, colluded with Japanese anti-China forces, and wantonly attacked and smeared China”, foreign ministry spokesman Lin Jian told reporters on Monday. “For his own selfish interests, (Seki)
Argentine President Javier Milei on Sunday vowed to “accelerate” his libertarian reforms after a crushing defeat in Buenos Aires provincial elections. The 54-year-old economist has slashed public spending, dismissed tens of thousands of public employees and led a major deregulation drive since taking office in December 2023. He acknowledged his party’s “clear defeat” by the center-left Peronist movement in the elections to the legislature of Buenos Aires province, the country’s economic powerhouse. A deflated-sounding Milei admitted to unspecified “mistakes” which he vowed to “correct,” but said he would not be swayed “one millimeter” from his reform agenda. “We will deepen and accelerate it,” he
Japan yesterday heralded the coming-of-age of Japanese Prince Hisahito with an elaborate ceremony at the Imperial Palace, where a succession crisis is brewing. The nephew of Japanese Emperor Naruhito, Hisahito received a black silk-and-lacquer crown at the ceremony, which marks the beginning of his royal adult life. “Thank you very much for bestowing the crown today at the coming-of-age ceremony,” Hisahito said. “I will fulfill my duties, being aware of my responsibilities as an adult member of the imperial family.” Although the emperor has a daughter — Princess Aiko — the 23-year-old has been sidelined by the royal family’s male-only
RSS