Critics of genetically modified (GM) foods are warning that a Vatican endorsement of biotech products would be a mistake, while supporters say the Vatican is wisely gathering evidence to make an informed decision about the issue.
Participants at a two-day Vatican conference on biotech foods also questioned whether the Vatican would get a balanced view, since speakers in the pro-biotech camp dominated the discussions, reflecting the views of its organizer, Cardinal Renato Martino.
Martino, who has spoken out frequently about the potential benefits of the technology, opened the conference titled GMO: Threat or Hope by acknowledging it could have far-reaching implications.
"We are fully aware that the stakes are high and delicate," he said, citing the divide in public opinion, commercial interests and ethical questions involved, as well as "the difficulty in defining scientifically a material that is subject to evolving research."
A Vatican endorsement of biotech foods would likely draw praise from the US, where biotech companies have been at the forefront of extolling the virtues of genetically modified organisms, or GMOs, which can be made to resist insects or disease.
But it would no doubt ruffle feathers in Europe, which has imposed a moratorium on growing or importing GMOs because of fears about the environmental and heath risks, and in African countries such as Zambia, which has rejected biotech food aid.
Greenpeace science adviser Doreen Stabinsky said in an interview Monday that she was dismayed that the Vatican was hearing a largely one-sided debate at the conference, and that it would be a mistake to draw final conclusions from it.
"We would hope that the Vatican takes a very slow and measured evaluation of GM," she said. "Based on the people that are up in the room right now, I wouldn't say are consulting widely at this point."
Greenpeace opposes GM crops on the grounds that the long-term ecological and human health consequences remain unknown.
Yet Thandiwe Myeni, a small-scale South African farmer and chairwoman of the Mbuso Farmers' Association, said her experience with GM cotton had been only positive. While the GM seeds cost more than regular ones, she saves money by not having to use so much pesticide and has harvested bigger crops.
"We need this technology," she told a press conference after she spoke to the symposium. "We don't want always to be fed food aid .... We want access to this technology so that one day we can also become commercial farmers."
Italy's agriculture minister, Gianni Alemanno, praised the Vatican for taking the initiative to gather expert advice on the important issue, and said he expected Martino would make a "prudent judgment."
Martino said the Vatican's aim was to find some common ground for the benefit of all of mankind, particularly the poor.
The issue of poverty and hunger is a major concern for the Vatican, which rejects arguments that limiting family size by using contraception is one way to improve the developing world's food security.
Margaret Mellon, a speaker at the symposium and a director of the Washington-based Union of Concerned Scientists, said she is concerned the claims that biotechnology will ease world hunger are overblown and that any benefits may not outweigh the risks.
Nam-Hai Chua, head of Rockefeller University's plant molecular biology laboratory, acknowledged that the technology may not be perfect, but that it deserves to be worked on since to date GM foods have been found to be safe.
"As a scientist, my conclusion would be that our present regulatory procedures are adequate to protect the safety of this kind of product," he said.
Greenpeace said the Vatican altered its lineup of speakers for the conference at the last minute because it had so few critics of GM technology and came under pressure from the Philippines' bishops conference, among others, to give a more balanced view.
As the sun sets on another scorching Yangon day, the hot and bothered descend on the Myanmar city’s parks, the coolest place to spend an evening during yet another power blackout. A wave of exceptionally hot weather has blasted Southeast Asia this week, sending the mercury to 45°C and prompting thousands of schools to suspend in-person classes. Even before the chaos and conflict unleashed by the military’s 2021 coup, Myanmar’s creaky and outdated electricity grid struggled to keep fans whirling and air conditioners humming during the hot season. Now, infrastructure attacks and dwindling offshore gas reserves mean those who cannot afford expensive diesel
Does Argentine President Javier Milei communicate with a ghost dog whose death he refuses to accept? Forced to respond to questions about his mental health, the president’s office has lashed out at “disrespectful” speculation. Twice this week, presidential spokesman Manuel Adorni was asked about Milei’s English Mastiff, Conan, said to have died seven years ago. Milei, 53, had Conan cloned, and today is believed to own four copies he refers to as “four-legged children.” Or is it five? In an interview with CNN this month, Milei referred to his five dogs, whose faces and names he had engraved on the presidential baton. Conan,
French singer Kendji Girac, who was seriously injured by a gunshot this week, wanted to “fake” his suicide to scare his partner who was threatening to leave him, prosecutors said on Thursday. The 27-year-old former winner of France’s version of The Voice was found wounded after police were called to a traveler camp in Biscarrosse on France’s southwestern coast. Girac told first responders he had accidentally shot himself while tinkering with a Colt .45 automatic pistol he had bought at a junk shop, a source said. On Thursday, regional prosecutor Olivier Janson said, citing the singer, that he wanted to “fake” his suicide
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi reaffirmed his pledge to replace India’s religion-based marriage and inheritance laws with a uniform civil code if he returns to office for a third term, a move that some minority groups have opposed. In an interview with the Times of India listing his agenda, Modi said his government would push for making the code a reality. “It is clear that separate laws for communities are detrimental to the health of society,” he said in the interview published yesterday. “We cannot be a nation where one community is progressing with the support of the Constitution while the other