There have been mixed comments after a long-running murder case came to an end on Friday after the defendants, known as the “Hsichih Trio,” were found not guilty.
The Taiwan High Court closed the 21-year-old case, saying its verdict was final and no further appeals were to be allowed, in accordance with the Fair and Speedy Criminal Trials Act (刑事妥速審判法).
It was the third time that Su Chien-ho (蘇建和), Liu Bin-lang (劉秉郎) and Chuang Lin-hsun (莊林勳) were acquitted in the High Court since their case was reopened in 2000.
Photo: Liu Hsin-de, Taipei Times
The three men were charged with the murder of Wu Ming-han (吳銘漢) and his wife, Yeh Ying-lan (葉盈蘭), who were found dead in their apartment on March 24, 1991. The couple had been stabbed a total of 79 times.
Five months after the murder, police arrested a soldier, Wang Wen-hsiao (王文孝). His brother, Wang Wen-chung (王文忠), whom he had implicated, was also arrested and he then named three classmates — Su, Liu and Chuang — as accomplices.
Wang Wen-hsiao was later found guilty and sentenced to death by a military court. Before his execution in January 1992, Wang maintained that the other three suspects had been involved in the murders.
Wang Wen-chung served two years in jail after being convicted of being an accomplice.
The three men were tried several times over many years and were sentenced to death five times. However, five separate justice ministers refused to sign death warrants for the three.
A report by US-based forensic expert Henry Lee (李昌鈺) played a key role in the case. Lee concluded that the crime may have been committed by a single assailant.
The three men are now free under the law, which stipulates that if a case is retried more than three times over a period of six years and a not-guilty verdict is returned three times, prosecutors are not allowed any further appeals.
Friday’s verdict has elicited mixed responses from groups.
Chen Shu-chen (陳淑貞), director of the Taipei Branch of the Association For Victim Support, said the law must be amended to protect the rights of victims. The aim of the law is to facilitate a speedy trial, but it could also result in a blurring of the truth, she said.
She raised the question of whether the law, which was enacted in 2010, had been “tailored for the Hsichih Trio.”
The law is aimed at ending long-running cases, but it has not helped to shed light on the truth in this particular case, nor has it helped the victims, she added.
Lu Chin-te (陸晉德), whose son was kidnapped and murdered in another high-profile case, said the law favors perpetrators and ignores the rights of the victims.
It is tantamount to handing defense lawyers an ace, which allows them to drag out the trial process for as long as possible to help their clients wriggle off the hook, Lu said.
On the other hand, Su Yiu-chen (蘇友辰), president of the Chinese Association for Human Rights and the trio’s defense lawyer, said the Fair and Speedy Criminal Trials Act is not a bad law.
“It is better to have the law than not have it,” he said.
The law will prompt prosecutors to be more careful in their investigations and to compile more solid evidence, he added.
Lawyer Chan Shun-kuei (詹順貴) said if defendants are freed because of the law, victims still have the right to sue for compensation. Victims can also question why judicial authorities failed to gather enough evidence to convict defendants, Chan said.
If judicial authorities were negligent in collecting evidence, then the issue of national compensation for the victims would arise, he said.
Wu Ching-chin (吳景欽), associate professor of Aletheia University, said law enforcement officials involved in the Hsichih Trio case should be held responsible for the previous guilty verdicts and the three suspects should now seek compensation.
If the three defendants pursue avenues for compensation for their wrongful imprisonment of more than 11 years each, they could each receive up to NT$21 million (US$701,000).
Taiwan Crime Victims’ Human Rights Association has criticized the law, saying that it offers scant protection for victims and could also be contradicting the Constitution.
The association said it does not want to see victims crying in the dark, while perpetrators go free.
Authorities should revise the law to uphold a fair and just judicial system, it said.
The sloppy handling of evidence gathered at the crime scene 21 years ago and a lack of forensics expertise at the time resulted in a weak case against the trio, but several judges still sentenced the three men to death based on the suspects’ statements and forensic reports, the association said.
Wu Ming-han’s family continue to believe that the three men were guilty because Wang had maintained they had been involved.
However, if the crime scene was compromised and forensic evidence lacked credibility, prosecutors would get nowhere with the case no matter how many times they appealed, observers said.
With the case now closed, judicial reforms over the past two decades should be reviewed and forensic expertise should be strengthened so that the rights of defendants and victims could be equally protected, observers added.
A group of Taiwanese-American and Tibetan-American students at Harvard University on Saturday disrupted Chinese Ambassador to the US Xie Feng’s (謝鋒) speech at the school, accusing him of being responsible for numerous human rights violations. Four students — two Taiwanese Americans and two from Tibet — held up banners inside a conference hall where Xie was delivering a speech at the opening ceremony of the Harvard Kennedy School China Conference 2024. In a video clip provided by the Coalition of Students Resisting the CCP (Chinese Communist Party), Taiwanese-American Cosette Wu (吳亭樺) and Tibetan-American Tsering Yangchen are seen holding banners that together read:
UNAWARE: Many people sit for long hours every day and eat unhealthy foods, putting them at greater risk of developing one of the ‘three highs,’ an expert said More than 30 percent of adults aged 40 or older who underwent a government-funded health exam were unaware they had at least one of the “three highs” — high blood pressure, high blood lipids or high blood sugar, the Health Promotion Administration (HPA) said yesterday. Among adults aged 40 or older who said they did not have any of the “three highs” before taking the health exam, more than 30 percent were found to have at least one of them, Adult Preventive Health Examination Service data from 2022 showed. People with long-term medical conditions such as hypertension or diabetes usually do not
POLICE INVESTIGATING: A man said he quit his job as a nurse at Taipei Tzu Chi Hospital as he had been ‘disgusted’ by the behavior of his colleagues A man yesterday morning wrote online that he had witnessed nurses taking photographs and touching anesthetized patients inappropriately in Taipei Tzu Chi Hospital’s operating theaters. The man surnamed Huang (黃) wrote on the Professional Technology Temple bulletin board that during his six-month stint as a nurse at the hospital, he had seen nurses taking pictures of patients, including of their private parts, after they were anesthetized. Some nurses had also touched patients inappropriately and children were among those photographed, he said. Huang said this “disgusted” him “so much” that “he felt the need to reveal these unethical acts in the operating theater
Heat advisories were in effect for nine administrative regions yesterday afternoon as warm southwesterly winds pushed temperatures above 38°C in parts of southern Taiwan, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said. As of 3:30pm yesterday, Tainan’s Yujing District (玉井) had recorded the day’s highest temperature of 39.7°C, though the measurement will not be included in Taiwan’s official heat records since Yujing is an automatic rather than manually operated weather station, the CWA said. Highs recorded in other areas were 38.7°C in Kaohsiung’s Neimen District (內門), 38.2°C in Chiayi City and 38.1°C in Pingtung’s Sandimen Township (三地門), CWA data showed. The spell of scorching