The government should be as transparent as possible in providing food safety information, rather than withhold knowledge that it assumes might be too complex for the general public to comprehend, pundits said yesterday.
The analysts made the remarks in response to government plans for melamine testing to only label content “detectable” or “non-detectable” and not specify how many parts per million (ppm) of the toxin are contained in products.
“The most important elements should ... make very clear the approach to be adopted in evaluating food safety, its detection limits and the possible consequences of consuming tainted foods,” said Winston Dang (陳重信), a professor of National Taipei University.
“Detection limits are especially important, because melamine is something that is not supposed to be included in foodstuffs, just like it is illegal to put dioxin in food,” said Dang, who previously served as an ombudsman at the US Food and Drug Administration.
On Wednesday, the Department of Health (DOH) surprised many with its announcement raising the allowable melamine content in foods from zero ppm to 2.5ppm. Department of Health minister Lin Fang-yu (林芳郁) resigned the next day under heavy criticism.
The eased standards came as the DOH struggled to standardize instruments used to test for melamine, with high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) chosen over gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS).
However, compared with GC-MS — which can detect melamine content as low as 0.002ppm — the HPLC method is not nearly as sensitive, with its lower limits between 2ppm and 2.5ppm.
Lin had said the standardization was meant to make sure all items were examined equally, but he did not explain why the HPLC method was chosen.
The decision was made at a committee meeting chaired by Lin and attended by DOH Deputy Minister Sung Yeh-jen (宋晏仁) among others.
When the change made headlines on Thursday and was met with strong criticism, Executive Yuan Spokeswoman Vanessa Shih (史亞平) said that “2.5ppm is an international standard” and the HPLC method had been adopted in the US and Europe for the analysis of melamine in human food.
Shih told reporters that the DOH shouldn’t have said how many ppm of melamine is permissible in foodstuff or which method was to be adopted, saying that the general public could misinterpret the decision “because following the issue required specialized knowledge.”
The DOH should simply tell people the testing is in line with international standards and foods found to include melamine would not be allowed to enter the market, she said on Thursday.
On Friday, Premier Liu Chao-shiuan (劉兆玄) and Lin’s successor Yeh Ching-chuan (葉金川) both said that the authorities would use a “zero detection” method, but they stopped short of saying whether the results would be based on HPLC or GC/MS testing.
“The way the government addressed the issue has turned the problem of whether melamine is allowed in food into a matter for rhetoric, and this is unacceptable,” Dang said.
“According to the US, EU and the WHO, the permissible level of melamine is zero, not ‘zero detection.’ Considering the lower limits of detection, of course we should go for the best available technology [one that offers the most precision] — the GC/MS or LC/MS/MS [liquid chromatography mass spectrometry] and not the HPLC, which is the method that was used in 1970s,” he said
Secretary-general of the EU Study Association Wu Chih-chung (吳志中) slammed officials for putting a spin on its position, saying that the government followed international standards yet failed to tell the public what kind of international standard it referred to.
“Apparently there is no such international standard of 2.5ppm, at least in the EU, US and Japan. Only Honk Kong has adopted that standard,” Wu said.
Yeh’s remarks that the DOH had to consult with international experts to decide on testing methods for melamine runs contrary to statements made by Shih, who said that the HPLC method met international standards, Wu said.
“The government should reveal all the information, including the person responsible for deciding on the testing method, the reasons why the approach was chosen and its limitations, because the people have the right to challenge the government’s decision and they need the information,” he said.
POLAM KOPITIAM CASE: Of the two people still in hospital, one has undergone a liver transplant and is improving, while the other is being evaluated for a liver transplant A fourth person has died from bongkrek acid poisoning linked to the Polam Kopitiam (寶林茶室) restaurant in Taipei’s Far Eastern Sogo Xinyi A13 Department Store, the Ministry of Health and Welfare said yesterday, as two other people remain seriously ill in hospital. The first death was reported on March 24. The man had been 39 years old and had eaten at the restaurant on March 22. As more cases of suspected food poisoning involving people who had eaten at the restaurant were reported by hospitals on March 26, the ministry and the Taipei Department of Health launched an investigation. The Food and
A fourth person has died in a food poisoning outbreak linked to the Xinyi (信義) branch of Malaysian restaurant chain Polam Kopitiam (寶林茶室) in Taipei, Deputy Minister of Health and Welfare Victor Wang (王必勝) said on Monday. It was the second fatality in three days, after another was announced on Saturday. The 40-year-old woman experienced multiple organ failure in the early hours on Monday, and the family decided not to undergo emergency resuscitation, Wang said. She initially showed signs of improvement after seeking medical treatment for nausea, vomiting and diarrhea, but her condition worsened due to an infection, he said. Two others who
MEDICAL: The bills would also upgrade the status of the Ethical Guidelines Governing the Research of Human Embryos and Embryonic Stem Cell Research to law The Executive Yuan yesterday approved two bills to govern regenerative medicine that aim to boost development of the field. Taiwan would reach an important milestone in regenerative medicine development with passage of the regenerative medicine act and the regenerative medicine preparations ordinance, which would allow studies to proceed and treatments to be developed, Deputy Minister of Health and Welfare Victor Wang (王必勝) told reporters at a news conference after a Cabinet meeting. Regenerative treatments have been used for several conditions, including cancer — by regenerating blood cells — and restoring joint function in soft tissue, Wang said. The draft legislation requires regenerative treatments
Taiwanese should be mindful when visiting China, as Beijing in July is likely to tighten the implementation of policies on national security following the introduction of two regulations, a researcher said on Saturday. China on Friday unveiled the regulations governing the law enforcement and judicial activities of national security agencies. They would help crack down on “illegal” and “criminal” activities that Beijing considers to be endangering national security, according to reports by China’s state media. The definition of what constitutes a national security threat in China is vague, Taiwan Thinktank researcher Wu Se-chih (吳瑟致) said. The two procedural regulations are to provide Chinese