When internationally renowned film director Hou Hsiao-hsien (
The coalition's main aim is to urge local politicians to stop "manipulating provincialism and ethnic topics" for partisan interests.
PHOTO: SEAN CHAO, TAIPEI TIMES
It also called on local news media to monitor political parties' and individual politicians' actions instead of merely giving sensationalist coverage to their ethnically biased comments and behavior.
The coalition itself seems to be a mixture of people from different backgrounds. On its Web site (www.handinhand.org) it lists several well-known figures as its founders. There are Mainlanders like Hou, writers Chu Ten-wen (
Mainlander's Anxiety
Yet it is Hou who speaks up most of the time for the coalition, and it was he who told the public not to join the 228 Hand-in-Hand Rally.
"Feb. 28 is a day of ethnic historic tragedy and not rites of celebration," Hou said. "Both camps should halt all campaign activities and face the unjustified suffering of history. If we cannot stop campaign activities on that day, the two camps should refrain from attacking their opponents with vicious speeches. There should be no discrimination, manipulation, and no ethnic division; do not add more sadness to a day of sadness."
Hou has always prided himself in making films like A City of Sadness (
But his public announcement on the 228 Incident this time was not so welcomed by the Hokkien group, and his Mainlander identity was questioned right away.
DPP campaign headquarters spokesman Wu Nai-jen (
"What would really constitute damaging ethnic harmony is for the perpetrators and their descendents to point fingers at the victims and their descendents," Wu said.
Hou has since been labeled as a unificationist and his true intentions were questioned by the pro-independence groups, with some even accusing him of accepting funds from China for his movies.
Several critics, including Academia Sinica sociologist Michael Hsiao (
Hsiao said the coalition avoided talking about the conflict between the Mainlanders and the Hokkien and promoted a concept of ethnic equality without real content.
"They should be talking about the current problems faced by the Mainlanders, yet they don't talk about it," Hsiao said.
"They are actually trying their hand at the de-Taiwanization of Taiwan. They are afraid of de-Sinicization of Taiwan, and this highlights the anxiety of the Mainlanders. They are anxious that Taiwan is becoming more and more like a country," Hsiao said.
"A major problem faced by the Mainlanders now is related to the election: they can only vote for the pan-blue camp and won't vote DPP, while Hokkien and Hakka people are more willing to make a choice between different parties. The Hokkien and Hakka people are enjoying democracy more," Hsiao said.
The coalition also appears to have some communication problems.
When Chi Hui-jung (
She explained that she went to only one coalition meeting and decided and then decided not to join the coalition.
"Ethnic education and social movement take a long time, yet these people do not have a long-term strategy and seem to be just trying to influence this election," Chi said.
Tuan Yi-kang (
As a second-generation Mainlander and a founding member of the Mainlander pro-independence group Goa-Sen-Lang Association for Taiwan Independence (
"I feel that the conflict between the Mainlanders and the Hokkien people is calming down, and polls tell us the same thing," Tuan said.
"But the issue of the conflict between the two sides will always heat up during an election, and Hou's problem is that he does not understand the situation, the fact that the ethnic group most sensitive to the conflict now is the one with the worst anxiety, the Mainlanders, with them being the minority group in Taiwan," Tuan said.
Tuan said that when the coalition wanted to oppose the division between the ethnic groups, it should not aim at only one camp, the DPP, when the other side was actually playing at the same thing.
Like Chi, Tuan also thought that wounds took a long time to heal.
"The healing of the wounds from past oppression takes a long time, and forgiveness also takes time. The Hokkien people need to understand why the Mainlanders are so united and anxious, while the Mainlanders need to understand the Hokkien people's hostility toward them. The country should make the majority group feel safe, and the minority group feel at peace," Tuan said.
Undercurrent of Conflict
Wu Nai-te (
"It is a bit confusing why Hou and the coalition tried to speak up in this election because compared with four years ago, the conflict between the ethnic groups is not as fierce," Wu said.
Wu pointed out that conflict between the Mainlanders and the Hokkien people now was in politics, and it was not visible in society because of the lack of a cultural division of labor.
"Intermarriages, other frequent social exchanges between the ethnic groups and the lack of the cultural division of labor smoothed out the hostility between the groups," Wu said.
"Access to education is not so different between the two groups and Taiwan's fast economic growth has made the two groups not so unbalanced in economic and social status," he said.
"However, although the social gap has started to disappear, the political division has not gone away. It has remained and gained a new theme. Democracy has switched the political position of the ethnic groups, and now it is the Mainlanders, positioned on a politically disadvantaged side, asking for respect and recognition," Wu said.
Wu said the 228 Incident was pivotal in the conflict between the Mainlanders and Taiwanese.
"The problem with the 228 Incident is that it has not been properly dealt with. The government only tried to pay off the victims and thought it would pass," Wu said.
"There were thousands of victims in the incident, yet there is no mention of any perpetrator. The past government did not want to reflect on the issue, and that's one of the greatest problems of the Lien-Soong ticket: they were part of that past," he said.
"However, at the same time, President Chen Shui-bian (
Yang Wei-chung (
"For young people like us, we did not experience the incident personally, so we do not have that tragic feeling. Instead, we just feel curious about it," Yang said.
Yang pointed out that in daily life he did not feel any problem raised by his Mainlander status, and there is seldom argument about the 228 Incident between him and others.
Mainlander's Nostalgia
But the Mainlanders have reasons to identify with China. After all, it was where they were born and grew up, and most were forced to retreat to Taiwan without a choice after the KMT lost the civil war to the communists.
Kenneth Pai (
He came to Taiwan in 1952 and graduated from National Taiwan University's Department of Foreign Languages and Literature in 1961. He continued his study in Iowa University in 1963 and started to teach at the University of California, Santa Barbara, in 1965.
In recent years he has been traveling between China, Hong Kong and Taiwan from his home in the US and has been energetically promoting Kun Opera (崑曲), with Kun (Yunnan Province) being where he spent part of his childhood.
In Pai's stories, Hokkien and Mainlander elements are often intertwined. In his 1983 gay classic Crystal Boys, the gay hero was a second-generation Mainlander called Li Ching (李青), who was banished from home because of his sexuality and hung out in Taipei's New Park, a favorite stamping ground for the gay circle back then.
With a twist Pai could not have predicted, New Park later became the 228 Memorial Park.
Pluralistic Identification
Stephane Corcuff, a professor of political science specializing in Mainlanders' issues from the University of La Rochelle, pointed out in his book Light Wind, Warm Sun: Taiwan's Mainlanders and the National Identity Transition (
Corcuff said in an earlier interview that if the Mainlanders' concern with Taiwanese domestic politics and unwillingness to give up their pro-reunification stance was a contradiction, it could be explained by "the remaining impact of past political socialization and electoral politics."
"One of the main findings of the research is that the Taiwanization of Mainlanders in Taiwan cannot be denied and it is an inevitable process. It's a natural movement, but politics constantly interferes with it," Corcuff said.
"Mainlanders have a pluralistic national identification, which comprises of China and Taiwan both at different degrees, changing from one person to another, but changing also in the same person at different moments," he said.
Wu Nai-te also considered the mainlanders to have pluralistic identifications, although he pointed out that the identification with China would be cultural rather than political, while the identification with Taiwan is a political one.
Michael Hsiao said that many mainlanders may not identify with China, and even if they do, they do not necessarily identify with the People's Republic of China, but rather the culture of greater China.
Tolerant society
Meanwhile, Chi Hui-jung is promoting a society that tolerates and appreciates pluralism.
"I hope that Taiwan can try to become a `salad bowl' like New York City, which contains different people and cultures with all keeping their own original faces rather than being a melting pot which devours and blurs the faces of different cultures," Chi said.
Yang Wei-chung agreed.
"I feel Taiwanese because I am living a Taiwanese life. Say if I should return to China now, I would not be able to adapt to the life there. However, it is hard to cut Taiwan completely from China; Taiwanese writing has often been influenced by Chinese writing. Taiwan is a tolerant place, and I would identify with a Taiwan that's inclusive of Chinese culture," Yang said.
Also See Story:
Editorial: What is a "New Taiwanese?"
“China is preparing to invade Taiwan,” Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs Francois Wu (吳志中) said in an exclusive interview with British media channel Sky News for a special report titled, “Is Taiwan ready for a Chinese invasion?” the Ministry of Foreign Affairs said today in a statement. The 25-minute-long special report by Helen Ann-Smith released yesterday saw Sky News travel to Penghu, Taoyuan and Taipei to discuss the possibility of a Chinese invasion and how Taiwan is preparing for an attack. The film observed emergency response drills, interviewed baseball fans at the Taipei Dome on their views of US President
The Central Weather Administration (CWA) today issued a "tsunami watch" alert after a magnitude 8.7 earthquake struck off the Kamchatka Peninsula in northeastern Russia earlier in the morning. The quake struck off the east coast of the Kamchatka Peninsula at 7:25am (Taiwan time) at a depth of about 19km, the CWA said, citing figures from the Pacific Tsunami Warning Center. The CWA's Seismological Center said preliminary assessments indicate that a tsunami could reach Taiwan's coastal areas by 1:18pm today. The CWA urged residents along the coast to stay alert and take necessary precautions as waves as high as 1m could hit the southeastern
The National Museum of Taiwan Literature is next month to hold an exhibition in Osaka, Japan, showcasing the rich and unique history of Taiwanese folklore and literature. The exhibition, which is to run from Aug. 10 to Aug. 20 at the city’s Central Public Hall, is part of the “We Taiwan” at Expo 2025 series, highlighting Taiwan’s cultural ties with the international community, National Museum of Taiwan Literature director Chen Ying-fang (陳瑩芳) said. Folklore and literature, among Taiwan’s richest cultural heritages, naturally deserve a central place in the global dialogue, Chen said. Taiwan’s folklore would be immediately apparent at the entrance of the
ECONOMIC BENEFITS: The imports from Belize would replace those from Honduras, whose shrimp exports have dropped 67 percent since cutting ties in 2023 Maintaining ties with Taiwan has economic benefits, Ministry of Foreign Affairs officials said yesterday, citing the approval of frozen whiteleg shrimp imports from Belize by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) as an example. The FDA on Wednesday approved the tariff-free imports from Belize after the whiteleg shrimp passed the Systematic Inspection of Imported Food, which would continue to boost mutual trade, the ministry said. Taiwan’s annual consumption of whiteleg shrimps stands at 30,000 tonnes, far exceeding domestic production, the ministry said. Taiwan used to fill the gap by importing shrimps from Honduras, but purchases slumped after Tegucigalpa severed diplomatic ties with Taiwan
RSS