A federal judge on Monday dismissed Lance Armstrong’s lawsuit against the US Anti-Doping Agency (USADA), opening the way for the agency’s drug case against the seven-time Tour de France winner to proceed.
US District Judge Sam Sparks noted “troubling aspects” of the USADA’s case against Armstrong and a “perplexing” battle between the USADA and the International Cycling Union (UCI) over jurisdiction in the case, but despite his criticism of those bodies he was firm in his view that the US courts were not the place to decide the issue.
Armstrong, who has vehemently denied doping during his cycling career, had argued that the USADA lacked jurisdiction to pursue a case against him and claimed the agency’s arbitration process violated his rights under the US constitution.
Sparks dismissed the lawsuit, filed in Armstrong’s hometown of Austin, Texas. Armstrong can appeal to a higher court, move on to arbitration with the USADA — and perhaps eventually to the Court of Arbitration for Sport — or accept sanctions from the agency, which has charged Armstrong with doping during the years he won the Tour de France from 1999 to 2005.
Penalties could include a lifetime ban from cycling and the loss of his Tour de France titles.
“We are pleased that the federal court ... has dismissed Lance Armstrong’s lawsuit and upheld the established rules which provide Congressionally-mandated due process for all athletes,” USADA chief executive Travis Tygart said in a statement. “The rules in place have protected the rights of athletes for over a decade in every case USADA has adjudicated and we look forward to a timely, public arbitration hearing in this case, should Mr Armstrong choose, where the evidence can be presented, witness testimony will be given under oath and subject to cross examination, and an independent panel of arbitrators will determine the outcome of the case.”
Armstrong has called the pursuit of the case a “vendetta” and his attorney Tim Herman welcomed Sparks’ comment that the motives were “mystifying.”
“[The] UCI has asserted that it has exclusive authority to decide whether charges should be brought in this case and has directed USADA not to proceed further,” Herman said in a statement. “We are reviewing the court’s lengthy opinion and considering Mr Armstrong’s options at this point.”
Sparks found Armstrong’s claim that the USADA’s procedures denied him his constitutional right to due process was “without merit.”
Otherwise, the judge said, the matter would be “best resolved through the well-established system of international arbitration, by those with expertise in the field, rather than by the unilateral edict of a single nation’s courts.”
Sparks did note “the deficiency” of the USADA’s charging document, but said the agency’s lawyers had informed the court that Armstrong would receive more detailed disclosures “at a time reasonably before arbitration.”
Sparks also noted “troubling aspects” of the case.
“Not least of which is USADA’s apparent single-minded determination to force Armstrong to arbitrate the charges against him, in direct conflict with UCI’s equally evident desire not to proceed against him. Unfortunately, the appearance of conflict on the part of both organizations creates doubt the charges against Armstrong would receive fair consideration in either forum,” Sparks said, but added that made it more important for the matter to be resolved by the parties involved — including the US cycling federation.
“As mystifying as USADA’s election to proceed at this date and in this manner may be, it is equally perplexing that these three national and international bodies are apparently unable to work together to accomplish their shared goal — the regulation and promotion of cycling,” Sparks wrote. “However, if these bodies wish to damage the image of their sport through bitter infighting, they will have to do so without the involvement of the United States’ courts.”
Revelations of positive doping tests for nearly two dozen Chinese swimmers that went unpunished sparked an intense flurry of accusations and legal threats between the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA) and the head of the US drug-fighting organization, who has long been one of WADA’s fiercest critics. WADA on Saturday said it was turning to legal counsel to address a statement released by US Anti-Doping Agency (USADA) CEO Travis Tygart, who said WADA and anti-doping authorities in China swept positive tests “under the carpet by failing to fairly and evenly follow the global rules that apply to everyone else in the world.” The
Taiwanese judoka Yang Yung-wei on Saturday won silver in the men’s under-60kg category at the Asian Judo Championships in Hong Kong. Nicknamed the “judo heartthrob” in Taiwan, the Olympic silver-medalist missed out on his first Asian Championships gold when he lost to Japanese judoka Taiki Nakamura in the finals. Yang defeated three opponents on Saturday to reach the final after receiving a bye through the round of 32. He first topped Laotian Soukphaxay Sithisane in the round of 16 with two seoi nage (over-the-shoulder throws), then ousted Indian Vijay Kumar Yadav in the quarter-finals with his signature ude hishigi sankaku gatame (triangular armlock). He
RALLY: It was only the second time the Taiwanese has partnered with Kudermetova, and the match seemed tight until they won seven points in a row to take the last set 10-2 Taiwan’s Chan Hao-ching and Russia’s Veronika Kudermetova on Sunday won the Porsche Tennis Grand Prix women’s doubles final in Stuttgart, Germany. The pair defeated Norway’s Ulrikke Eikeri and Estonia’s Ingrid Neel 4-6, 6-3, 10-2 in a tightly contested match at the WTA 500 tournament. Chan and Kudermetova fell 4-6 in the first set after having their serve broken three times, although they played increasingly well. They fought back in the second set and managed to break their opponents’ serve in the eighth game to triumph 6-3. In the tiebreaker, Chan and Kudermetova took a 3-0 lead before their opponents clawed back two points, but
Taiwanese gymnast Lee Chih-kai failed to secure an Olympic berth in the pommel horse following a second-place finish at the last qualifier in Doha on Friday, a performance that Lee and his coach called “unconvincing.” The Tokyo Olympics silver medalist finished runner-up in the final after scoring 6.6 for degree of difficulty and 8.800 for execution for a combined score of 15.400. That was just 0.100 short of Jordan’s Ahmad Abu Al Soud, who had qualified for the event in Paris before the Apparatus World Cup series in Qatar’s capital. After missing the final rounds in the first two of four qualifier