The three presidential candidates yesterday crossed words in the second and final televised debate, with Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) candidate Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) continuing to question Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) candidate Eric Chu (朱立倫) over campaign irregularities and the controversial KMT party assets issue, while Chu questioned Tsai’s stance on importing US pork products and People First Party (PFP) candidate James Soong (宋楚瑜) asked Tsai and Chu to clarify their stances on cross-strait economic exchanges.
The two-and-a-half-hour debate, broadcast by Sanlih E-Television (SET-TV), began with the candidates delivering their opening statements, followed by questions selected from a list proposed by the public before questioning each other. The debate ended with the candidates each making a final statement.
As soon as candidates could pose questions to each other, Chu asked Tsai why she has changed her stance on importing US pork products, criticizing her for overlooking the interests of pig farmers and public health.
Photo provided by the organizers of the debate
“Chairperson Tsai shocked us during the last presidential debate when she said that she has made a U-turn and now agrees on importing [US pork products]. We remember that the DPP has always insisted on zero tolerance [of ractopamine], calling [US meat] ‘poisonous pork’ and ‘poisonous beef,’” Chu said. “Chairperson Tsai, why have you changed your stance? Did you make a secret deal with the Americans during your visit to the US in June [last year]? Did you talk to pig farmers and members of the public before making the change? Did you organize any public hearings on it? Is this your special ‘Ing’s clique’ (英派) opaque decisionmaking process? Is unconditionally accepting another nation’s demands your decisionmaking model?”
Tsai defended herself, accusing Chu of trying to apply false labels to her, despite her repeated explanations.
Tsai said the DPP has always insisted on following the international standard on ractopamine. However, before the Codex Alimentarius Commission voted on a standard for ractopamine residue in 2012, “there was no international standard, and thus zero tolerance was our caucus’ position,” she said.
She rejected Chu’s allegation that she made a secret deal during her visit to the US, adding that Taiwan is still far from allowing imports of US pork products, which would not happen until after prolonged and complicated negotiations.
“It is really too early to talk about this issue, and I have made it clear that I will not change my stance, which is to protect the health of our people, and pig farmers’ interests will absolutely not be sacrificed,” Tsai said.
Tsai then returned the argument, accusing Chu of being the one who has changed stance on the US pork issue.
“During your visit to the US [in November last year], you said that if neighboring countries share the same position on the US pork issue, Taiwan should not be different from others. How would you explain the change in your stance?” Tsai asked.
“Perhaps you really care about public health, but I think that you are more concerned with political manipulation for the sake of your campaign and sticking labels on me,” she added.
Meanwhile, Soong said he is “strongly reserved” about importing US pork products — a position he explained at a post-debate news conference as “objection.”
“If you [the US] must export pork with ractopamine to Taiwan, would you be amenable to Taiwan turning it into pork jerky that you Americans like to eat so much, and shipping it back to the US?” Soong asked.
Soong said that if the US is unwilling to accept the proposal, it would mean that the pork is problematic, adding that the US should “try it first to prove that it is safe.”
When it was her turn to ask questions, Tsai continued to pressure Chu on KMT assets and on election irregularities that resulted in the disqualified elections of four KMT legislators since 2008, as well as KMT Hsinchu City legislative candidate Cheng Cheng-chen (鄭正鈐) last week being accused of vote-buying for his participation in a banquet for 10,000 attendees hosted by the KMT caucus of the Hsinchu City Council.
She asked Chu and Soong what they would do to prevent election irregularities.
Chu said that vote-buying is not allowed in a democracy and that any party would punish those involved in such activities by revoking their party membership. He then accused Tsai of “passing judgement before a trial.”
Tsai pressed the issue of the KMT’s controversial assets, which many see as evidence that transitional justice has not yet been achieved in Taiwan, saying that no one believes that there will not be scandals when a governing party runs businesses.
Soong voiced his agreement with Tsai, saying the KMT should take care of its party assets after the election.
“Especially the [KMT assets that were originally] properties left over by the Japanese, because those are the property of the nation and should be returned to the people,” Tsai said.
However, Chu said that the KMT has returned all illegitimate party assets, adding that he has only heard of stories regarding illegal party assets that involve former president Lee Teng-hui (李登輝), “who is Chairperson Tsai’s teacher, as well as Soong’s.”
The three candidates also touched on the subject of minimum wages, with Chu saying that he has always insisted that raising the minimum wage would boost economic development and accused Tsai of being opposed to an increase.
“If you [Tsai] are opposed [to raising the minimum wage], you are betraying the nation’s workers,” Chu said.
In response, Tsai said: “I want to reiterate that I am not opposed to raising the minimum wage.”
“In fact, I have repeatedly said that we should pass legislation on the minimum wage, which would stipulate that the minimum wage should be adjusted each year according to a set standard,” she said.
The proposed legislation would guarantee that the basic needs of workers are fulfilled, Tsai said, adding that the minimum wage should not only be adjusted when an election is approaching.
“As for the idea you [Chu] mentioned that raising salaries might boost economic development, I have never seen a successful case in other nations,” Tsai said. “If amending the law to increase the minimum wage could revive the economy, then making economic policies would not be difficult.”
Soong voiced his agreement to Tsai’s position, saying: “As Tsai mentioned, there is no nation in the world that has boosted economic development only by raising salaries.”
“[If that were the case], let us pass legislation setting the minimum wage to NT$500,000 per month. Would that not be great?” he said.
RESTRICTING TAIWAN: Beijing is using coercion and economic incentives to force other countries to accept its claims on Taiwan, the MOFA said The Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA) said yesterday it would close its representative office in Papua New Guinea and stop buying liquefied natural gas (LNG) from the country, citing Chinese pressure. Papua New Guinea’s minister of foreign affairs in July said the government had decided to close Taiwan’s representative office in the country immediately, winning praise from China, although the office had remained open in the interim. Taiwan has decided to shut the office and withdraw all personnel on the basis of national dignity, diplomatic autonomy and the country’s overall interests, the MOFA said, adding that the government will reassess and adjust
Chinese national Cheng Wanjun (程萬軍), who was at Taiwan Taoyuan International Airport after arriving on a connecting flight from Thailand on Monday and sought asylum in Taiwan, was deported to Thailand early yesterday, the National Immigration Agency (NIA) said. In a video circulating on X, Cheng identified himself as a former host at China Central Television (CCTV) and said he was seeking temporary humanitarian protection in Taiwan. Cheng said he was sentenced to six years in prison after he was recorded and reported to authorities in 2019 for criticizing “a ruler who loses his country.” After his release, he was forced to go
COORDINATED: More than 100 Chinese ships have been reported in the west Pacific, with two main clusters seen between Taiwan and its neighbors, the report said China might be conducting a major, unannounced military exercise simulating the isolation of Taiwan that is larger than the Chinese People’s Liberation Army’s (PLA) “Justice Mission 2025” exercise, the American Enterprise Institute and the Institute for the Study of War said in a joint report released on Friday. The rumored military exercise includes PLA forces from the eastern, northern and southern theater commands, possibly representing an effort to coordinate surface combatants from all three coastal theater commands into a single far-seas operation, the report said. The report cited National Security Council Secretary-General Joseph Wu (吳釗燮), who on Tuesday last week said
PLUMMETING: The TAIEX plunged 3,737.67 points in early session yesterday, the largest intraday drop in history, and closed down 1,873.08 points due to AI data center concerns The government yesterday authorized the activation of its NT$500 billion (US$15.26 billion) National Stabilization Fund (NSF) to support local shares, as the stock market experienced significant fluctuations while uncertainties in the international political and economic situation continue. The NSF’s steering committee may use the fund to intervene in the market to prop up local shares, the Ministry of Finance said in a statement. Once the fund is activated next week, it would be the 10th time the NSF has intervened in the market. Separately, the Financial Supervisory Commission (FSC) yesterday announced temporary curbs on short selling shares and other measures to help
RSS