The Taipei High Administrative Court yesterday upheld the legitimacy of the Taipei City Government’s demolition of townhouses owned by the Wang (王) family in the controversial Wenlin Yuan (文林苑) urban renewal project in Shilin District (士林).
The court dismissed the family’s request that they be allowed to rebuild their homes apart from the apartment complex, and ruled that the city government’s handling of the demolition adhered to the Urban Renewal Act (都市更新條例).
The Wang family said they were greatly disappointed with the ruling and vowed to appeal.
Photo: CNA
Despite the family’s unwillingness to participate in the urban renewal project initiated by a private firm, Le Young Construction Co (樂揚建設), its two townhouses were still put on the list of houses to be torn down to make way for a 15-story apartment building, sincea majority of residents on the project site have agreed to the plan. The city government also said that the Wangs had failed to actively express their opposition to the plan.
In March last year, while hundreds of people supporting the Wangs surrounded their homes to oppose the tearing down, a demolition crew escorted by about 1,000 police officers moved in. A severe clash ensued as police forcibly removed the protesters and the crew flattened the houses.
Following a constitutional interpretation handed down in April that the Urban Renewal Act violates people’s constitutional right to property and that relevant clauses would become invalid in a year, the Wang family filed an administrative lawsuit, asking the court to revoke the city government’s decision.
“I feel disappointed and sad when I heard the ruling,” said Wang Kuang-shu (王廣樹), a family member. “What have I done wrong? Am I not allowed to refuse to collaborate [with the construction firm]?”
Wang said it was a shame for a democratic nation ruled by law to have the government send 1,000 police officers to escort the demolition squad of a private firm to flatten the private homes of a family who has been living there for more than a century.
Wang Kuang-shu’s aunt, Wang Yang Mei-yu (王楊美玉), who is in her 80s, said it was horrible that the government was “robbing people’s properties.”
“It’s our houses that were torn down this time, next time, it could be anybody else’s house,” she said.
Thomas Chan (詹順貴), the pro bono attorney representing the Wangs, said he could not accept the ruling.
“According to the court ruling, the judge believes that, although clauses in the Urban Renewal Act has been declared unconstitutional earlier this year, they are still valid at the moment since the constitutional interpretation gives a one-year buffer for the clauses to become invalid,” Chan said.
“This is unacceptable, we will appeal the case,” he said.
Separately, Taipei Deputy Mayor Chang Chin-oh (張金鶚) applauded the ruling for affirming the legality of the city government’s handling of the project, and expected the ruling to facilitate the stalled construction.
The city government respected the Wang family’s decision to file an appeal, but the court cannot handle the case without the presentation of new evidence, he said.
“We have confidence in our handling of the case. What is important is for the long-lasting dispute to be resolved soon. The city government wants to create a win-win situation for both sides. There will only be higher social cost by stalling the project,” he said.
Taipei City Urban Redevelopment Office director Lin Chung-chieh (林崇傑) said the Wang family has filed 11 lawsuits against the city government over the stalled project. The city has won 10 so far.
The High Court is rehearing its lawsuit against the city’s approval of the urban renewal project.
The Wang family also filed a lawsuit against the project developer for damaging a container the family has erected on the construction site to hinder construction.
There could be a breakthrough for the stalled project if the court hands down a ruling in this case, he said.
Additional reporting by staff writer
Taiwan has arranged for about 8 million barrels of crude oil, or about one-third of its monthly needs, to be shipped from the Red Sea this month to bypass the Strait of Hormuz and ease domestic supply pressures, CPC Corp, Taiwan (CPC, 台灣中油) said yesterday. The state-run oil company has worked with Middle Eastern suppliers to secure routes other than the Strait of Hormuz, through which about 20 percent of the world’s oil and liquefied natural gas typically passes, CPC chairman Fang Jeng-zen (方振仁) said at a meeting of the legislature’s Economics Committee in Taipei. Suppliers in Saudi Arabia have indicated they
A global survey showed that 60 percent of Taiwanese had attained higher education, second only to Canada, the Ministry of the Interior said. Taiwan easily surpassed the global average of 43 percent and ranked ahead of major economies, including Japan, South Korea and the US, data from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) for 2024 showed. Taiwan has a high literacy rate, data released by the ministry showed. As of the end of last year, Taiwan had 20.617 million people aged 15 or older, accounting for 88.5 percent of the total population, with a literacy rate of 99.4 percent, the data
CCP ‘PAWN’? Beijing could use the KMT chairwoman’s visit to signal to the world that many people in Taiwan support the ‘one China’ principle, an academic said Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Chairwoman Cheng Li-wun (鄭麗文) yesterday arrived in China for a “peace” mission and potential meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平), while a Taiwanese minister detailed the number of Chinese warships currently deployed around the nation. Cheng is visiting at a time of increased Chinese military pressure on Taiwan, as the opposition-dominated Legislative Yuan stalls a government plan for US$40 billion in extra defense spending. Speaking to reporters before going to the airport, Cheng said she was going on a “historic journey for peace,” but added that some people felt uneasy about her trip. “If you truly love Taiwan,
NEW LOW: The council in 2024 based predictions on a pessimistic estimate for the nation’s total fertility rate of 0.84, but last year that rate was 0.69, 17 percent lower An expected National Development Council (NDC) report expects the nation’s population to drop below 12 million by 2065, with the old-age dependency ratio to top 100 percent sooner than 2070, sources said yesterday. The council is slated to release its latest population projections in August, using an ultra-low fertility model, the sources said. The previous report projected that Taiwan’s population would fall to 14.37 million by 2070, but based on a new estimate of the total fertility rate (TFR) — the average number of children born to a woman over her lifetime — the population is expected to reach 12 million by
RSS