The Taipei High Administrative Court on Thursday ruled in favor of the Taichung Environmental Protection Bureau in its administrative litigation against the Ministry of Environment for the rescission of a NT$18 million fine (US$609,570) imposed by the bureau on the Taichung Power Plant in 2019 for alleged excess coal power generation.
The bureau in November 2019 revised what it said was a “slip of the pen” in the text of the operating permit granted to the plant — which is run by Taiwan Power Co (Taipower) — in October 2017.
The permit originally read: “reduce coal use by 40 percent from Jan. 26, 2020,” and was changed to: “reduce coal use by 40 percent before Jan. 26, 2020.”
Photo: Taipei Times
The bureau on Nov. 29, 2019, sent personnel to inspect the plant and fined it NT$3 million for failing to achieve the coal reduction goal in the revised permit provisions. It again fined the plant NT$6 million on Dec. 14, 2019, for failing to make improvements, which contravened the Air Pollution Control Act (空氣污染防制法). On Dec. 23, 2019, it gave the plant a third fine, NT$9 million, and revoked its permit on Jan. 1, 2020, for the same reason.
The bureau then filed administrative litigation against the ministry to cancel the rescission of penalties given to the plant.
Taipower on Thursday said the court ruled that the rescission be canceled, as it believes the Taichung City Government’s alleged misconduct should be addressed by the Executive Yuan, in accordance with the Local Government Act (地方制度法), instead of by the ministry.
That does not mean the court considered the bureau’s conduct legitimate, it added.
The ruling also said that the bureau’s request to invalidate the rescission of the penalties was “groundless,” which indicated that the penalties might not be lawful, Taipower said.
The Executive Yuan rescinded the penalties in November 2021, in accordance with the Local Government Act, and the rescission would not be affected by the ruling, it said.
The No. 2 and No. 3 generators at the plant would continue to operate to ensure a stable power supply, Taipower added.
The ministry on Thursday said that it respects the ruling, but would seek an appeal.
The city government arbitrarily revised the text and required Taipower to achieve the coal reduction goal within two months, which went against the principle of legitimate expectations and would undermine the permit licensing procedure, the ministry said.
The ministry was obligated to interfere as a supervisor of the bureau’s air pollution control operations, it said.
Taichung Mayor Lu Shiow-yen (盧秀燕) yesterday said that it would be unreasonable for the ministry to appeal the case, as the bureau imposed the penalties to safeguard Taichung residents’ health.
“It is OK that the ministry made a mistake, and it should have admitted it,” she said.
Additional reporting by Huang Hsu-lei
SHIPS, TRAINS AND AUTOMOBILES: The ministry has announced changes to varied transportation industries taking effect soon, with a number of effects for passengers Beginning next month, the post office is canceling signature upon delivery and written inquiry services for international registered small packets in accordance with the new policy of the Universal Postal Union, the Ministry of Transportation and Communications said yesterday. The new policy does not apply to packets that are to be delivered to China, the ministry said. Senders of international registered small packets would receive a NT$10 rebate on postage if the packets are sent from Jan. 1 to March 31, it added. The ministry said that three other policies are also scheduled to take effect next month. International cruise ship operators
HORROR STORIES: One victim recounted not realizing they had been stabbed and seeing people bleeding, while another recalled breaking down in tears after fleeing A man on Friday died after he tried to fight the knife-wielding suspect who went on a stabbing spree near two of Taipei’s busiest metro stations, Taipei Mayor Chiang Wan-an (蔣萬安) said. The 57-year-old man, identified by his family name, Yu (余), encountered the suspect at Exit M7 of Taipei Main Station and immediately tried to stop him, but was fatally wounded and later died, Chiang said, calling the incident “heartbreaking.” Yu’s family would receive at least NT$5 million (US$158,584) in compensation through the Taipei Rapid Transit Corp’s (TRTC) insurance coverage, he said after convening an emergency security response meeting yesterday morning. National
PLANNED: The suspect visited the crime scene before the killings, seeking information on how to access the roof, and had extensively researched a 2014 stabbing incident The suspect in a stabbing attack that killed three people and injured 11 in Taipei on Friday had planned the assault and set fires at other locations earlier in the day, law enforcement officials said yesterday. National Police Agency (NPA) Director-General Chang Jung-hsin (張榮興) said the suspect, a 27-year-old man named Chang Wen (張文), began the attacks at 3:40pm, first setting off smoke bombs on a road, damaging cars and motorbikes. Earlier, Chang Wen set fire to a rental room where he was staying on Gongyuan Road in Zhongzheng District (中正), Chang Jung-hsin said. The suspect later threw smoke grenades near two exits
The Forestry and Nature Conservation Agency yesterday launched a gift box to market honey “certified by a Formosan black bear” in appreciation of a beekeeper’s amicable interaction with a honey-thieving bear. Beekeeper Chih Ming-chen (池明鎮) in January inspected his bee farm in Hualien County’s Jhuosi Township (卓溪) and found that more than 20 beehives had been destroyed and many hives were eaten, with bear droppings and paw prints near the destroyed hives, the agency said. Chih returned to the farm to move the remaining beehives away that evening when he encountered a Formosan black bear only 20m away, the agency said. The bear
RSS