The Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) yesterday held a press conference showing how the Special Investigation Division (SID) wiretapped the party’s caucus whip Ker Chien-ming (柯建銘), and also revealed that it had inadvertently wiretapped the daughter and husband of High Prosecutors’ Office Prosecutor Lin Shiow-tao (林秀濤).
Party legislators unanimously blasted the division for overreach and acting above and beyond the parameters of its given powers.
On Aug. 31 SID Prosecutor-General Huang Shih-ming (黃世銘) informed President Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九) of alleged lobbying involving Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Wang Jin-pyng (王金平), Ker, former minister of justice Tseng Yung-fu (曾勇夫), High Prosecutors’ Office Head Prosecutor Chen Shou-huang (陳守煌) and Lin.
Photo: Taipei Times
During the wiretapping of Lin, the division found that the telephone they believed to be Lin’s was actually used by her daughter, and had quickly terminated the wiretapping before applying for another wiretap approval for the telephone Lin was using, the division said on Wednesday.
The SID said that the telephone used by Lin’s daughter was tapped for less than a week.
Huang’s admission on Wednesday that the division had tapped Lin’s telephone sparked heated debate among legal experts and also drew fire from DPP Chairman Su Tseng-chang (蘇貞昌).
Photo: Liu Hsin-de, Taipei Times
That a junior-high school student was placed under wiretap and surveillance is a great setback to the democratic values Taiwan holds dear, Su said, adding that Huang should step down as prosecutor-general and be investigated.
Su called on Ma to take responsibility and explain the situation.
DPP legislators also lambasted the division, with Kuan Bi-ling (管碧玲) saying that no one really knew how many wiretaps had been carried out, adding that the lack of knowledge was terrifying.
Kuan said that all her data had been provided by the division, and that the documents received on Sept. 17 had showed a total of only 28 wiretap approvals, six of which were related to Ker’s case. She added that after Huang’s admission on Wednesday that the division had also wiretapped Lin, two new cases were revealed.
Kuan also pointed to the four wiretap approvals that were to be sent to Ker provided by Huang and said they were only vaguely connected to Ker.
The approvals had been used to wiretap former KMT Tainan City councilor Wu Chien-pao (吳健保), Ker, Lin’s husband, and Wu’s lawyer Tu Ying-ta (杜英達). Wu was jailed for profiteering in 2006.
Aside from being accused of lobbying Wang to influence Tseng, Chen, and Lin to relieve legal pressure from himself, Ker was sentenced to six months in jail for violating the Business Accounting Act (商業會計法) in 1997 when he was general manager of Formosa Telecom Investment Co (全民電通). The court allowed the sentence to be commuted to a fine. The ruling was appealed twice. A retrial at the Taiwan High Court found Ker not guilty.
Kuan said the latest evidence indicated that Ker’s wiretap had been approved because he was potentially involved in the bailing of Wu. This was tied to a bribery case in 2010 in which Taiwan High Court judges Chen Jun-ho (陳榮和), Lee Chun-ta (李春他), Tsai Kuang-chih (蔡光志), and Banciao District Prosecutor Office prosecutor Chiu Mao-jung (邱茂榮) had taken bribes to rule former KMT Legislator Ho Chih-hui (何智輝) not guilty in a graft case.
Kuan lambasted that the division had been using the 2011 SID case No. 61 (一百年特他字第六十一號), which had been filed to wiretap all possible suspects in the judges bribery case in 2010, as a ploy to use the judiciary system’s shame that its members had been embroiled in bribery cases to ask for wiretap warrants, adding a call for the division to provide the data for every case that had been wiretapped by warrants applied for under No. 61.
DPP Legislator You Meinu (尤美女) also said that only cases that merited at least three years of imprisonment as a sentence, but the intentions for committing the crime and evidence linking the crime and the perpetrator could not be found outside of wiretapping could apply for wiretaps.
The four wiretap approval notices provided by Huang showed that lobbying itself was not an element necessitating wiretapping, You said.
DPP Legislator Wu Yi-chen (吳宜臻) also called for the division to bring out all the evidence, while Yao Pasuya (姚文智) also called for Huang to step down.
Additional reporting by Lee Hsin-fang.
INCURSION: After 13 PLA aircraft flew into Taiwan’s ADIZ, the US Department of State said that China should rather ‘engage in meaningful dialogue’ with Taiwan US President Joe Biden’s administration on Saturday urged China to stop placing military pressure on Taiwan, while calling on both sides of the Taiwan Strait to engage in peaceful dialogue. The statement by the US Department of State was issued after 13 Chinese military aircraft flew into Taiwan’s southwest air defense identification zone (ADIZ) on Saturday, the highest number observed in a single day this year, the Ministry of National Defense said. The air force scrambled fighter jets to monitor the Chinese aircraft, issuing radio warnings and mobilizing air defense assets until the planes left the ADIZ. The US “notes
‘INCREASED VIGILANCE’: A source of infection has not yet been found for the latest two cases in a hospital cluster, which should serve as a warning, Chen Shih-chung said A total of 2,991 people associated with a COVID-19 cluster infection at Taoyuan General Hospital have been put under home isolation, after an emergency expanded isolation order was issued on Sunday evening, the Central Epidemic Command Center (CECC) said yesterday. Fifteen people have so far tested positive in the cluster infection. The first case in the cluster (case No. 838) was reported on Jan. 12 — a doctor who treated an infected patient who had returned from the US. Contact tracing for the first 13 cases found connections to case No. 838, said Minister of Health and Welfare Chen Shih-chung (陳時中), who
FAMILY UNIT: The CECC warned that the eldest sister of the latest case, who also has COVID-19, visited Taoyuan’s Chungping evening market on Tuesday and Wednesday The Central Epidemic Command Center (CECC) yesterday reported a domestic case of COVID-19, associated with a recent cluster infection at Taoyuan General Hospital, and two imported cases. Minister of Health and Welfare Chen Shih-chung (陳時中), who heads the center, said that the latest case (No. 885) is a woman in her 50s, who is the third daughter of case No. 881, a man in his 90s. The woman is the main caregiver of her elderly father, who had been hospitalized earlier this month and was treated by a nurse (case No. 852) from Monday to Thursday last week, he said, adding that
DUBIOUS HONOR? A man in his 90s, who tested positive yesterday and is part of the Taoyuan hospital cluster, is the oldest person in Taiwan to have contracted COVID-19 Taiwan yesterday recorded six new imported cases of COVID-19 and two new domestic cases, the Central Epidemic Command Center (CECC) said, adding that the local infections are linked to the cluster at Taoyuan General Hospital, which now totals 12 cases. One of the domestic cases is a man in his 90s, who was treated earlier this month at Taoyuan General Hospital and tested negative for COVID-19 on Monday last week, four days before he was discharged, the center said in a statement. After one of the nurses on the ward was confirmed on Saturday last week to have contracted COVID-19, the