Sat, Sep 03, 2011 - Page 1 News List

Diaoyutais belong to ‘China’: official

PRIZED PROPERTY:A group of Taiwanese and Chinese academics at a forum rejected Japan’s claims to the islands, with an official suggesting calling for world arbitration

By Shih Hsiu-chuan  /  Staff Reporter

The controversy over the disputed Diaoyutai Islands (釣魚台) should be viewed from an historical perspective and as an act of invasion by Japan against Chinese territory rather than an issue related to political and economic interests, a government official said yesterday.

“In the eyes of the people of China, it was an incident that cannot be compartmentalized from the history of intrusion into China by Japan. Japan should look at the issue from this perspective,” said Shaw Yu-ming (邵玉銘), chairman of the Coordination Council of North American Affairs (CCNAA).

The CCNAA, the headquarters of the Taipei Economic and Cultural Representative Office in the US, was established as a counterpart to the American Institute in Taiwan (AIT) after the termination of diplomatic ties between the US and the Republic of China (ROC).

Addressing a forum on the Diaoyutais, Shaw suggested Japan and China utilize international arbitration to resolve the dispute over the islands because they are both UN members subject to the UN convention that calls for parties to to resolve territorial issues peacefully.

Judging from the tension between Japan and China surrounding the Diaoyutais in the past, “the issue may well become a flash point,” and therefore, bringing the issue to an international court would be the only way to prevent military conflicts between the two countries, he said.

In response to questions from the Taipei Times on whether his suggestion would leave Taiwan no say in the matter given that the country has no access to international courts, he said that was less important than the fact that the Diaoyutais are currently controlled and administered by Japan.

If the international court rules that the islands belong to China and not Japan, “it would be good for us because China would agree that Taiwan owns the Diaoyutai Islands,” as it did in 1871 when the islands belonged to the Kavalan Prefecture administration office, now Yilan County, which was then incorporated into Fujian Province during the Qing dynasty, he said.

Earlier at the forum, Wu Jinan (吳寄南), director and senior fellow of the Department of Japanese Studies at Shanghai Institutes for International Studies, Shaw Han-yi (紹漢儀), a research fellow at the Research Center for the International Legal Studies at National Chengchi University, as well as other Chinese and Taiwanese academics, presented papers to rebut Japan’s claims to sovereignty over the islands.

Examining related legal claims and historical evidence under international law and traditional East Asian order, the academics concluded that the Diaoyutais belong to “China.”

Asked to comment on the conclusion, Shaw Yu-ming said he did not find it problematic saying the islands belong to China as opposed to the ROC.

“Like I said, the Diaoyutai Islands were incorporated into the Kavalan Prefecture administration office in 1837. At that time, the ROC had not been established. Furthermore, the ROC is also part of China. China is the generic term for the ROC and the People’s Republic of China [PRC]. This case shows why the ‘1992 consensus’ is necessary. For us, it’s the ROC, and for the mainland, it’s the PRC. Together, it’s China,” he said.

Shaw Yu-ming said he agreed to the suggestion made by several Chinese academics at the forum that “China shall publicly declare its position that the Diaoyutai Islands belong to Taiwan.”

This story has been viewed 6147 times.

Comments will be moderated. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned.

TOP top