Shih Jun-ji (施俊吉), a commissioner in the Cabinet-level Fair Trade Commission (FTC), is probably one of the few officials who has dared to pinpoint what goes on behind the scenes in Taiwan's cable TV business -- that is, political manipulation.
"The problems with cable TV operations are due to the intricate relations between political and business circles," Shih said during a conference held by the Government Information Office (GIO) last week.
"If the law stipulated that neither KMT central standing committee members nor those of other parties could be involved in the cable business, the state of operations would be improved," Shih said, drawing applause from many of those attending the conference.
Shih's hopes, however, could be little more than wishful thinking since politicians employ a variety of means to manipulate the rules of the game in the cable TV market, according to insiders.
Legislators have admitted that some of their colleagues who have their own interests at stake in the highly lucrative market have interfered with the rule-making process for their own benefit.
"When the Legislative Yuan reviewed the amendment to the cable and broadcasting law in 1998, the intricate relationships between political and business circles made the process very chaotic," said KMT legislator Hung Hsiu-chu (洪秀柱).
DPP legislator Fan Hsun-lu (范巽綠) was even more direct, naming KMT legislator Wang Ling-lin (
According to Fan, Wang said that cable operators needed to control at least one-third of the market share to survive.
Wang is the chairman of Eastern Multimedia, one of Taiwan's largest cable TV operators.
Officials at the local level have also used their political connections to influence cable regulations, insiders said.
Following the 1998 amendment to the cable and broadcasting law, local governments were authorized to set subscription fee standards starting from 1999.
But many found that political forces were interfering with what critics said should be a "professional" fee-reviewing process.
Citing the experience of two of her colleagues, Liu Yu-li (
"I want to appeal to local councilors not to interfere [with the fee-reviewing process] by using political tactics," she said.
Worse yet, industry insiders said, is that big companies involved in monopolized cable TV market have distorted market mechanisms through unfair practices and then used their political influence to head off any official investigation.
The two big players in Taiwan's cable industry are Rebar Corporation's Eastern Multimedia (
Eastern, which is now headed by KMT legislator Wang Ling-lin, was founded under the leadership of his father, Wang Yu-tsung (王又曾). United was started by Koo Chen-fu (辜振甫), a senior KMT figure who also chairs the Straits Exchange Foundation. It is now run by his son, Koo Chih-yun (
The elder Koo and Wang are both members of the KMT's central standing committee.
In late 1998, the two conglomerates took steps to end their bitter rivalry and cooperate in dividing up the market. Since they not only own cable system operations but also channel distribution businesses, they have achieved a "horizontal and vertical" domination of the market that prevents fair competition, Fan said.
Citing statistics provided by independent cable TV operators, Fan said she suspected that the two groups had already exceeded the legal ceiling of one-third market share, adding that the GIO had turned a blind eye to the groups' monopolization of the industry.
But GIO officials have cited statistics indicating that the nominal market share controlled by the conglomerates does not violate the law. Among the 74 cable TV operators in Taiwan, 13 were run under the Eastern banner and another 12 under United, the statistics showed.
However, one GIO official who asked not to be named said the statistics were a product of the conglomerates' deceit.
Their trick, the official said, was to use the names of people who do not have direct connections with the conglomerate to open new companies.
Independent cable TV operators, meanwhile, have accused the two groups of having taken action that violated the Fair Trade Law.
The two groups are often united in offering a "genre" or "bouquet" of bundled channels to independent cable operators on a "take-it-or-leave-it" basis, alleged Frank Lai (賴文雄), secretary-general of a cable TV operators' association that mostly comprises independent operators.
Legislators and scholars have criticized the FTC for being too passive in investigating unfair business practices -- such as the two groups' bundling of channels -- in the cable TV market.
Shih denied that the FTC had failed to take any action, but admitted the existence of political intervention in the FTC's investigations. He said the FTC has levied fines of NT$27 million for violations of the Fair Trade Law in the cable TV market in the past two years. Eastern and United were among those fined, Shih said.
According to Shih, several cable TV companies under the Eastern banner were fined NT$7.5 million last year for their concerted efforts to raise prices. United was fined a total of NT$10 million last year for similar behavior.
Shih acknowledged that both conglomerates were able to engage in practices that were on the verge of violating the law because of their "good" connections within political circles.
To underscore his point, Shih mentioned how the Cabinet-level Committee of Administration Appeal overturned the FTC's decision to punish Eastern for engaging in illegal practices two years ago.
"I won't rule out the possibility that political interference affected the committee's decision," he said.
But Shih said he still believed that one of the best solutions for curing the ills in Taiwan's cable TV operations is to severely punish the wrongdoings that have distorted market transactions.
Critics say the remedy is to redesign the legal framework to increase competition in the market.
"Behind the dispute over Taiwan's cable TV operations is a problem that is economic in nature," said attorney Nigel Li (
Chuang Chuen-fa (莊春發), an economist at National Chunghsing University, said the government should work "to raise competition" in the cable market. Chuang said the government should consider amending the law to allow more competitors to enter the cable TV market.
"The government should show its determination to correct current practices in the cable TV market," he said.
South Korea has adjusted its electronic arrival card system to no longer list Taiwan as a part of China, a move that the Ministry of Foreign Affairs said would help facilitate exchanges between the two sides. South Korea previously listed “Taiwan” as “Taiwan (China)” in the drop-down menus of its online arrival card system, where people had to fill out where they came from and their next destination. The ministry had requested South Korea make a revision and said it would change South Korea’s name on Taiwan’s online immigration system from “Republic of Korea” to “Korea (South),” should the issue not be
Tainan, Taipei and New Taipei City recorded the highest fines nationwide for illegal accommodations in the first quarter of this year, with fines issued in the three cities each exceeding NT$7 million (US$220,639), Tourism Administration data showed. Among them, Taipei had the highest number of illegal short-term rental units, with 410. There were 3,280 legally registered hotels nationwide in the first quarter, down by 14 properties, or 0.43 percent, from a year earlier, likely indicating operators exiting the market, the agency said. However, the number of unregistered properties rose to 1,174, including 314 illegal hotels and 860 illegal short-term rental
Both sides of the Taiwan Strait share a political foundation based on the “1992 consensus” and opposition to Taiwanese independence, Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Chairwoman Cheng Li-wun (鄭麗文) today said during her meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平). Both sides of the Strait should plan and build institutionalized and sustainable mechanisms for dialogue and cooperation based on that foundation to make peaceful development across the Strait irreversible, she said. Peace is a shared moral value across the Strait, and both sides should move beyond political confrontation to seek institutionalized solutions to prevent war, she said. Mutually beneficial cross-strait relations are what the
ECONOMIC COERCION: Such actions are often inconsistently applied, sometimes resumed, and sometimes just halted, the Presidential Office spokeswoman said The government backs healthy and orderly cross-strait exchanges, but such arrangements should not be made with political conditions attached and never be used as leverage for political maneuvering or partisan agendas, Presidential Office spokeswoman Karen Kuo (郭雅慧) said yesterday. Kuo made the remarks after China earlier in the day announced 10 new “incentive measures” for Taiwan, following a landmark meeting between Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) and Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Chairwoman Cheng Li-wun (鄭麗文) in Beijing on Friday. The measures, unveiled by China’s Xinhua news agency, include plans to resume individual travel by residents of Shanghai and China’s Fujian
RSS